Written by: Lauren Long
Published: June 25, 2022

“I think that any good impulse can be twisted into something evil. I think when we make choices – for each choice is individual of the choices we have made before – we must examine not only our reasons for making them but what results they will have, and whether good people will be hurt by our decisions.”
Cecily Herondale, The Infernal Devices: Clockwork Princess, Cassandra Clare
Two months ago, we set our feet on the path of the Shadowhunters in Victorian England. Alongside Tessa, Will, Jem, and the other residents of the London Institute, we faced love, loss, betrayal, and tested loyalties. The Infernal Devices: Clockwork Princess is the third book and conclusion of this prequel series by Cassandra Clare. The stakes are higher than ever, and our beloved characters will be forced to make choices and sacrifices they could never have imagined.
At the end of Book 2, The Infernal Devices: Clockwork Prince, Will Herondale’s younger sister Cecily arrived at the London Institute to be trained as a Shadowhunter. However, at least at first, this is a façade she’s putting up. She has come to the Institute to try and bring Will home to their parents so that they can be a family again. We learned in Book 2 that Ella, the eldest Herondale child, died protecting Will and that he was cursed by the demon Marbas. Because of this curse, Will left his family, with no warning, to protect them.
I understood Cecily’s desire to have her brother back and for her family to be together again, but there is a slight problem. Will can never go home to stay because it’s against the Law. Will and Cecily’s father was a Shadowhunter who fell in love with a mundane (ordinary human) woman who didn’t have the Sight. Sophie, Agatha and Thomas, the latter two were slain in the first book by Mortmain’s clockwork creatures, all have the Sight, as do Bridget and Cyril Tanner, Thomas’s brother, who came to work at the Institute in Book 2. If you have the Sight, you can be put forward for Ascension and become a Shadowhunter, and if you’re an ordinary human who the Clave considers to be worthy of becoming a Shadowhunter, your fiancé/e can put you forth for Ascension.
The Clave refused Will’s father’s request for his love’s Ascension, and he chose to leave the Clave and marry her. Shadowhunter Law decrees that every year until a child with Nephilim blood turns 12, a member of the Clave comes to ask if that child wants to become a Shadowhunter. If the child says yes and they leave home to be trained as Shadowhunters, they can never see their families again. A harsh Law and a difficult decision for anyone to make. What would you choose? Would you choose to be a Shadowhunter and swear to protect the world against demons, all the while knowing that you would never be permitted to see your family again? Or would you choose to remain with your family?
Will is furious that Cecily has come to the Institute and Cecily, in turn, is furious that Will won’t even consider visiting their parents or writing to them and explaining why he left. Cecily doesn’t understand, but Will does, that even written correspondence is against the Law. So that’s a bone of contention between the two Herondale siblings.
Meanwhile, Jem and Tessa are preparing for their wedding. They’re seventeen and eighteen, respectively, and which is very young to be married, but they know that the end of Jem’s life is rapidly approaching. I talked about this in the review I did for Book 2, but I’ll do a quick little recap. When he was a child, Jem and his parents were captured and held prisoner by the demon Yanluo, who held a grudge against Jem’s mother for slaying its offspring. Jem was repeatedly tortured in front of his parents by Yanluo injecting him with its venom. By the time a rescue force arrived, it was too late. Jem is addicted to the venom of the demon, and he has to take the yin fen every day to survive. The drug is a curse because while it keeps Jem alive, it is shortening his life, and once the drug runs out . . . well, I don’t think I need to say what will happen when it runs out. And in true villain style, Mortmain has bought up all the yin fen in London to give him leverage over the Shadowhunters of the London Institute.
In Book 2, we didn’t see Mortmain in person. We knew that he was still a part of the story, still an active threat, because his name comes up more than a few times throughout the story. At the end of Book 1, Mortmain stole a Pyxis from the Institute, which contained the soul and energies of a demon. When Jessamine was under interrogation via the Mortal Sword, which makes the holder tell the truth, Charlotte asked Jessamine if Mortmain had managed to open the Pyxis yet. If Mortmain manages to open the Pyxis, the consequences are catastrophic. From the very beginning, we’ve known that Mortmain wants Tessa. She’s the last part of his plan for revenge on the Shadowhunters. Mortmain sends a message to the London Institute that drips with false sympathy over Jem’s rapidly declining health. He offers a deal: in exchange for Tessa, he will give all the yin fen in his possession to the London Institute so that Jem’s life may be extended. Tessa says that she will go, but Jem refuses to let her and throws the letter and the accompanying small packet of yin fen into the fire. Will burns his hands getting it out and Tessa, after giving him her handkerchief, leaves the room, angry and betrayed that Jem would insult her by refusing her sacrifice for him.
A little later, Jem and Tessa reconcile. It is their last moment of normalcy, safety, and love between the two of them before the net of dangerous shadows that has been slowly tightening around them and their loved ones traps them entirely. Jessamine Lovelace, who has been imprisoned in the Silent City after she betrayed the Shadowhunters, is returning to the Institute. Her arrival provides the perfect cover for Mortmain’s carriage to roll in behind the Silent Brothers’ carriage, and the Shadowhunters, joined by Gabriel and Gideon Lightwood, are immediately locked in a battle with Mortmain’s creatures. Tessa, Sophie, Bridget and Cecily all join the fight, but Tessa is chloroformed and taken by Mrs. Black. Jem sets off in pursuit of the carriage while the courtyard fight continues, and Jessamine is killed by one of the automatons. I won’t go into the details of how she dies, because it’s too horrific, but I will say that Will gives her the farewell spoken by all Shadowhunters: “Ave atque vale, Jessamine Lovelace,” which is Latin for hail and farewell. Jem returns to the Institute, covered in blood and moving slowly, and Will is reminded of when he found Thomas on the steps of the Institute, bloody and barely clinging to life.
Jem tells the assembled group of Shadowhunters that he couldn’t keep up with the carriage, and he goes to say more before he doubles over as though someone has punched him in the stomach, coughing so hard that blood spatters the ground as he falls. Jem has been taking more of the yin fen than he should so that he could burn more brightly for Tessa, but in doing so, he has used up a supply that should have lasted for a year and shortening his life as a result.
Before I carry on, I want to talk about the Lightwood brothers, Gabriel and Gideon. Near the end of Book 2, the Shadowhunters of the London Institute discovered that Benedict Lightwood had been breaking the Law for years by laying amongst demons, and as a result, he contracted demon pox. Upon learning that his father had been defying and breaking the Law Shadowhunters have sworn to uphold, Gideon chooses to leave his family home and returns to the Institute with Charlotte, Will and Tessa.
At the beginning of Clockwork Princess, Gabriel comes to the Institute seeking help because his father has entered the last stage of demon pox: he has become a demon himself. Gabriel has been struggling with his gut instinct that something is not right, and at the same time, he’s denying there’s anything because the Lightwoods have been living in blissful ignorance. But that ignorance was shattered in Book 2 when Charlotte delivered her ultimatum to Benedict, and now in Book 3, Gabriel knows he can no longer deny that there is something wrong. The graphic examples of slime on the stairs and torn remains of the servants in the gardens can attest to that.
Gabriel is an interesting character because his character development from Book 1 to Book 3 is so evident. In Book 1, he’s very arrogant and he believes he’s superior to Will and Jem because he’s just turned 18, which is the age that Shadowhunters officially become adults, and he believes that his father can do no wrong. Every time his path crosses with Will and Jem, he picks a fight, and when he does it in front of Tessa at the Institute, he’s taken aback by her defence of Will after Gabriel says that no one’s expecting Will to live to be older than 19 and that no one would be sorry to see him die. Not a good first impression, Gabriel, and not a nice thing to say either.
Tessa is shocked by Gabriel’s ill will towards Will, and she speaks up for him. She says “Telling someone you wouldn’t be sorry if they died! It’s inexcusable!” She took hold of Will by the sleeve. “Come along, Will. This—this person—obviously isn’t worth wasting your time on.” You can tell by the way Cassandra has written these words that Tessa is holding back what she would really like to say to Gabriel. I think that she really wants to say something that would be considered unladylike, but she is still not used to the world of the Shadowhunters and she’s finding her footing and herself in this new world and new life.
In Book 2, Gabriel and Gideon are volunteered by their father to train Jessamine, Sophie, and Tessa in defence. Gabriel touches Tessa without her consent, she lets him know how she feels about that, and he apologizes, saying he knows that he shouldn’t have touched her like that. He expresses frustration that Will is present in the training room and when he asks Tessa to tell Will to go away, she responds “Now, why would I do that? Will is my friend, and you are someone whom I do not even like.” Gabriel is, to say the least, astonished that Tessa would speak to him like that and he questions Tessa on what she means by that. She says that Gabriel behaves as if he dislikes her and all the other residents of the Institute. Her reasoning is sound, if someone acts like they don’t like you, do you have any reason to act as though you like them? I think not.
I already covered what happened at the end of Book 2 and the beginning of Clockwork Princess, so I’m going to fast-forward a little bit. After Tessa is abducted and Jem is unconscious from the courtyard fight, Gabriel stops Cecily from going into Jem’s room, where Will is. The bond between parabatai is a bond that the Nephilim take as seriously as the bond between a husband and wife or brother and sister. The Nephilim apply the same kind of grief and mourning to losing a spouse or a sibling to losing a parabatai. During his brief time as a resident of the London Institute, Gabriel’s perception of Will has begun to change. He tells Cecily that he and Will have disliked each other for years, but now that he’s spent time with Will and has witnessed his interactions with Jem, Tessa, and the others at the Institute, Gabriel is beginning to see that “many things that I had always thought were certain, are not certain. And Will is one of those things. I was certain he was a scoundrel, but Gideon has told me more about him, and I begin to understand he has a very peculiar sense of honor.”
With these words, Gabriel shows how much his character has developed since the beginning of the Infernal Devices, as well as hitting on a very strong home truth. Our first impression of someone plays a strong role in our opinion of them, and usually, our first impressions are right. But every once in a while, we are forced to reconsider and re-examine our initial impressions of someone. Gabriel has learned this lesson with Will, and the reader has learned to re-evaluate their opinion and first impression of Gabriel in turn. Fallaces sunt rerum species. He also pledges his loyalty to Charlotte in front of Henry and the rest of the Shadowhunters who live at the Institute, something he would not have dreamed of doing in Book 1.
With Tessa’s life and Jem’s health in jeopardy, the third act of Clockwork Princess begins. Clinging to life, Jem gives Will and the rest of the Institute permission to search for a cure. As they set about researching the resources in the library, Will summons Magnus Bane, though not to ask him for his help with Jem, simply to talk. Magnus is astounded by this because, despite the Nephilim relying on information from warlocks and other Downworlders, they are not seen as human beings. Magnus has lived a long time, and during his long life, he’s encountered very few, if any, Shadowhunters like Will who see him as a person. “I do not think a Shadowhunter has ever called upon me before simply to pass the watches of the night with him.”
Throughout these three books, the relationship between Magnus and Will has altered from that of acquaintances to friends. Will trusted Magnus with his greatest secret, the curse he falsely believed had been placed upon him at the age of 12, and Magnus not only sympathizes with Will but he does everything in his power to help him.
Magnus acts as a friend when Will expresses the desire he feels to go after Tessa but also the desire to stay by Jem’s side as he knows that time is quickly running out. One of the things I love about Cassandra Clare and about the world she has created is that she writes her characters as very relatable people and she has them speak such profound truths. Take these words Magnus speaks to Will upon hearing his inner turmoil: “Will. You asked me for my wisdom, as someone who has lived many lifetimes and buried many loves. I can tell you that the end of a life is the sum of the love that was lived in it, that whatever you think you have sworn, being here at the end of Jem’s life is not what is important. It was being here for every other moment. Since you met him, you have never left him and never not loved him.” Every time I read these words, I feel like my heart just opens in the most incredible way because Magnus is right. Love is the most powerful thing in the world, and the love we show others and are shown in return is what truly matters, in addition to being there for the moments of triumph, heartbreak and everything in between.
Magnus then tells Will that he will stay with Jem and watch over him while Will goes after Tessa. Magnus then departs the room to give Will the privacy he needs to say goodbye. Atque in pepetuum, frater, ave atque vale are the lines spoken at each Shadowhunter’s passing and are the words Will speaks over Jem, knowing as he does so this is likely the last time he will ever see his parabatai alive again.
Little did Will and Magnus realize that Jem was awake, and heard Magnus ask Will if Jem knew that Will is in love with Tessa. After a brief moment of hesitation, Will tells Jem that he didn’t dream Magnus asking him that, that he is in love with Tessa. Jem is wracked with guilt that he didn’t know that Will is in love with Tessa, that his parabatai was suffering in silence at the cost of Jem’s happiness. It’s a difficult thing to come to terms with when we realize our happiness has come at the price of someone else’s pain. Jem tells Will that had he known Will was in love with Tessa, he wouldn’t have proposed and he would have ended the engagement.
Jem is a very perceptive young man and he saw the change in Will, he saw the carefully constructed walls Will had built to keep other people out for their own protection lower when he rescued Tessa and brought her to the Institute. Jem then tells Will that he is glad that Will loves Tessa because it makes it easier for Jem to ask Will to go in his place to save Tessa. Jem trusts Will to go after Tessa because he knows that if Will does not go after Tessa, no one will.
Will knows this and after receiving Jem’s blessing to go after Tessa, to have a life with her, Will bids Jem farewell. “If there is a life after this one,” he said, “let me meet you in it, James Carstairs.” These words really pack an emotional wallop because you can feel the love and faith and trust that Jem and Will have in each other, but also the heartbreak and sadness at the knowledge of them both knowing that life as they know it is coming to an end.
I could go on for another 10 pages, but I will end with this. Will rides to rescue Tessa and the two of them spend the night together, which at the time would have been considered scandalous as they were not husband and wife. The other Shadowhunters of the London Institute, as well as Sophie, Bridget, Cyril, Magnus and some of the Silent Brothers, make up the rest of the rescue force/cavalry. Charlotte sent word to the Council to ask for their aid but Consul Wayland, due to his anger at the fact he cannot control Charlotte the way he had hoped, refuses help.
This comes at a great price as he and the other Shadowhunters in the Council meeting having a very heated discussion about going to Cadair Idris and Mortmain’s clockwork creatures ambush them. Mortmain needed Tessa to open the Pyxis, and for her to open the Pyxis, Mortmain needs Tessa to change into his father, a warlock by the name of John Shade who, along with his wife, was slain by Shadowhunters led by Aloysius Starkweather. Starkweather is present at the Council meeting, and he is slain by an automaton, though not before he tells the stunned Shadowhunters who have just watched their Consul be slain that Charlotte was right.
Meanwhile, at Cadair Idris, Henry is gravely injured and the Shadowhunters are in a fight for their lives. It is here that we learn that Jem went to the Silent City to try and become a Silent Brother, and had the initiation failed, he would have died. He chose to become a Silent Brother to save his life and because of that, he can fight alongside Will and see Tessa one last time.
Tessa is the heroine of the Infernal Devices Trilogy, she’s strong, witty, and cares deeply about the people around her. It is her love and care for the Shadowhunters, who have given her a safe place and a family, that drives her to make the ultimate sacrifice: she reaches into her clockwork angel and becomes the angel who has been imprisoned there since before Tessa was born. It is in angel form that Tessa defeats Mortmain once and for all, thus saving the Shadowhunters in Cadair Idris and London, as well as Downworlders and the mundane world, from a terrible fate.
With that, this concludes our journey in Victorian London, but there’s more to come. I hope you’re enjoying reading my thoughts about these books as much as I enjoy writing about them. Our next adventure in the world of the Shadowhunter will unfold in The Mortal Instruments in modern-day New York with fifteen-year-old Clary Fray, a young woman who embarks on a journey of danger, self-discovery, and the realization that she is not what she seems.
Until next time, xoxoxo