Written By: Lauren Long
Published: January 26, 2022

“Whatever happens, we will find each other. We always will.”
Bridget Vreeland, Girls in Pants: The Third Summer of the Sisterhood, Ann Brashares
Girls in Pants marks the end of high school and the beginning of adulthood for Tibby, Carmen, Lena and Bridget. The girls each meet new challenges in the forms of family drama, changing relationships, and a ghost from their first summer with the pants. As their third summer with the pants unfolds, new voices join their lives and old voices return.
Tibby’s relationship with Brian has evolved throughout the last two books. They went from being strangers to friends, and Bailey’s death was a turning point in their relationship because when you share something like a death in the family or the death of a close friend with someone, it bonds the two of you. Now, two years later, Tibby’s relationship with Brian is changing from platonic to more romantic. Brian is already at the point where he knows he has deep feelings for Tibby, as is shown when he shows up at her house the night of the graduation dance with flowers for Tibby and chocolates for the family. Tibby is a little slower in getting to the same place as Brian with her feelings for him. Remember, this is the girl who has trouble acknowledging her emotions and sharing them, and Tibby knows that once she acknowledges she has feelings for Brian that it is out there, and I think that scares her.
Lena has her own drama to deal with at home. Her grandmother, Valia, has come from Greece to live with them at the insistence and forcefulness of her son, George. Valia is miserable and in turn, her son, daughter-in-law, and granddaughters are all miserable. Lena and Effie both got jobs before the summer started so that they wouldn’t have to be home all the time. It’s a hard thing when you lose a family member and their spouse comes to stay with you and your family and suddenly your routine and your home life has been turned on their head. It is even harder when you’re trying to move through your own grief and pain at the loss of a beloved grandparent or other family member and their spouse is lashing out at everyone because of their own hurt, pain and anger. It definitely doesn’t make a shared living space any easier, nor does hearing about the same things over and over again. Lena experiences this as her grandmother constantly bombards her with news about Kostos. I really felt for Lena here; when you’re trying to get over someone because you know that they’re in a relationship or marriage, being told of the things they are doing with someone else that you hoped you would get to experience with them and their current marital status is thrown at you is really hard. I get that Valia is as hurt and disappointed as Lena is at Kostos’ marrying another woman, but jeez, would it kill her to show some discretion and compassion towards her granddaughter? How can she not see that her constant need to share what Kostos is doing is affecting Lena? What exactly is she trying to accomplish by telling Lena about Kostos and what he’s doing? I have to admit, if it was me in Lena’s place, I probably would have exploded and told Valia to stop, and there was a small part of me that was waiting for Lena to tell her grandmother to back off, that if she wanted to hear about Kostos she would ask, but then I realized how out of character that would be for Lena. Kostos is the first boy to break Lena’s heart, and ironically enough he was the first person that she felt brave enough to wear her heart on her sleeve for. He was the first person that made her want to take a chance on love and take a chance on herself.
Carmen gets a summer job looking after Valia, and a chance meeting introduces her to Win Sawyer, a pre-med student at Tufts in Boston. This is the first time in the series that we see Carmen with a love interest, and Carmen is excited and experiencing that thrill of realizing that someone you like likes you back. However, Carmen struggles with showing Win her true self. He thinks she’s a good, selfless person because that’s what she’s letting him see, she hasn’t let him see her less than flattering qualities. She refers to the person that he sees as Good Carmen and the other part of herself as Bad Carmen. I think the greatest challenge for any of us, especially someone who is seventeen, almost eighteen, is to be seen for who we really are, good parts and bad. We all have good qualities and we all have less than flattering personality traits, and when we like someone, we hide the parts of ourselves that we know are unattractive. That’s what Carmen does with Win; she hides the fact she can be a total brat, that she’s resentful of her unborn sibling after discovering pre-natal vitamins while looking for her mother’s fake eyelashes, and that while she likes David, she’s insecure about him and how he affects Carmen’s relationship with her mother.
Bridget is at a soccer camp in Pennsylvania for the summer, but instead of being a player, she is a coach. She is the youngest coach at the camp, and she reunites with Diana, who she met in Baja in Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants. Diana is a coach as well and so is Eric, much to Bridget’s surprise. Bridget hasn’t seen Eric for two years and she didn’t know he was going to be at the camp. Life has a funny way of bringing people we’ve met previously back into our lives when we least expect it, and that’s exactly what happens to Bridget.
After a little awkwardness between the two, Bridget and Eric become friends. Eric joins Diana and Bridget for dinner, the two of them spend time together outside of chaperoning afternoon activities and the dining hall, and Eric sometimes joins Bridget for her evening runs. Bridget knows she still loves Eric, but she respects that he has a girlfriend and is happy to be his friend. She just loves that she gets to spend time with him. Of course, history repeats itself in an ironic twist of fate. One of the players on Bridget’s team is infatuated with her, and his infatuation with Bridget reminds her of how she behaved around Eric the summer they met. How she would flirt and show off and not really give him any breathing space. She didn’t care about the rules then, but she does now. It’s funny how when someone acts the same way to us that we acted around certain people it puts things into perspective, and Bridget is horrified and disgusted with herself that she acted this way around Eric when she was 15. Two years have passed, she’s grown up since then, and the fact that she realizes “hey, the way I acted around Eric when I was 15 was not okay,” shows great self-development and self-awareness. After a run with Jack Naughton, the infatuated player on Bridget’s team, where he confesses that he romantically likes her, Bridget has another moment of self-realization and she apologizes to Eric for the way she acted around him two summers ago. Bridget feels like it was all her, but Eric tells her that he couldn’t forget it, he couldn’t forget her, and that it wasn’t all her, that he wanted to be with her too. Because he was a coach and Bridget was a player, it was against the rules for them to be together romantically. Eric would have gotten into serious trouble had anyone found out, most likely would have lost his job as a coach and Bridget would have been kicked out of the soccer camp and not allowed to come back. Our hearts are tricky things, and more often than not we fall for people who are not good for us, or, in Bridget and Eric’s case, fall for each other at the wrong time and the wrong place. It’s hard when you feel a strong pull towards someone who is out of reach and you feel miserable because you like them and want to be with them, but you know that there would be consequences for the both of you if you were to act on your feelings and the two of you were discovered.
In the end, Eric ends his relationship with his girlfriend Kaya, because he knows that he feels something so much bigger and stronger for Bridget. He knows that they’re soulmates, and fate brought them together again because it was the right time. They’re both a little older, wiser, and are free to be together without worrying if they are going to get into trouble.
I feel sad for Tibby in this book because while she’s learning to let herself feel her emotions, she’s still very reluctant to show her true feelings, not just to Brian but to her family as well. I think that changes when her baby sister, Katherine falls out of Tibby’s window, which she left open to let some fresh air in. Katherine can see the apple tree in their yard from Tibby’s window, and it is her latest fantasy to climb the tree and pick the apples. Up until this point, Tibby has unfairly resented Katherine because her mother dumps the responsibility of babysitting in Tibby’s lap every time it’s convenient for her. Tibby feels guilty that she resents looking after her younger siblings, but her guilt increases when Katherine falls out of Tibby’s window. When Tibby is waiting for news of Katherine, she admits she hasn’t loved Katherine as she deserves. She wants a chance to do better, to love Katherine as she should have done from the start. The second moment in the book where Tibby is scared and worried and experiences how powerful love can be is when she is Christina’s unofficial birth coach. Carmen goes to find David so that he can be there for the birth, and asks Tibby to come so her mother is not alone. Tibby is terrified, of course, I think any 17-year-old would be, but when the moment comes for Christina to give birth, Tibby is a pillar of strength for her and helps Christina make the leap to push. There’s nothing quite like helping someone you love to bring a new life into the world, and Tibby is overwhelmed with love. This is the moment where she fully opens her heart to love and tells Brian that she has feelings for him too.
Besides trying to cope with her grandmother’s grief, anger, and bitterness, Lena faces another challenge when her father discovers she’s taking a figure drawing class with nude models. He completely freaks out and forbids her to go back because he’s old-fashioned and very, very strict. He’s become even more so in the year since his father passed, I remember in the second book that Lena’s father was very firm on the fact that she and Effie were not allowed to bring boys up to their rooms, he wouldn’t even allow their boy cousins to go upstairs.
Lena’s father is unsupportive of her going to art school, he doesn’t believe that it’s a good way to make an income. I can relate to this because I’ve had countless people tell me that being an author/writer isn’t a career, it’s a hobby. It’s a hard feeling when you want something so much, that you know in your heart this is what you’re meant to do, but external voices are telling you that they think they know what is best for you. This, coupled with the small voice of self-doubt and fear that seems to exist in our heads, can affect the paths our lives will take. Do we choose something safe, predictable, and will guarantee a steady income and a roof over our heads? Or do we choose to follow our hearts and go off the beaten path into the unknown? Lena, with the support and encouragement of her art teacher, Annik, follows her heart and takes on three more shifts at her waitressing job she despises (anyone who’s done this job knows how tough it can be) to come up with the deposit for RISD after her father tells her he and her mother won’t be paying for Lena to go to art school. Annik also encourages Lena to create a portfolio and apply for a scholarship to RISD, which Lena does. She makes sketches of her grandmother, her sister Effie, Carmen’s stepbrother Paul, and her parents.
I noticed that Ann Brashares has switched the point of parental conflict in Lena’s life. In the second book, Lena and her mother are at odds after Lena discovers her mother had a past relationship with a man named Eugene. In Girls in Pants, her conflict is with her father. While in the second book Lena’s father was not aware of the conflict between his wife and oldest daughter, Lena’s mother Ari is very aware of the conflict between Lena and her husband. I felt great sympathy for Ari because she’s caught in the middle. She wants to support her daughter because she can see that Lena’s heart is set on going to art school, but at the same time, she needs to stay united with her husband. It’s a fine line and a tough position to be in. How do you support your child without causing more conflict between them and your spouse and how do you stay connected to your spouse without breaking your child’s heart? How do you keep the peace between all three of you?
I’m going to be blunt about this because there’s no nice way to say it and I don’t see the point in sugarcoating it. Lena’s father George is a hypocrite. I say this because his parents expected him to follow in their footsteps and go into the restaurant business, but he became a lawyer instead, and they were disappointed at first but eventually came around. I don’t understand why George wouldn’t support his daughter and do the same to her that his parents did to him when he chose to pursue a career in law instead of the food industry. Why do we treat people the same way we’ve been treated, all the while knowing what it felt like when it was done to us. Why do we ignore and disregard the feelings of the person whose deepest wishes and dreams we are crushing? It’s not until Lena makes a drawing of her father and leaves it out in the open that he finally sees the mistakes he’s made, not just with Lena but also with his mother. Lena shows the strength of her gift when she’s able to look past the faces of her family and see what’s on the inside and reflect those in her drawings. That’s the challenge she sets herself, to see them and their emotions. She saves the hardest drawing for last, when she draws herself while looking in the mirror, and has a moment of self-realization. All this time, she’s been waiting for Kostos, hoping that he will come for her, even reading the letters he sent her over and over. She knows she loves him, but she also knows she needs to let go and move on with her life. He can’t set her free, only Lena herself can do that. That’s her realization as she looks in the mirror, she’s the one who holds the power to move on and fall in love again.
Finally, Carmen struggles with herself as she weighs the options of staying home and being a part of the baby’s life while going to the University of Maryland and going to Williams as she’s always planned. Carmen wants to go to Williams because that’s where her father went, and we learn that after Carmen got early acceptance into Williams in January, she stopped doing her homework. Not exactly the brightest move, you wouldn’t stop exercising because you’d lost the weight you wanted to lose, you have to keep working at it to maintain your body’s current level of health and fitness. Why would you stop doing your homework if you got accepted early into the college of your dreams? Sure, you don’t have to worry about being accepted anymore, but your grades for the last semester of your high school career still count for something. That’s my opinion anyway.
I feel as though Carmen’s parents know her better than she knows herself because when she decides to go to Williams after all, there are no problems, which makes her wonder if her dad never called Williams to withdraw his deposit and if he and her mother collaborated. After all, they knew there was a very high possibility that Carmen would decide to go to Williams after all. Parental intervention at its finest.
After seeing Carmen resent the baby so much, remember this is the girl who doesn’t like change, it was nice to see her start to come around and even consider changing her college plans so she could be at home. When we leave home for the first time, we’re always afraid things are going to change. And for the most part, things do change, but they also stay the same. When we come home for holidays or summer breaks, we find that we have changed. When I moved away from home to go to university I changed a lot in my first semester and continued to change and grow as a person during the four years of my undergraduate degree. While some things did change at home, some things stayed the same. I always knew home was there waiting when I needed it the most, and as I’ve gotten older, I’ve realized that no matter where we go or who we’re with, we always find a home in some way.
That’s a wrap on book three of the Sisterhood saga! We’ve got two more to go! As I go further and further into these books, I’m realizing things I didn’t before. Sometimes it takes writing about books that you’ve read and loved to have your eyes opened even further and go deeper into the story and the characters. Thanks for reading, until next time!