Written By: Lauren Long
Published August 9, 2021

“Our fate lives within us, you just have to be brave enough to see it.”
Merida, Brave, 2012
Brave’s Merida follows in the footsteps of her fellow princesses with the character traits of bravery, intelligence, and determination. On June 22, 2012, a sassy 16-year-old Scottish lass stormed her way onto the silver screen with Disney Pixar’s Brave. Princess Merida of the Clan Dunbroch is fiery, stubborn, fiercely independent, and as wild as her unruly red hair. Unlike Mulan, who stood with a foot on either side of the fence of tradition, Merida opposes tradition completely.
Merida really stands out from the early Disney princesses and even from the Renaissance princesses who were soft-spoken, ladylike, and demure. Merida is the total opposite of a bashful princess. She is rambunctious, loud, and has zero time or patience for romance or anything outside of her own self-interests. She only sings with her mother when she is a small child and never actually sings by herself, making her the first princess who doesn’t belt out a love or empowerment ballad. Brave is the first princess movie where none of the characters sing on screen. However, we get the full Scottish experience with kilts and bagpipes. This lively Celtic soundtrack consists of traditional bagpipes, Uillean pipes, Celtic harp, fiddle, percussion, and whistles. While Merida doesn’t sing on screen, her desire for freedom and free-spirited personality are reflected in the lyrics of “Touch the Sky.”
Unlike Pocahontas and Mulan, who committed selfless acts of bravery and heroism and thought their decisions through, Merida is impulsive, does not consider the consequences of her actions, and puts her needs above the needs of others. Her tongue is one step ahead of her brain, and she often thinks without speaking.
Out of all the princesses, I think Merida shares more similarities with Jasmine. Both of them are against the traditional arranged marriages they are born into; however, Jasmine is ready and wants to marry for love, while Merida wants to enjoy her freedom a while longer and choose her life partner against the wishes of her mother, Queen Elinor.
Brave and its heroine are a contradiction: the film embraces some of the ideas of past Disney princess films, such as marriage, tradition, and familial expectations. However, Merida is a diamond in the rough. She is a skilled horsewoman who does not strive for perfection but reluctantly performs the duties, responsibilities and expectations of a princess all the same. This unconventional princess allows the film to skilfully break away from past film ideals and carry on with Mulan’s challenge of breaking gender norms. For instance, King Fergus declares, “Princess or not, learning to fight is essential,” when Queen Elinor proclaims Merida should not have weapons because she’s a princess. This gender attitude change shows great progression as King Fergus encourages Merida’s skill with a bow and arrow as well as a sword. I applaud this character development in Merida, and like many young girls, I’ve always wanted to learn how to wield a sword since I first saw one in Mulan’s hands. I became an archer after being inspired by another princess, but that is a story for another time.
Brave is the first Disney princess movie that does not focus on romantic love; Merida doesn’t have a love interest by the end of the film, nor does she desire a romantic relationship. Brave’s primary focus is the mother and daughter relationship between Merida and Queen Elinor. At the start of the movie, Merida and Elinor have a playful and loving relationship. However, over time, Merida’s growing independence and pride on both their parts weaken their bond. Queen Elinor wants Merida to be a traditional princess and adhere to the expectations and traditions of her people, while Merida wants to change her fate without considering the consequences to her family clan. Merida’s selfishness echoes that of Ariel. Both of these princesses like to challenge themselves and share a disregard for rules. Merida is athletic and proves her strength and ability when she climbs the Queen’s tooth and drinks from the Fire Falls, which, according to Fergus, only the ancient Kings were brave enough to drink the fire.
The magical will o’wisps lead Merida to a witch, who gives her a spell in the form of a cake to change Elinor. Like Ariel and Cinderella before her, Merida seeks the magic of a witch to solve her problems, completely disregarding the potential consequences of this decision. “Fate be changed, look inside, mend the bond torn by pride,” is the verse the witch discloses to Merida to reverse the curse. The ill-fated curse is actually a blessing in disguise as Elinor begins to understand Merida’s true self and struggle for independence as they begin to reconnect. Elinor sees Merida’s skill with the sword, bow and arrow, as well as her knowledge and ability to hunt and provide food for them in the woods.
Merida demonstrates her capability to be a leader with her historical speech of a time when their clans were enemies but joined forces against invaders from the sea. “It was an alliance forged in bravery and friendship, and it lives to this day.” Merida makes her parents proud with this statement and reunites the clans once again. She shows newfound maturity by admitting her selfishness and taking responsibility for her actions. In this way, Merida and Mulan are alike as they both accept responsibility and recognize there are consequences for their actions. However, while Mulan’s actions were selfless, Merida’s were purely selfish.
Brave is the first film since Pocahontas to have a relationship between women as a storyline. Merida and Queen Elinor’s relationship is a loving yet tense one. Merida’s love for Elinor and Elinor’s acceptance of her free-spirited daughter is strong enough for the two women to work together to persuade the clans to let the young people choose their life partners, breaking the tradition of arranged marriage. It is Merida’s strong love for Elinor that turns her mother back into a human, and the mother-daughter duo learn to accept and appreciate each other’s beliefs and values, strengthening their bond. Merida reminds us, “Our fate lives within us, you only have to be brave enough to see it,” inspiring us to find the courage to choose the kind of life we wish to lead. Disney’s Frozen in 2013 also deals with fate as well as the power of love between family.