Written By: Lauren Long
Published: February 5, 2022

We’re ready to move forward again in our way. Together or apart, no matter how far apart, we live in one another. We go on together.
Carmen Lowell, Sisterhood Everlasting, Epilogue, Ann Brashares.
Well, here we are. The fifth and final book in Ann Brashares Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants saga. Five books, four friends, and a magical pair of pants that saw them through first loves, heartbreaks, ever-changing family dynamics, and their love, support and acceptance of each other. Lena, Bridget, Tibby, and Carmen have always been each other’s cheerleaders, no matter how big or small the triumphs and tribulations. Ten years have passed since that fateful trip to Greece to look for their lost pants, and the girls have struggled to maintain their closeness through their busy lives. I think no matter who you are and how old you are, there’s that desire to sustain and keep that closeness you have with your friends. Whether we’re 10, 20, 30 years old, we want to hang on to that closeness we have with our friends, but more often than not, life gets busy and our lives and relationships constantly shift and change. This is a hard thing to accept, but the people with who we make an effort and make an effort with us in return stay in our lives.
Carmen, Bridget, Lena and Tibby are 29 years old now, they were 15, almost 16 when we met them in the first book. They’ve grown as people, gone to and graduated from university, and have taken their places in the world of adults. Before we step into the world of the Sisterhood one last time, I want to take a moment to say that this post may contain spoilers, so if you haven’t read this book, now’s a good time to stop reading.
The book starts with a prologue narrated by Carmen. Each book is written this way as a refresher of who the girls are and what their personality traits are. As I read the prologue, I realized I was similar to all the girls in different ways. I’ve said before I identify the most with Lena, but I can see a little bit of Bridget, Tibby and Carmen in myself too. Lena is the oldest one of the girls, the responsible and selfless one who knows how to take care of others.
Bridget is the true middle child who doesn’t care what others think and doesn’t know how to feel her own pain, but she can feel the pain of others around her. Now that I think about it, I used to be like Bridget. In the second way, not the first one. I could always kind of feel other peoples’ emotions, but I didn’t really know how to feel my own. Or maybe I did and I just didn’t want to feel them. Whenever someone was going through something, I would shut my own emotions off to help them, only to end up with a lot of unresolved emotions and trauma later on down the road. I’ve gotten better at not shutting my emotions off and letting myself feel what I’m feeling in the moment. I wish I could say I was like Bridget in the way she doesn’t care about what other people think, but I’m not. I have a bad lifelong habit of caring too much about what others think of me, and lifelong bad habits are very difficult to break when you’ve been that way for the last however many years. Caring too much about what others think, people-pleasing and making myself miserable in the process, and not having much in the way of boundaries are all things I’ve realized over the last two years and am working every day to change those things.
Bridget can also be reckless, I remember reading in the first book that a mental health professional wrote that when it comes to her goals, Bridget pursues them with a single-minded view to the point of recklessness. As soon as she sees something she wants, Bridget zeroes in on it and everything else is out of focus, she can only see her end goal and what she’s willing to do to get to that point. I don’t think I’m like Bridget in this way, I don’t feel like I’ve ever done anything reckless in my entire life. I’m more the kind of person who tries to think things through and think about the consequences of whatever choice I make. Do you ever make a pro-con list to help you make a decision? I’ve done that a few times and it usually helps me, but there has been the odd time when I’ve been left feeling more confused and turned upside down than I was before I made the list. I think Bridget’s recklessness and her tunnel vision to her goals are why she sometimes crashes on the rocks, and also plays a role in Lena, Tibby and Carmen realizing that Bridget needs help long before Bridget herself realizes it.
Tibby is described as the younger middle child, she’s the sly observer who has a gift for exposing the lies we tell to other people and to ourselves. I once heard Ashley Benson as Hanna Marin on Pretty Little Liars say “if you tell a lie to others often enough, eventually you start to believe it yourself.” I think, at some point, we’ve all told a lie to ourselves and to others instead of the truth because we don’t always want to acknowledge the truth. Sad but true. I’ve definitely lied to myself and to others instead of telling the truth because I didn’t want to deal with the truth. In hindsight, it would have been better, to tell the truth, and acknowledge it instead of living a lie.
Tibby is also described as cynical, judgmental, and devastating in her cleverness. I think that last one could go back to the whole exposing of the lies I mentioned in the paragraph above. In the dictionary, cynical is defined as “skeptical of or sneering at goodness, shameless in admitting unworthy motives.” A cynic is someone skeptical about people, motives, and actions. I identify with Tibby this way because I have definitely been cynical about certain people. I have trust issues from past experiences and when you’ve been hurt numerous times, that tends to change your perception of people and make it really difficult to let your guard down and let the people who genuinely do want to get to know you and befriend you in.
Judgmental is defined as “of or depending on judgment; tending to make moral or personal judgments.” Tibby says that she judges people too quickly and then finds out that she’s wrong about them. I try not to judge people because I know what it feels like to be judged on the way you look and what you like to do and the clothes you wear, but I’m sure I have judged people without realizing that I’m doing it. I’ve experienced judgments by family members that have really hurt me, and when you’re judged over and over by those same people, you take that inside and start to second-guess yourself and the voices of self-doubt and self-negativity grow louder in the words said by other people. “Am I good enough to do this?” “Should I be doing this?” “What if I get to where I want to be and then find that I can’t do it?” Ugh. The monsters of self-doubt, self-offence and self-negativity grow ever stronger with each judgment passed on us by people we don’t even know, friends, family, and ourselves. For very sensitive people, this can lead them to feel unstable, unsure of themselves, and more likely to go along with what other people say to them and do what others want them to do instead of what they want. I know this because I’ve done it.
Lastly, Tibby is described as someone with a sensitive heart. Her personality and sarcasm at times hide this in a hard casing. She hides the fact she has a sensitive heart because she doesn’t want to be hurt and she knows that there are people who would take advantage of her sensitivity and her good heart if she showed it. I’m like Tibby in the way my heart is sensitive, and I’ve paid the price for that a few too many times for my liking. I’ve been taken advantage of because, as I’ve been told by my family and my friends, I’m kind, and that makes me an easy target for people who prey on the kindness and compassion of others. I don’t always make good moral or personal judgments when it comes to people, my younger years at school can attest to that, but that’s something I’m trying to change.
Finally, Carmen is the youngest of these four women who have known each other since birth. Their moms connected while the girls were in utero, and the girls’ friendship blossomed and grew from babyhood to the toddler years, to girlhood and young adolescents, to womanhood. She is very open about the fact that she can be bratty and emotionally tempestuous, sometimes to the point of uncontrolled, turbulent, and violent anger, which we saw in the first book when she threw two rocks through the window at her dad’s new house. I have a bit of a temper myself, but it takes a lot to get me angry. Although, if my emotional reserves are low and I have nothing left, sometimes all it takes is a single word or action to send me downward. Depending on the day and my emotional state, I have a long fuse on some days and a shorter one on other days. Sometimes I don’t even realize how angry I am until something triggers that anger. So, I’m like Carmen in this way, we don’t realize how angry we are until something happens repeatedly to make us realize that the anger has been there all along, simmering and bubbling until it bursts forth like lava out of a volcano. Carmen didn’t realize how many years of anger she’d been holding in towards her dad until the summer he got married to another woman.
While Carmen can be turbulent and obnoxiously selfish at times, she is also very loyal. She’s loyal to her friends, family, and, as we saw with Julia in Forever in Blue, to those who don’t do anything to deserve it and don’t return her loyalty. I think loyalty is the same as respect and trust, if you want those things, you have to give them to get them. I’m like Carmen in the way that I’m loyal to my friends and family and the things that I believe in, but I’ve also made the mistake of showing and giving my loyalty to those who take it and don’t give anything back. The kinds of things you realize about yourself when you’re writing. As I read back over these paragraphs, I can see now there’s more of Bridget, Carmen and Tibby in me than I originally believed. I only saw the parts of myself that identified with Lena at first. Maybe that’s what writing reviews about the same four characters for five books does for you; your eyes are opened a little wider and your self-awareness grows more every time.
Bridget, Carmen and Lena are all excited when they receive plane tickets to Greece from Tibby, who moved to Australia two years before the events of the book. They’ve all been missing their friendship and the closeness they shared as children and then adolescents on the cusp of young adulthood. Carmen, Bridget and Lena arrive in Greece and wait for Tibby at the airport. When she doesn’t show, they make their way to Lena’s grandparents’ place. As more time passes, the girls grow increasingly worried. Lena calls the police and they show up at the house the next morning to say that a fishing boat found Tibby’s body. She went into the Caldera to swim and drowned. What should have been a happy reunion for the four friends has now turned tragic as they try to piece together what happened to their friend and go back home to the States with broken hearts.
Tibby’s unexpected death hits all the girls hard, but I feel as though Bridget is the one who takes Tibby’s death the hardest of all. Bridget lost her mom to suicide when she was really young, and she and Lena and Carmen all think that drowned intentionally. We learn before she goes to Greece that Bridget is living in San Francisco with Eric, and her old restlessness is coming into play. While she’s happy with Eric, she’s not happy in San Francisco.
Bridget doesn’t have a steady job or income; she takes temp jobs and she’s always looking for things in her and Eric’s apartment to give away. Tibby’s death pushes Bridget over the edge, she shuts down emotionally and she leaves her and Eric’s apartment while he’s sleeping. She sleeps on a park bench and she travels to Perry’s, her brother, place before leaving there and biking around. In Sacramento, Bridget discovers she’s pregnant and she’s shocked. It’s when she’s sitting on a beach, she hasn’t stopped moving since returning from Greece, that her anger and sadness at Tibby finally comes to a head. She screams and kicks at the sand and opens the envelope Tibby left for her. I guess I should backtrack a little, through their numbness and shock and grief at Tibby’s death, the girls find letters addressed to each of them. Bridget isn’t supposed to open her letter for two weeks, but in the storm of her anger and pain and sadness at having lost both her mother and Tibby, she is past the point of caring. After reading the letter, Bridget’s anger disappears to be replaced fully by sadness. She decides to go to Australia for answers and Eric helps her get the money to go.
I’m writing about Tibby after Bridget because their two stories are interlinked by Bridget’s decision to go to Australia and see Brian. When Bridget gets to Australia, she discovers that Brian and Tibby have a baby girl named Bailey, she is named after Bailey who Tibby met in the first book. While Bridget is helping Brian out by taking care of Bailey so he can work, she begins to take to the idea of becoming a mother. She sees Tibby in her daughter’s eyes and knows there’s no way she can leave Bailey when they return to the States.
It isn’t until they’ve arrived at the farm Tibby and Brian have bought in Pennsylvania that Bridget learns the truth about Tibby’s death. Tibby did not go into the ocean to kill herself, she had Huntington’s. Huntington’s disease is a rare terminal disease that progressively breaks down nerve cells in the brain. The symptoms of the disease can develop at any time but often appear in the 30s or 40s. There are medications to help manage the symptoms but treatments are unable to prevent the decline of physical, mental and behavioural health associated with Huntington’s. Tibby was afraid for her friends and family to see what was happening to her, and Brian tells Bridget that while he was worried about Tibby travelling to Greece, she was sure that she still had the strength to make the trip. She wanted her friends to remember her as she was before she was diagnosed with Huntington’s. How hard that must have been, for Brian and Tibby knowing that her life would never be the same, and for Bridget realizing that she, Carmen and Lena all had the wrong idea. She calls Eric and he comes to Pennsylvania, where Bridget finally tells him about her pregnancy and that she wants to keep the baby. They have an emotional reunion with Eric saying that a family with Bridget is what he’s always wanted.
On the farm, there are individual buildings for Bridget and Eric, Carmen, Lena and Kostos. Carmen is the next to arrive, with Lena and Kostos arriving shortly after.
While Carmen is a successful actress (I’m guessing the theatre festival in book four helped pave the way for her career) living in New York City, she’s not truly happy. Carmen has always been the one out of her four friends who read fashion magazines and tabloids, but she has learned that the entertainment industry is boring. I think we’re all enamoured with it because we’re seeing our favourite actors and actresses and singers/songwriters, and we see the beautiful clothes that they wear, and it is because of this we tend to ignore or pretend that the darker side of the entertainment industry doesn’t exist. I’ve never been interested in reading the tabloids or gossip sites because how many of the stories written in them are true? I’ve always said I would never write for those types of things because I don’t believe in writing stories that are designed to spread gossip and hurt people, I saw enough of that in high school, I don’t want to be responsible for damaging a complete stranger’s mental health. Because Carmen is now in the world where she’s in the public eye, she sees what she couldn’t see before: the manipulations, the coverage that has been bartered and bought, Botox, fake teeth, starvation and double-sided tape. Funny how when you’re on the other end, you realize it’s not so glamorous after all.
Carmen is engaged to Jones, an executive at ABC. Her friends do not like him, and on the other end of the spectrum are people who are always looking for connections in the business that can move them higher up. Which is a very sad reality. If I was in Carmen’s place and I had people sucking up to me because of who my fiancé was, I would be miserable. How do you know if someone is interacting with you because they genuinely like you and not because they think that you can use your connections to get them a better job? I didn’t like Jones to begin with, but my dislike for him became permanent when he wasn’t a supportive fiancé to Carmen after Tibby’s death and tells her that an audition for what could be a big breakthrough in her career is more important than going to Pennsylvania like Tibby asked her to.
Fate and circumstances cause Carmen to reconnect with the parts of herself that she lost while working in the entertainment industry. She befriends a young father and his two young children on the train to New Orleans, and it’s as she spends time with them that she remembers who she really is and how much she misses and needs Bridget and Lena. After her audition, Carmen goes home to New York, calls off her engagement and wedding to Jones, and moves out of their shared loft. She drives to Tibby and Brian’s place, where she meets Bailey and hears the whole story from Bridget and Brian. Lena and Kostos arrive next. I’m happy for Carmen because she’s left what would likely have been an unhappy marriage and she’s finally found where she feels at home.
In the ten years since Forever in Blue, Lena has accomplished a lot. She went to graduate school and was the only person to be offered a salaried teaching job at RISD after she finished her master’s degree and there’s a waitlist to get into her classes. She’s learned how to speak Greek fluently with the help of a woman named Eudoxia, and the two have a weekly coffee date. Eudoxia knows about Lena’s life, about her friends, about Kostos, and she talks about them to Lena as though she’s met them in person.
Throughout the five books, so much of Lena’s story revolves around Kostos. It’s been a will-they-won’t they situation, it’s been star-crossed lovers kept apart by fate, and throughout all of that, Lena and Kostos always find their way back to each other. It’s the kind of love story we all hope we’ll find. It’s a once-in-a-lifetime thing, I think, that you meet a person who you truly connect with. Lena thinks a lot about Kostos and the road she didn’t take with him. After she graduated, he asked her to come and spend the summer with him in Greece and she said yes, but as the date drew closer, her fears and doubts set in and she cancelled the trip. That’s something she’s always regretted, it’s a constant question of “what if?” What would have happened had she gone that summer and spent the summer with him? It’s human nature to do this, we always wonder “what if.” What would have happened had we taken a different life path than the one we chose? Would have it changed our lives for the better or for the worst? I’ve done this more times than I can count because, like Lena, I’m afraid to leap. Both of us are frightened by our hearts and what our hearts want.
After Tibby’s death, Lena calls Kostos to ask him to come and help her in Greece after Carmen and Bridget have left to go home. The few days that Lena and Kostos spend together are filled with the question of what-ifs, and when Lena leaves to go home, she watches Kostos from the deck of the ferry until the boat is too far away to see the mainland.
Lena’s emotions around Tibby’s death come out in a nasty wave when she has a falling-out with Effie over Tibby’s death before Christmas. Effie has come to New York to spend Christmas with her sister because in her words “you’re not allowed to spend Christmas alone.” The two sisters go out for dinner and Effie drinks a martini and two glasses of red wine before she brings up Tibby’s death. Alcohol has a way of loosening our tongues, our inhibitions, and our emotions. Lena believes that Effie is not being genuine, that it’s all the alcohol talking when she says that she misses Tibby and that though they had their conflicts (Brian in the fourth book) it doesn’t mean that Effie doesn’t love Tibby. Yikes. That’s all it takes for Lena’s anger, sadness and confusion to erupt and she tells Effie she didn’t love Tibby before asking her sister how she could say that. That’s the problem with bringing up sensitive and painful topics while consuming alcohol: feelings get hurt, tears and anger come, and things that can’t be taken back are said. It’s just a big, heady cocktail for disaster.
I wonder what would have happened had Effie brought up Tibby’s death when she was sober, but maybe it would have had the same outcome. Lena becomes estranged from her sister and only visits her parents when she knows Effie will not be at home, all out of shame and guilt for scaring away her sister, potentially for good.
The letters I mentioned earlier contain a few surprises for Lena, one is that she’s meant to deliver a letter to Kostos in person, and another is Tibby offering Lena and Kostos the chance to finally be together and stay together. In her letter, Tibby says “Someday is now. (Or it is never). Please come to the following address on the Second of April at 4 o’clock p.m. Eastern Standard Time. If you choose to come, bring yourself, all of yourself, and no one else. Consider it a journey that could last the rest of your life. If you choose not to come, that’s a different ending, but it’s a beginning too.” Remember what I wrote earlier about how we always wonder about how our lives would be different had we chosen a different path? This invitation pretty much sums that up. Lena realizes she is being given one last chance, and after a heart-to-heart with Eudoxia, she spends some time in self-reflection. Five days before she’s meant to open the last letter from Tibby, Lena decides to open the letter that very moment and that gives her the push she needs to make the leap.
In the first book, Lena learns that she’s like her grandfather. She’s proud, silent, and fearful. Fearful of the unknown, of taking risks, of what could happen if she does take a chance on herself and with her heart. After a celebration on the island, Lena is sitting in her room looking at the two moons in the sky, and she sees her grandfather’s elbows. He’s looking at the moons just like she is. Her grandfather once found the courage to take a chance on love from someone who knew how to give and receive it, and Lena prays that she’s like him enough that she finds the same courage. When she’s 29, she finally does. She goes to London because she wants to meet Kostos halfway, and he goes to New York because he wanted to go all the way. Lena reconciles with Effie and she and Kostos finally get their happy ending.
It was really hard to write this review. I’ve grown so used to writing about all four girls that I experienced a bit of a shock when I realized I wouldn’t be writing about Tibby in the same way I have the past four books. The book ends with the girls holding their pants ceremony they never got to have in Greece, and their stories coming full circle. Lena is with Kostos, Bridget is finally happy and at ease, and Carmen is close enough to New York she can make the trip once or twice a week for an audition if she needs to. Tibby knew that her life was going to end, but she also knew her daughter would grow up with three mothers that would love her and help her grow just as Tibby would have done had she been able to. Tibby left her friends, Brian and her daughter what they needed to live their lives as fully as they could: love. She knew how much love her three childhood friends had to give Brian and Bailey and each other.
Five books, four friends, one sisterhood, and a friendship spanning nearly three decades. Thank you for coming on this journey with me as I rediscovered my love for these books and these girls. I’ve realized over these five reviews that as Lena, Bridget, Tibby and Carmen have changed, so have I.
Pants = Love. Love your pals, love yourself.
Thanks for reading and I will be back soon with another review. Until then, xoxoxo.