Lena Kaligaris
Written By: Lauren Long
Published March 1, 2022

“Can you make yourself love? Can you make yourself loved?” – Lena Kaligaris
Ann Brashares
I know, I just finished writing my reviews for these books, but this idea came to me while I was writing my notes for the second-to-last review. When you’re writing about four main characters who all have such complex stories, you don’t always get to write the things you’d most like to. I’m writing this post for Lena because there’s quite a bit I didn’t get to write about her that I really wanted to.
The very first time I read The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants, the connection I felt to Lena was instantaneous, and every time I read the books that feeling grew stronger. I thought “here is a girl who is just like me.” We’re both reserved, we have our guards up, and we have trouble trusting people outside our family members and those in our innermost circle of friends. We guard our hearts carefully because we’re afraid of having them broken, and yet by guarding them and refusing to let people in we break them ourselves. My mom once told me I can’t keep my heart in a vacuum and not let people in, and I think Lena does the same thing. People pay attention to Lena for her looks, which she hides or tries to disguise by wearing plain, simple, uninteresting clothing because she wants to be loved for who she is on the inside and not what she looks like on the outside. I keep my heart in a vacuum because of the bullying I faced in elementary and high school and I have trust issues and trauma that stem from that.
Lena doesn’t realize that she’s in love with Kostos until she draws a picture of him from memory, and with a pep talk from Effie and taking the courage the pants offer her, Lena goes to make amends with Kostos and tell him how she feels. Both of those things are very hard to do, especially when you realize you’ve made a mistake and passed an unfair judgment on someone. I’m talking about the moment Lena goes swimming in the pond at the olive grove and she thinks Kostos is spying on her. Lena’s a very private person and she felt safe enough in the olive grove to go skinny-dipping, something she normally wouldn’t do, but when Kostos comes there, the sense of safety she felt shatters and he also doesn’t turn around and give Lena her privacy. I would freak out too. Lena’s emotions and rationality are thrown out the window and her words “Kostos is not a nice boy!” leads her grandparents to think that Kostos sexually or physically assaulted Lena and her grandfather goes to beat him up. Yikes. I can see why Lena’s grandparents would think that something untoward happened when she tells her grandmother that Kostos is not a nice boy, and this scene is a good example of what happens when our emotions, and sense of good judgment, and rationale fly out of the window. We don’t think of the potential consequences of the words we said in anger, frustration, fear or other emotions that cloud our judgment until after the fact, and Lena realizes that her rushed response and her anger at having her privacy invaded has led her grandparents to assume the worst. How often do we get the wrong impression from someone else’s words and actions and only find out the truth after the dust has settled?
I was really happy and proud of Lena when she went to tell Kostos how she felt and made amends with him. At the time I didn’t know what their story would hold because I didn’t know if there would be any more books. I was happy when four more books followed, but felt sad for Lena and Kostos throughout books two to five.
If you think about it, Lena and Kostos had a Romeo and Juliet/will they, won’t they dynamic through books two to five. Lena breaks up with Kostos sometime before the summer in the second book and then they get back together when he comes to the States, only to end things again. I really felt for Lena after her grandfather died and she discovered that Kostos had gotten married because she lost two people who she loved. She said that her grandfather was her soulmate, not in a romantic sense but in the sense that he was a kindred spirit. He understood Lena and he was supportive of her dream of becoming an artist. We learn in Sisterhood Everlasting that Lena left behind one of her drawings for him and he hung it in his closet Lena finds it when she goes to Greece to clean out her grandparents’ house so it can be sold. I feel as though out of everyone in Lena’s family, her grandfather knew and understood her the best. He could see that her passion for art was what lit her fire and made her feel alive. Lena’s mom wants to support her daughter in her dream of being an artist, but she shares her husband’s view that it isn’t a steady and reliable source of income. She’s got a foot on either side of the fence.
I think Valia, Lena’s grandmother, realizes her granddaughter’s potential and creative gift as an artist, and like her husband, she silently acknowledges Lena’s talent. We never really hear what Effie thinks of Lena’s gift as an artist. Effie agrees to be a model for Lena’s portfolio when the latter is trying to win a scholarship to art school, but Effie fidgets and moves around, making it difficult for Lena to draw her. When Lena asks her what’s wrong, that she feels as though Effie is mad at her, Effie tears up and says she doesn’t want Lena to go away to school and leave her at home with their parents and grandmother. I can understand Effie’s feeling this way, her grandmother is miserable in her grief at the loss of her husband as well as her son all but forcing her to come live with them in America, and her grief comes out in anger, petulance, and complaints about everything. It really wears on your family and home life when someone is miserable and their mood affects you, so much so that you tiptoe around them because you’re afraid of saying or doing the wrong thing.
I wonder now if there wasn’t something else underlying Effie’s saying maybe she doesn’t want Lena to go to art school. Lena is the older sister, and Effie is the younger. I think the older sibling and younger sibling dynamic, there’s a certain feeling of being left behind as well as wanting to do everything that the older sibling is doing. Older siblings get to experience everything first, the transition from elementary school to high school to post-secondary education, school dances, prom, the list goes on. I think Effie is reluctant to see Lena leave home not only because of the feeling of being left behind but also because she sees Lena’s getting to leave home to go to university as an escape from their home and family. Home is meant to be a place where you feel safe, happy, loved, and peaceful, and this is what the Kaligaris household is normally like, but because of Valia’s grief and anger, it is an unhappy place to be, fraught with tension and turbulence. Effie is reluctant and resentful of Lena going to university because she sees herself as trapped at home whereas Lena will be free. It’s a sad feeling when you feel like you’re trapped in your own home with a family member who is going in circles with the five stages of grieving and their mood is impacting yours. It’s even harder when you try to be supportive and they are volatile and lash out at you, which results in you not wanting to be around them at all. Everyone has a limit for how much anger and other emotions they can take from another person, and once that limit is hit, our own emotions can spill out.
Lena finally hits her limit with her grandmother’s antics the morning after she draws Valia. When Valia questions who made the coffee that morning and Lena responds that she did, Valia tells her that it’s the worst coffee. Lena tells her if she doesn’t like the coffee to not drink it, Lena has finally had enough of her grandmother complaining about everything and making everyone around her miserable, and in her saying this to her grandmother, Lena is saying she won’t be putting up with it anymore.
The friendship and relationships that Lena, Tibby, Bridget and Carmen have with each other are at the heart of the Sisterhood books, with the relationships they have with their families and romantic relationships following closely behind. Lena’s relationship with Kostos is a major plotline in the books, he doesn’t make a physical appearance in Girls in Pants but he’s always there on the sideline of Lena’s mind. She’s always thinking about him even when she’s trying not to. When Lena is doing her self-portrait, the final piece of her portfolio for her scholarship application, she has a deep moment of self-reflection. For a whole year, she’s waited for Kostos, she’s never really given up the hope that he will come for her and that they’ll finally be together. It’s when she’s looking in the mirror that she realizes she can’t wait for him anymore, she has to move on with her life and fall in love again. We see hints of attraction between her and Paul, Carmen’s stepbrother, and Lena has thought about having a relationship with him but she knows she needs to move on from Kostos first. I think I talked about this before in my blog post for Girls in Pants, but when Lena is having this moment of self-reflection and looking in the mirror, this is the moment she realizes and understands the only person who can set her free from Kostos is herself. I relate to her in this way because we both harbour crushes for too long when we know we need to let go. It took me a long time and a few broken hearts to realize the only person who could set me free from a failed crush was myself.
Another moment of self-reflection Lena has earlier in the book is when she’s remembering an interview with a woman who was adopted at birth and never met her birth mother. Lena saw this interview when she was at home sick one day during the school year, and she thinks a lot about this woman and the interview for months afterwards. She finally realizes she’s been thinking about this woman and her story so much because Lena sees herself in this woman, even though they’ve never met. They’re both people who prefer routine and stability over spontaneity and like to stay home more than they like to travel. I can relate to this, I’m definitely a homebody, sadly even more so since the outbreak of the coronavirus pandemic, and even the shortest trip has me anxious to come home again. How strange it is that we see someone on television, celebrity or not, and we feel a connection with them because we recognize ourselves in them.
The last thing I want to touch on is the moment in Forever in Blue when Lena and Tibby are talking about love and relationships. It’s after Tibby has had a pregnancy scare and she’s broken up with Brian and she is miserable without him and Lena tells her that Brian is miserable without Tibby. To me, Lena was the best person for Tibby to have this conversation with because she showed Tibby empathy and sympathy. Lena’s words “There are some people who fall in love over and over, and there are others who can only seem to do it once,” apply both to Tibby and Brian and Lena and Kostos. About a year ago I posted these words as a Facebook status, sometimes I’ll write a long post, other times I write quotes from novels, movies, or TV shows, usually because they strike a chord with me. These words spoken by Lena struck a chord with me the first time I read Forever in Blue, and they’ve become engraved in my memory since then. Lena is Kostos’ soulmate and he is hers, they both know that they are it for each other. I don’t know what kind of person I am when it comes to love. I’ve had crushes, sure, everyone has those, I’ve fallen in love with someone who did not love me back and it took me a long time to fall out of love with him. I haven’t been in love since then, and that was nearly ten years ago. I’m the kind of person who’s made the mistake of giving her heart to the wrong people over and over again, far too many times, and I’m hoping the next time I give my heart to someone it will finally be the right person. I’m hoping that the next time I give my heart to someone, that will be it, and I will have fallen in love for the last time.
Hope you enjoyed reading this deeper look into Lena Kaligaris and the connection I feel with her. Until next time, xoxoxo