Written By: Lauren Long
Published: January 7, 2022

“Don’t make your life about the loss. Make it about the love.”
Tracy Deonn, LegendBorn
Before we dive into the next book review, I hope you all had a very Merry Christmas and Happy New Year! A new year means new beginnings, new milestones in life, and new adventures. This book took me on an adventure through the past and present, and I hope after reading this review, you’ll be intrigued and go on the adventure. Without further ado, let’s soar into LegendBorn.
Tracy Deonn’s LegendBorn is a gripping coming-of-age novel. I have the habit of reading the first few pages of a novel when I pick up a book in the bookstore to find out what the story is about and if it checks the boxes of reading the book cover to cover: relatable characters that are strong and vulnerable, a compelling plot, and a carry-on to be unpacked by the reader. If all three boxes are checked, the chances are pretty good I will be taking the book home with me. I didn’t find LegendBorn in the bookstore, it was given to me by a dear friend for my 30th birthday last August. I actually started writing this review before the Christmas holidays but I struggled with writing it because it handles sensitive topics that are prevalent in our world today. It wasn’t until I sat down with my friend who gave me the book and we talked about the story that my head cleared and I knew what I wanted to say. Okay, enough rambling. Allow me to introduce the protagonist and heroine of LegendBorn, Briana Matthews.
Briana Matthews, or Bree, is sixteen years old and has been accepted into UNC-Chapel Hill’s Early College Program in North Carolina. On her first night at the college, Bree and her best friend Alice attend an illegal party that is a student tradition before the first day of classes. At the party, Bree sees magic but Alice can’t see it, which is similar to Clary and Simon in Cassandra Clare’s The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones when Clary can see Jace, Alec and Isabelle at the Pandemonium club. Bree realizes that she has seen magic before: on the night that her mother died and she and her father were at the hospital. Bree is struggling with her mother’s death and feels guilt that the last words they said to each other were in anger.
The themes of guilt and loss are major in LegendBorn. After seeing the magic at the party and realizing she has seen it before, Bree becomes obsessed with finding out what really happened to her mother and why she saw magic at the hospital the night of her mother’s car accident. I think she does this as a form of closure and also as a way of making amends to her mother for the fight they had over Bree’s desire for more independence.
Bree applies for the Early College Program at UNC-Chapel Hill without telling her parents because she wants to surprise them with the news when she gets in. Unfortunately, it doesn’t go over well with her mother and the argument between the two opens the theme of the transition from youth to adulthood. Bree wants more independence and her mother is not ready to let her child go just yet, but Bree feels like she doesn’t have any breathing room. I think it’s pretty common when a teenager is making the transition from being a youth to a young adult that family members go through a bit of an adjustment period because suddenly the child that they remember is gone and in their place is a young man or woman who is starting to find their place in the world and as a result, the family members try to hang on even tighter which causes the young man or woman to lash out and seek more independence. I think that’s what happens to Bree’s mom, she realizes her little girl is growing up and she, the parent, is not ready for that to happen.
I love this book not only for the great storytelling and its great characters, I love it because it really makes you think about the history of our world past and present. In addition to the themes of loss and guilt and the transition from youth to adulthood, the themes of racism, overthrowing tradition and changing what’s always been there and the brutality shown to slaves in the deep South are chillingly prominent. Bree is African American, and through her eyes and her voice, we are given a very vivid picture of the trials and tribulations she faces. There are numerous images throughout the book that open your eyes to the open racism that Bree and her best friend Alice, who is Taiwanese American, face. One such image is when the two of them are being taken back to campus in a police car, and Bree paints a vivid picture of what it’s like to be African American and in a police car driven by a white officer, “I’m sixteen. I pay attention. I listen to the stories from uncles, cousins—hell, my own father—about police run-ins and stops. I see the videos online. Sitting in this car and thinking about those images makes my heart pound.” Pretty vivid imagery huh? As I write this I can feel my heart pounding and my hands are not quite sweating but close enough.
The theme of overthrowing tradition and what’s always been there is shown when Bree meets Nick Davis, a self-exiled LegendBorn, and becomes his page in the Round Table. Nick’s father is the current leader of the Round Table and expects his only son to follow in his footsteps, but Nick is reluctant to fulfill his destiny. He does so, however, to help Bree discover the truth about her mother. Selwyn Kane, or Sel, is the Kingsmage (Merlin, Order’s sorcerer) and bodyguard assigned to Nick for his protection, and the relationship between the two is a tense one. Sel is suspicious of Bree because she can see magic, leading him to believe she’s a demon in disguise, and when Nick saves Bree from a hellhound on campus, things get even tenser between the two boys. It reminds me of the moment in City of Bones when Clary is attacked by a Ravener demon and Jace saves her and brings her to the Institute, much to the displeasure of Alec because at that point they think she is a mundane, the term used for human beings who are unaware of the Shadow World. Likewise, Sel thinks Bree is an Onceborn (ordinary human) but there isn’t anything he can do to prove it.
Bree realizes just how difficult her quest for answers about her mother is going to be when she sees that she is the only person in the Order who is not White. She thinks about what it might cost her if she succeeds in an organization that was founded by men who could have legally owned her and wanted to, and this is another image that puts a chill in the bones because of how historically accurate it is. It’s also an image of her courage and her desire for the truth that allows her to take the first step in tearing down the tradition to build the foundation for something new. The Order is patriarchal and male-based, there are women in it but they are all White. Within the Order of the Round Table, there’s a separate group for women called The Order of the Rose: a women’s auxiliary founded when women weren’t allowed to be Pages, Squires, or Scions. Of course, the Order of the Rose is also tradition-bound and they believe that Bree is a servant because she’s African American. This is showcased when one of the Rose members tries to give Bree her umbrella to dry, and Scion Victoria Morgan, I wanted to slap her for saying this, openly insults Bree when she refers to her as “the year our Chapter welcomes its most diverse Page class.” Not at all subtle and an example of White entitlement.
So, the themes of racism and the rebellion against tradition are tied together, and the brutality shown to the slaves in the South are attached to these two themes. Bree’s father signs her up for counselling in the hopes that it will help her begin to process and come to terms with her grief over her mother’s death. He sets up a counselling schedule with Dr. Patricia Hartwood, one of the few African American counsellors on the website. At their first session, Dr. Hartwood says that the table they’re sitting at makes her sad, which causes Bree to take a closer look, and what she finds shocks her. The table’s stone slab is being raised by African Americans. Dr. Hartwood tells Bree that this table is the “Unsung Founders Memorial. Carolina’s way of acknowledging the enslaved and the servants who built this place.” This imagery really reminds me of the statue in the Ministry of Magic in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows because the muggles are holding the weight of witches and wizards. Dr. Hartwood knew Bree’s mother when they were at UNC together, and she aids in Bree’s search for answers about her mother when she asks Bree if she is a Wildcrafter like Bree’s mother was. Wildcraft is the branch of root craft Bree’s mother practiced, she could manipulate the energies found in growing things like plants, herbs, and trees. The craft flows from mother to daughter and is why Bree can see magic and mage flame. Up until this point, Bree doesn’t know her mother could use magic and realizes at the same time that a Merlin (sorcerer) knew about her mother.
At their next session, Patricia takes Bree to the cemetery near the school, where the segregation between races is demonstrated by a wall between the two sections. Patricia tells Bree that some of the African Americans buried here were enslaved and owned by the faculty and were kept on campus to help build and maintain the school. Almost all of the graves are unmarked. Patricia brings offerings so that the ancestors will share the root with their descendants, and Patricia and Bree are taken back in time, where Bree experiences the brutality shown to slaves firsthand. When I read this part, I felt like I was there too, I felt like I was standing in the room watching as Abby, a Black woman whose memory was chosen by Patricia’s ancestor Louisa, lay on the floor to have her back treated after she’d been whipped over an alleged tale of talking back to a white woman on the street. I share Bree’s disbelief, horror, and sickened anger that a human being did this to another person. We learn that the boy who whipped Abby and left her for dead has a monument on the quad. After two more memories, Bree is sent back to the present and she finds the statue of Carr, who is the one that carried out Abby’s whipping.
On her way back to campus, Bree finds Carr’s statue. Deonn describes the imagery of the perfect soldier posture to a tee: rifle in hand, straight spine, shoulders back, and an uplifted chin, however, he’s standing for a war that wasn’t won. This, coupled with Bree’s pain and horror at everything she witnessed in the past brings forth a sense of belonging when she sets her hands on the statues and pushes as she claims the bodies whose names the world wants to forget, the bodies whose names she was taught to forget and the unsung bloodlines that would claim and own her if they could. She sends the statue a message with this push.
Understandably, Bree is really hesitant and unsure of how to tell Nick what she saw in the cemetery because she’s afraid that he won’t understand. She’s afraid he wouldn’t understand because she knows he never would have been on the other end of the whip. I think it’s this realization that helps Bree to discover her branch of root craft, which gives her the ability to see the root in its raw form.
In addition to the enhanced sight to see things that other people can’t, Bree’s other powers include the powers of a Medium and a Blood-crafter. Bree is not who she thought she was, but her newfound knowledge of her own powers allows her to open the door and connect with her ancestors and discover her mother’s car accident was really just an accident. The climax of the book shows Bree her ancestor Vera’s life. Vera was enslaved on a Scion of Arthur’s plantation and through a poem-like sequence, Bree learns that Vera became pregnant by her master and used the root to help protect her and her unborn child. A rhythmic chant carries Bree through eight generations of women, right up to the night of her mother’s death when she learns that the police officer she saw glamoured that night was Sel’s mother. Sel’s mother tells Bree that she was friends with Bree’s mom.
By the end of the book, Sel has gotten over his animosity and suspicion of Bree, and the two of them have feelings for each other. It’s a complicated situation because Bree has feelings for Sel, but she also loves Nick. It reminds me of the love triangle between Will Herondale, Jem Carstairs, and Tessa Gray in Cassandra Clare’s The Infernal Devices. So not only does Bree now have a new life and abilities she has to come to terms with but two love interests as well. The question remains: who will Bree choose?
What do you think the message was that Bree sent the statue when she pushed against it?