Written By: Lauren Long
Published: January 14, 2022

“I may have lost her.” “Who?” “Myself.” . . . “You need to find her then.”
Bridget Vreeland and Tibby Rollins, The Second Summer of the Sisterhood, Ann Brashares
The Sisters of the Pants are back for another summer, but instead of only one of the girls staying home, there are three of them staying home, that is, until Bridget discovers letters to her and her twin brother from their maternal grandmother. Bridget learns that her dad has kept the letters from them because he does not get along with his mother-in-law. In their sixteenth summer, with the travelling pants by their side, Lena, Bridget, Tibby and Carmen meet new challenges, new heartbreak and make new discoveries.
Bridget is a very different person than the wild, unstoppable girl who attended soccer camp and fell head over heels for Eric. She has totally lost herself, she can’t outrun her demons and troubles so she makes every effort to change herself physically. She is no longer on the soccer team; gained 15 pounds over the winter and spring, and has tried to dye her hair dark, although that last one didn’t really turn out the way she wanted it to. She’s used a very dark shade of brown dye, but her blonde hair is so luminous and bright that it keeps peeking out from underneath the dark brown with which she has tried to conceal it. Before Bridget finds the letters from Greta, her grandmother, she’s more than happy to stay home for the summer and be with her friends, but as Lena describes it “Bridget has never met a plan she didn’t like to change,” and that’s exactly what she does when she finds the letters. She decides to go and visit her grandmother in Alabama, and I think she does this because not only does she want to re-establish a connection with her grandmother, but she also wants to find herself again and reconnect with herself, and sometimes the best way to do that is to leave home and get a fresh change of scenery somewhere else.
Last summer, Tibby was the one who stayed home while her friends left for the summer, but this summer she is going to Williamston College in Virginia for a summer film program. I felt a little bit more of a connection with Tibby in this book than I did in the first one. I think Tibby meeting Bailey and having her eyes opened to the bigger picture of looking deeper than a person’s physical appearance was Bailey’s gift, her power of being able to look beneath the surface and see other people’s hearts. It’s why her death struck Tibby so hard. I think before Tibby met Bailey, she didn’t really let herself feel her emotions, you know, she stuffed them down and after spending time with Bailey and learning from her, it’s like Tibby got cracked open. When her parents drive her to Williamston College, the plan is for the three of them to have lunch together before Tibby’s parents go back to Washington. That plan changes when Alice, Tibby’s mother gets a phone call saying that Tibby’s younger brother Nicky got sick in swimming class and her parents have to cancel their lunch plan. Tibby brushes it off and studies the instruction booklet for the telephone system in her room so she doesn’t feel sad. Hmm, maybe she hasn’t learned to let herself feel. Not all the way at least.
For someone who didn’t allow herself to be open to the possibility of love and being loved by a boy because of her past experiences, Lena has done a complete 180. For the past year, she has spent a lot of time missing Kostos. She imagines that he is present wherever she is, and his imagined presence gives her perspective on her value as a person. I identify with Lena in this way because I have imagined the presence of people who are special to me.
Carmen, ugh, this part made me feel uncomfortable and mad at the same time. When I read these books as a kid I was touched by Carmen’s concern for Bridget in this book, but now I just feel really annoyed. It says Carmen subtly tries to pry introspection out of Bridget (how subtle can it be if Tibby can see that Carmen’s doing it?) but it never comes. This really bothers me; the protocol I use is if a person brings up something that is happening in their lives because they want to talk about it, that’s fine. That’s their boundary to set. If they don’t bring it up, I don’t either. I feel as though Carmen doesn’t really know how to adhere to and respect her friends’ boundaries.
Bridget’s choice to go to Alabama turns out to be the best thing for her. At first, she continues her self-protection by telling her grandmother that her name is Gilda, but eventually, she starts to shed her fake identity and regain her true self. She starts running again, she starts playing soccer again, and she lets the brown dye fade away for good, letting the natural beauty of her hair make its presence again. I said earlier that sometimes we need to leave home to find ourselves again, and Bridget not only finds that, but she also finds a home and the love of her grandmother waiting for her. Bridget gets the maternal love she has been missing since her mother died and she finds peace.
I think Tibby’s greatest challenge is her difficulty in being seen for who she really is. When she gets to Williamston College, she meets two kids, Alex and Maura, and I think subconsciously she’s drawn to them because they’re the way she was before she met Bailey, although Tibby isn’t as cruel and mocking as Alex and Maura are. She goes through that phase of laughing at whatever they say, even if it is mean and at someone else’s expense because she wants to fit in. She’s in a new environment, Bridget, Lena, and Carmen are not with her, and when you’re a teenager and around new people, all you want is to find a connection with someone and fit in. The video that Tibby makes of her mom is cruel, mean and shallow. Tibby herself says that she was firing mean and malicious shots at her mother with the movie, and she feels a deep sense of remorse and self-loathing when her mother sees the movie when she comes to surprise Tibby for the viewing for the halfway mark of the course. Have you ever been so consumed by negative emotions for someone that you set out to do something that will make you feel better but will hurt them, and then after you’ve done it you’re filled to the brim with anger and self-loathing and remorse. This is a really humbling moment for Tibby, she’s rightfully horrified with herself and this is when she learns the lesson of not letting her emotions get away from her so that her judgment and sense of rationale fly out the window. She makes a new movie featuring Bailey and redeems herself with this. She remembers the lessons that Bailey taught her, and it is this movie that helps Tibby to realize that she is a great filmmaker, that she has a little bit of Bailey’s power of being open to everything and everyone around her and seeing what’s really there underneath the surface. She can see it all and Alex and Maura are the unlucky ones because they haven’t learned the lesson of looking past a person’s outward appearance to see what lies beneath their skin.
Carmen’s challenge has two parts to it: she is dating this boy named Porter, but she is also contending with the fact that her mother Christina is also dating someone, a man named David who works at the same lawyer’s office as Christina. Carmen is an only child, and the previous summer she watched her father marry another woman. This summer she has to deal with her mother having a new relationship. Carmen is someone who does not like change and does not cope with it well, and there are numerous points throughout the book where she is a total brat. She wants a relationship with Porter but she doesn’t want her mom to be happy so she does numerous things to sabotage her mom’s relationship with David, and she acts like a child and throws a tantrum when her mother wears the Traveling Pants on a date with David. If you don’t want to share the pants with people other than your friends, Carmen, don’t leave them out on the kitchen counter. However, like Tibby, Carmen redeems herself by phoning David and asking him to take her mother out to dinner after she realizes that Christina deserves a new beginning too, just like how Carmen’s father Al found a new beginning with Lydia and her two children Krista and Paul.
For Lena, my soul sister, not only does Kostos come back into her life but she also discovers a long-kept secret of her mother’s by accident. Lena learns from Tibby’s mom that her mother, Ari, was with a man called Eugene before she met Lena and Effie’s father. Lena’s desire to find out who Eugene is and her mother’s story with him causes a rift between the two of them that isn’t mended until the end of the summer.
I was mistaken, Lena has three major things that happen to her in this book: she finds out about her mother’s past relationship with Eugene, reignites her relationship with Kostos, and she loses her grandfather. As I referenced earlier, Lena has spent the past year thinking about and missing Kostos. He surprises her by coming to her house while he is working in New York and the two begin to see each other again. Lena is the happiest she’s been and it is implied that she and Kostos, they don’t have sex, begin being a little sexually intimate with each other. Kostos knows that Lena is a virgin and he’s a gentleman, he doesn’t push her. Lena really surprised me when she asks Kostos “Do you think you could take a short break from being a gentleman and start again tomorrow?”. When I met her in the first book, I never thought she would say something like that. Lena is a very modest person, but I think her love for Kostos pushes her past her limits and encourages her to open up and share her heart and her feelings a little more. How I would love to have a love like that.
The bubble the two are living in bursts when Kostos unexpectedly has to go back to Greece. Have you ever heard that expression that bad things come in threes? Kostos knows the reason he has to go back to Greece, but he chooses not to share it with Lena. Almost immediately after he leaves, Lena and Effie’s grandfather has a massive stroke and he passes away before Lena and her family arrive in Greece. At the funeral, oh boy, this is really hard to write, Lena sees Kostos and she’s excited to see him despite the tragic circumstances, but she’s brought crashing down to earth when she discovers he’s married. A little while later, he tells her that his wife, Mariana, is pregnant and that he is trying to be a good man, an honourable man. The island where he and Lena’s grandparents live is a very old-fashioned, traditional place, and he tells her this and that marrying a woman who is with your child is what a gentleman does in this place, even if you do not love them.
Poor Lena and poor Kostos. They finally get together after a year apart and after writing letters, although that stopped because the long distance was hard on both of them, and now they are apart and will live their lives without each other. It’s almost like Romeo and Juliet in a way, two people who want to be together but fate keeps placing obstacles and walls in their way.
Lena gets hit with a double dose of grief and heartbreak from her grandfather’s passing and Kostos unexpected marriage, and she spends the day in bed. She’s lost two people who are incredibly special to her, and anyone who has lost a well-beloved family member or friend or partner or has gone through a really tough breakup knows that you don’t want to get out of bed. You don’t want to eat, you don’t want to shower, you don’t want to do anything when it feels like your heart has both been ripped from your chest and been scrubbed with sandpaper until it’s raw and beats painfully against your ribcage. It is Lena’s heartbreak over Kostos that brings her and her mother back together. Her mom climbs into bed with her and finally tells her the story of Eugene, and tells her daughter that her heartbreak over Eugene was the best thing to happen to her because she got the life and marriage with Lena’s father that she deserved. I think this is a really good piece of advice to remember; that heartbreak over an ended romantic relationship may seem huge and all-consuming at the time and you think you’re never going to fall in love again, but as time goes on and you grow more into the person you were always meant to be you realize that those previous heartbreaks that crushed you opened the doors to something better and the person you’re meant to spend your life with will come along when you least expect it. My aunt once said something similar to me, after I expressed my heartbreak over a guy I’d had a crush on, she comforted me and told me “Your time will come my dear and it will be worth the wait for the right man who truly knows how to treat you like a princess. Never settle for less than that as you deserve the very best.” Those words have always stuck with me and they remind me that he is out there. I know he is.
At the end of the book, the girls come together, their lives have changed once again. They’ve gained and lost, but the friendship these four girls have with each other remains strong. Bridget has learned that no matter how hard we might try, we can’t outrun ourselves, our true selves always catch up with us in the end. Tibby has learned what it means to consider the feelings of others and how her relationships with them are impacted by her choices. Carmen has learned that no matter who comes into her parents’ lives, her parents will both always love her. And Lena? She has learned how to love, but also how to need. She’s learned it’s okay to not be the strong one all the time, that she’s allowed to fall apart every now and then, because her friends and her family, the people who love her the most, will always be there to be whatever she needs. Best of all, their mothers, who fell out of touch and fell out with each other around the time Marly, Bridget’s mom, passed away, have apologized to each other and resumed their friendship, after so many sad and bitter years apart. Remember how I said the friendship between Bridget, Carmen, Lena, and Tibby was one to be inspired by? Well, I think their moms were inspired by their daughters’ friendship and realized that they missed the friendship that was formed in a prenatal aerobics class. We all make mistakes and burn bridges, but sometimes life and fate offer us the chance to make amends and build those bridges again. They won’t be the same, they’ll be better.