New “Friends,” Unexpected Challenges, Reconnecting with Family and Another Familiar Face in Ann Brashares’ Forever in Blue: The Fourth Summer of the Sisterhood

Written By: Lauren Long

Published: February 2, 2022

Photo by Ana on Pexels.com

“And so for a long time we sat and watched in silence because the seam was invisible and the color was eternity. And I thought about the color and I realized what blue it was. It was the soft and changeable, essential blue of a well-worn pair of pants.”

Bridget Vreeland, Forever in Blue: The Fourth Summer of the Sisterhood, Epilogue, Ann Brashares.

  It’s the fourth summer of the pants, and Carmen, Tibby, Bridget, and Lena have just finished their freshman year of college. The girls still love each other, but over the past year they’ve discovered keeping in touch isn’t as easy as they thought it would be. Between classes, family time and boyfriends, they all seem to just miss each other during the holidays. I think this book is a testament to that first year of college and being away from your family and friends for a longer time than just the summer. You start to find out who you are as a person in your first year at college. You’re done with the stereotypes and cliques and labels of high school, you’re finally free to be yourself. The sisters of the pants are lucky because they had each other through the tumultuous teenage years as well as the fact they all accept and love each other for who they truly are, good traits and bad.

   The story opens with the girls at Gilda’s on the night of their pants ritual. However, Carmen is not with them, and Lena, Bridget and Tibby don’t feel right doing the pants ritual without her because the ritual of the pants matters to Carmen a lot. It matters to the other three too but Carmen is the one who’s a sucker for ritual and ceremony. Carmen has really changed in the year since the girls last saw each other. I never realized until this book just how deeply connected Carmen was to her three pals, she’s terribly lonely and misses Bridget, Tibby and Lena very much. In the past three books, Carmen has, for the most part, felt good about herself and about her body, but now she’s feeling very self-conscious about her body. She’s not wearing the cute, flirty, vibrant clothes that reflect her personality anymore, she’s hiding behind sweatshirts even when it’s quite warm out.

    Have you ever been so desperately lonely and missed your friends so much that you befriend the first person who talks to you, only to find out later they’re a total fake and flake with a mean streak? Carmen experiences this when she meets and gets to know a girl named Julia Wyman. Ann Brashares does a really great job of showing how different Carmen’s relationship with Julia is from the one she has with the girls with who she’s been friends since birth. Whereas Carmen, Tibby, Bridget and Lena all love and support each other no matter what, Julia is the kind of person who has to tear other people down to feel good about herself. We’ve met people like Julia and when we’re used to having friends who are there for us no matter what, we don’t always see the true personality of the person we’ve befriended right away. Sometimes it takes their repeated small manipulations and mind games for us to see who they really are. This is exactly what happens to Carmen, after a failed attempt to befriend her roommate, she finds out she’s not very good at making friends because up until now she hasn’t had to. She’s slowly lost herself, there’s a shadow of the person she used to be still inside her but she has changed a lot. Carmen intentionally lets her relationship with Win disappear because “she didn’t know or like herself enough to be knowable or likable when she was with him.” I’m not going to lie, I was really disappointed when Win didn’t make an appearance in this book, I actually think he was very good for Carmen. On the other hand, you have to love and know yourself before you let someone into your heart romantically and platonically. People can tell when you don’t love yourself and you’re eager to please, and that causes them to take advantage of you. I relate to Carmen on this level because for a long time I didn’t love myself and I was too damn eager to please other people without thinking about the impact it was having on my emotional and mental health. From a very young age, I had the importance of working hard and achieving good grades drilled into me by teachers and select family members. Somewhere along the way, I missed the lesson about showing myself the same kindness and love I was showing to others. That’s a lesson I’ve started to learn in the last few years through counselling and pole dancing, an interesting combination but it’s true, and it’s a story for another blog post.

   I think Julia can see that Carmen doesn’t know or love herself enough, and that makes her easy prey for Julia. Hey, Carmen says herself that Julia is a snake, and snakes usually target vulnerable and easy targets. Carmen is more like Julia’s errand girl/servant than her actual friend. When Julia asks Carmen to come to the Village Summer Theatre Festival in Vermont, she plays a mind game with Carmen about a certain type of conditioner she said was on the list. Carmen checks the list after Julia goes to bed, there’s no conditioner. Julia feels threatened by Bridget when she sees a picture of Bee that Carmen has printed out. Julia is very doubtful that Bridget is friends with Carmen, but Carmen hasn’t really talked about her friends to Julia, only mentioned them in passing. After Julia makes the comment that Bridget should use a darker shade for her hair and Carmen says that Bridget doesn’t dye her hair, that that’s her natural colour, Carmen realizes that Julia feels threatened by Bridget and is competing with a girl she’s never even met. Insecure much, Julia? I think so. Isn’t it strange how we can feel threatened and intimidated by someone we’ve never met?

   Carmen starts to come back into herself when she auditions for The Winter’s Tale and gets the leading lady. It’s here that Julia’s true self really begins to come out. When she sees that Carmen is feeling happy and confident, Julia goes out of her way to sabotage that. She wants to keep her errand girl, I’m not even going to say that Julia is Carmen’s friend because she’s not worthy of that word, and she wants Carmen’s light to remain hidden. There are certain parts in the book where Julia displays abusive behaviour towards Carmen, such as answering for her when somebody congratulates Carmen on her audition and when Julia uses Carmen to get close to one of the lead actors in The Winter’s Tale. Julia is a striver, a social climber, any other word you can think of that describes a person who’s willing to push others down to get to where they want to go. I’ve never really thought about it until now, but as I sit here typing this review, I have a feeling that karma took care of Julia. Karma is a very real thing, if you treat people badly, the universe has a way of making sure you get exactly what you deserve. Your past actions always come back to haunt you. While Carmen has three friends and two parents who love her, and expanded family with step-parents in Lydia and David, step-siblings in Krista and Paul, and a half-brother in Ryan, Julia only has herself because of the way she treats people. I was cheering when Carmen finally stood up to Julia and told her where she could stick it. Carmen got her mojo back from doing the play and she remembered who she was.

  Bridget goes through something similar and yet at the same time different to Carmen, and like her friend, she shows self-awareness and self-growth that continues when she returns home.

    We see a little bit more of Bridget’s home and family life in this book. We got a glimpse of how broken it was and how much she and her father and brother have lost touch with each other in the second book, but in this one, it really comes to light. Before Bridget leaves for an archaeological dig in Turkey, she goes to ask her brother if he has a spare toothbrush, and it’s at this moment that she realizes just how isolated her brother has become. He’s taking time off school, he’s very reclusive and the only social interaction he has is through online interactive games. Bridget’s been gone at Brown for the last year and she didn’t spend Christmas with her dad and Perry so she hasn’t been home to see Perry’s reclusiveness. In just a few minutes, she sees it in the darkening of hair and the paleness of skin that looks like it’s gone ages without seeing the sunlight. Bridget becomes very worried that her brother has depression and will die just like their mother did, but when she tries to bring it up to her dad, he tells her that she lives her life the way she wants and to let her brother do the same. I don’t think he says this because he doesn’t care about his children, no, that isn’t it at all. I think deep down Bridget’s father is afraid he will lose one or both of his children to depression, he’s already lost his wife. Grief does strange things to people, sometimes it makes us withdraw from our family and loved ones, and that’s what has happened to Bridget’s father. He’s withdrawn from his children, who both still need him, even though they are young adults now.

   While Bridget is in Turkey, she immediately finds herself attracted to her archaeology professor, Peter. It’s a mutual attraction, and he has a wife and two young children. Bridget kisses him, and she immediately feels ashamed of the kiss and of herself after. Her shame and guilt increase when Peter’s wife and kids come to surprise him for his birthday. The guilt and shame Bridget feels help her realize that it is time to grow up and that she doesn’t want to be the person who breaks up a marriage. She knows that Peter will do the same thing again with another girl, but she refuses to be the person who lets her actions guide her with no remorse and no thought to who will be affected by her actions.

   After the kiss, Bridget feels as though she doesn’t have the right to Eric’s love, and I can’t help but wonder what would have happened if her mother had lived. Her father’s absence has really impacted her and her decisions at times in her life when she needs parental guidance. She hasn’t had anyone to show her what a healthy, loving relationship with someone outside of her family and friends looks like. Bridget feels like she’s not worthy of love because she is sorely missing the love she needs from her father and brother. She has the love of her friends and her grandmother, but that’s not the same as the love we receive from our parents and siblings. Bridget’s time in Turkey helps her realize that she can salvage and rebuild the relationships with her brother and father, and that’s exactly what she does. She goes home armed with the knowledge and lessons she learned in Turkey and begins to help her father and brother join the land of the living. The three of them make dinner together and Bridget turns the radio on to an oldies station, and she hears her dad sing along with two of the words from “Hey Jude.” It’s only two words, but it makes her happy. It made me really sad when I read that part because I could envision it in my head and I could see and hear what Bridget was experiencing. Eric comes to D.C. to see Bridget, and her father and brother make the effort to talk to him, even though they’re out of practice. I think it’s this moment when Bridget realizes everything is going to be okay and because of the effort she’s put in, her brother and her dad will start putting in an effort too, to make up for those lost years. They can never get them back or the time they lost, but they can move forward.  

   While Carmen learns the hard way that some friends are not true and Bridget learns how to reconnect with her family, Tibby learns what it means to be open and honest in a romantic relationship through trial and error.

     Tibby is spending the summer in New York taking film classes and working at Movieworld. Tibby and Brian have been together for almost a year, ever since the day she was Christina’s labour coach and Tibby and Brian went to the pool and swam after hours. That was when she confessed her feelings for him. Tibby was in a very vulnerable emotional place after being in the room when Christina gave birth, and the walls that she put up around her heart and her feelings for Brian came down because her emotional shell was cracked open. We learn that Brian has been wanting to take their relationship to a more physical level, but he’s been a gentleman and he respects Tibby when she says stop, he doesn’t push her. This is very valuable and important to include in the book because it teaches not only the importance of consent but also respecting the emotional and physical boundaries of your partner.

    When Brian comes to surprise Tibby for the weekend, they go out for dinner and then come back to her dorm room and drink wine. Tibby decides that she’s ready to take that next step, but the post-coital bliss they feel is shattered when they discover the condom has broken. This causes a great deal of stress for Tibby, even more so when her period is late. She freaks out and disappears into herself, closing herself off from her friends and Brian, her performance at work really suffers, so much so that her boss asks her to reduce her hours. I understand why Tibby panics, I would too, but what I don’t understand is why she doesn’t open up to her friends and Brian or even her mom. That would have been better for her, mentally, because when we talk to people about things that we are scared of or worried about what might happen, the people we love let us know that they’ve got our backs and are there to offer support. I can’t help but wonder if the reason Tibby doesn’t reach out to her friends at first is that they have grown apart slightly over the last year. True, Bridget is in Turkey and Carmen and Lena are busy with their respective summer activities, but I think either one of them would have stopped what they were doing to listen to Tibby and help her through it. Tibby does reach out to Lena; if I’m being honest, I would have chosen Lena as the person to help me through this, with the request to bring a pregnancy test. Tibby’s period comes right before Lena gets there, much to her relief. I think Tibby’s period was late because she was stressed, when our bodies internalize external and internal stressors, it affects us mentally and physically. Sadly, Tibby tells Brian that she thinks they need to take a break and he agrees even though he’s heartbroken.

   Tibby’s breakup with Brian causes complications when Effie, Lena’s sister, comes to New York to ask Tibby if she would mind if Effie goes out with Brian. Effie is revealed to have had a crush on Brian for a while, and Brian, being lonely and heartbroken over Tibby, goes out with her. Effie is his rebound, which is not fair to anyone. Whether it’s someone you know through a mutual connection or a complete stranger, using someone as a rebound is never a good way to get over a relationship, because it not only messes with that person’s emotions but it also screws around with your emotional and mental state, and that’s not good. For her part, Effie should have followed the protocol “you don’t date your friends’ exes.” True, she doesn’t have the same relationships with Bridget, Tibby, and Carmen that Lena does, but she had to know that her acting on her feelings for Brian after his breakup with Tibby would hurt all three of them. It doesn’t matter who you are, dating a friend’s ex or an ex of one of your sibling’s friends is never okay. This causes a rift between Lena and Effie; the latter being stuck between her love and loyalty for both her sister and one of her best friends.

    Lena is in Providence taking summer art classes, and she’s still thinking about Kostos. Lena’s story throughout the book is basically feeling stuck in a rut about her feelings for Kostos. She wants to move on, but there is that part of her that wonders what if. What would have happened had Kostos not gotten married? What would have happened if they’d stayed together no matter how hard the long-distance was? The questions go round and round in Lena’s head, and it’s when she meets Leo in her figure drawing class that the thoughts of Kostos start to fade a little. After she notices him for the first time, she asks Carmen if she thinks Lena is over Kostos, and Carmen wisely tells her that Lena will be officially over Kostos when she talks about and looks at someone else. That sounds about right, when we take notice of someone else, the feelings we felt for another person begin to fade. However, Carmen also says that she has a strange intuition that as soon as Lena forgets about Kostos, she’s going to see him again. And that’s exactly what happens. By the time Lena has embarked on a summer fling with Leo, starting with the two of them posing for each other for portfolio purposes and then going on dates, Kostos comes to the States to find Lena. He’s divorced now and he tells Lena that there never was a baby, that Mariana just wanted to marry him and she thought a baby would come in time. He still loves Lena, he’s never stopped, and he’s so hopeful that she will come back to him and they will finally be together that he buys her a ring, he makes all these arrangements to be near Lena while she’s finishing her degree, that he doesn’t stop to consider the possibility she may have moved on.

  I empathize with Lena in the fact that she’s angry with Kostos and his assumption that she would be waiting for him, that she hadn’t moved on, but I also feel sympathy for Kostos. To love someone that much, to pack up your things and check into a hotel because you’re so sure that you’re finally going to be together only to have it come crashing down around you in the face of their anger is heartbreaking. Lena tells Kostos he shouldn’t have come, she’s so angry at him that she says “was I supposed to rush into your arms?”. Ouch.

She tells him she has a boyfriend, which is a lie but she doesn’t care because she feels freed by the lie. I think she tells him this because she’s been held prisoner by her feelings and hopes of them being together for so long, and maybe because she wants to convince herself that she can move on. She’s never gotten angry at anyone like this before, and I believe it’s this, plus her attraction to Leo, that clouds her judgment and she loses her virginity to Leo after she goes to confront Kostos. However, while we can lie to ourselves and say that we are over someone, or that sleeping with someone else will help us to get over someone, we can never lie to our hearts. Lena’s heart scares her, and it is her dream-self that allows the sadness, the vulnerability, the truth that her waking self doesn’t. After she and Leo have sex, she goes home and she’s dazed and off-kilter, and she falls asleep only to wake up crying. Her heart has connected to her inner consciousness, something she didn’t allow while she was awake but has no control over when she’s sleeping, and what she realizes when she wakes with a tear-soaked face and hair is that she’s been waiting for Kostos, she always envisioned her first time being with him.

  It’s after this that Lena has her falling out with Effie, who is upset that Brian took Tibby back. Effie feels as though Lena is choosing Tibby over her, and maybe in a way Lena does choose Tibby because she knows that Tibby does love Brian and Brian didn’t stop loving Tibby. It was wrong of Brian to go out with Effie when he knew he was still in love with Tibby. The rift between Lena and Effie results in Effie stealing the travelling pants, wearing them on the ferry to Greece where they get wet, and when she puts them on the railing to dry, they are blown away by the wind.

   This event causes Lena, Tibby, Bridget and Carmen to really be together for the first time in a year when they go to Greece to find the pants, but it also brings Lena back into contact with Kostos. He finds out she’s there and they clear the air at the olive grove where they saw each other naked in the first book, and Lena wonders if they’ve really gotten over each other when it seems like they’ve gotten over themselves. She meets him one more time and they confess that while they’ve tried to love other people, they can’t. Kostos tells Lena “Someday” in Greek before they part ways, and the girls realize that they were using the pants to keep themselves apart. Their lives may be different now, but pants or no pants they are part of each other. They were a part of each other long before the Traveling Pants came into their lives.

   Phew! This book really takes you on an emotional rollercoaster, but Ann’s portrayal of her four heroines allows you to step into the pages and experience the triumphs, trials and tribulations right alongside the girls. We’ve got one book of this journey left, so if you’ve been here since the beginning of the Sisterhood journey, thank you for reading. Till next time, xoxoxo

Leave a Comment