Complicated Relationships, Colliding of Worlds and Insecurities in Cassandra Clare’s The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones

Written By: Lauren Long

Photo by David Skyrius on Pexels.com

“Clary, you’re an artist, like your mother. That means you see the world in ways that other people don’t. It’s your gift, to see the beauty and the horror in ordinary things. It doesn’t make you crazy – just different. There’s nothing wrong with being different.”

Luke Garroway to Clary Fray, The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones, Cassandra Clare

Welcome to another blog post. I hope you’re ready to continue our journey in the world of the Shadowhunters. In the Infernal Devices trilogy, we walked into London, England during the reign of Queen Victoria. We met James Carstairs, Tessa Gray, Will Herondale, and their allies and enemies. Three books, one story, and multiple lives crossing each other.

    In the Mortal Instruments, we meet Magnus Bane once again. Once again, he uses his warlock powers for good as he helps Clary Fray, Simon Lewis, Jace Wayland, and Isabelle and Alec Lightwood as they search for answers about Clary’s past and battle a new foe: Valentine Morgenstern. Together, Clary, Jace, Simon, Isabelle, Alec, and Magnus round the main cast.

   This time, we’re in present-day New York City, where 15-year-old Clary Fray and Simon Lewis encounter a mysterious figure one hot summer night in August. Little do they know that this night will change their lives forever. In Cassandra Clare’s first book of The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones, secrets and lies come to light, true identities are revealed, and a seemingly ordinary young woman discovers a world hidden within her own and that she is part of something bigger than she ever could have imagined.

  The book opens at the Pandemonium Club. It is here that we meet Clary and Simon on the fateful night that changes everything. Clary likes coming to Pandemonium because it’s an escape from her ordinary life, whereas Simon only comes because he knows Clary likes going there, while he thinks it is boring.

 “The girl was gorgeous, the kind of girl Clary would have liked to draw – tall and ribbon-slim, with a long spill of black hair.” The girl is Isabelle Lightwood, a beautiful Shadowhunter girl Clary’s age. Isabelle is what we could call a femme fatale because she’s beautiful and deadly. She’s aware of her beauty and she uses it like a weapon. We then meet Alec Lightwood, Isabelle’s older brother, who is tall and has black hair like Isabelle’s, and his parabatai Jace Wayland. Where Isabelle and Alec have dark hair and blue eyes, Jace is blonde with tawny-coloured eyes that glitter like chips of amber, and he is the adoptive brother of Alec and Isabelle.

   With her descriptions of Jace, Alec, and Isabelle, Cassandra Clare gives us a very clear picture of how she envisioned her characters in her mind and in turn, we can visualize them. It’s no different with her physical descriptions of Clary, Simon, Jocelyn and Luke.

  Clary is a slender redhead with green eyes. She got her figure, hair and eyes from her mother Jocelyn, and like every teenage girl, she has insecurity about her looks. She doesn’t see herself as pretty or beautiful because she’s just over five feet tall, and her height, hair and freckles make her view herself as a Raggedy Ann doll, whereas she sees her mother as a Barbie doll.

   I thought the way Cassandra Clare wrote the characters of Isabelle and Clary was really well done because you see the differing opinions of the two girls on their own appearances. Where Isabelle knows that she is beautiful and flaunts it, Clary is the only one who can’t see her own beauty. Isabelle is a girly girl, even when she’s dressed in Shadowhunter gear she still gives off an aura of femininity, whereas Clary is a tomboy, she doesn’t really wear dresses or skirts.

  For Isabelle’s part, when she and Clary meet again after Jace brings Clary to the Institute after her mother goes missing, we learn that Isabelle is insecure around Clary because she’s used to being the only girl in a room full of boys. She’s also envious of Clary because Clary is short, whereas Isabelle is tall, and she feels insecure about her height because she doesn’t have to look up at a boy, she’s either on an equal eye level or looking down at them. Some boys are intimidated by Isabelle’s height, and she finds that really hard to deal with, so both she and Clary are going through the insecurity that comes with not truly loving yourself and accepting yourself for who you really are.

  Because of their mutual unease, nervousness and insecurity around each other, Clary thinks that Isabelle hates her, and she’s surprised when she expresses this to Jace because he tells her that Isabelle doesn’t hate her. “You just make her nervous, because she’s always been the only girl in a crowd of adoring boys, and now she isn’t anymore.”  When Clary responds “But she’s so beautiful,” Jace elaborates on his previous point with “So are you, and very different from how she is, and she can’t help but notice that. She’s always wanted to be small and delicate, you know. She hates being taller than most boys.”

   Like Clary and Isabelle, Jace, Alec and Simon all have insecurities and secrets that they are struggling with as well. Jace is handsome, with golden hair and golden eyes, and he’s got a bit of a reputation as a ladies’ man. He flirts with girls and he’s aware of their attraction to him, but he’s never had a serious relationship or been interested in having one. That is until he meets Clary. Jace finds himself inexplicably drawn to Clary and she to him, even their first few interactions are them getting frustrated with each other. Jace and Clary’s deepening connection and feelings for each other are evident to Isabelle, Alec, and Simon, and it hurts the latter two for the same reason.

   Alec is a really interesting character because unlike his sister Isabelle and his adoptive brother Jace, he’s an introvert. He doesn’t trust other people easily, he’s an outcast, and he has a secret that is weighing heavily on him. Like his younger sister, Alec is also very good-looking, but unlike her, he doesn’t use his looks as a weapon. He’s aware of them, but he does everything he can to downplay his looks and direct attention away from himself.

   In Mortal Instruments, Cassandra tackles the topic of homosexuality and homophobia. Alec is gay and he’s in love with Jace, his parabatai. It’s forbidden for Shadowhunters that are parabatai to have romantic relationships, and in terms of Shadowhunters who are not straight, the Clave is very old-fashioned and unaccepting of their members who are gay or bisexual. At one point in the book, when Clary and Isabelle are getting ready for Magnus’s party, Clary asks Isabelle if Alec is gay and Isabelle immediately goes into protective mode. She loves her brother, she knows that he’s gay and she accepts that he’s gay, but she is terrified of what would happen to him if anyone outside of their family found out. By anyone, I mean the Clave. In the world of the Shadowhunters, if you’re gay, you don’t talk about it.

  I really felt for Alec, because I could feel his inner turmoil and his fear of what would happen if he revealed that he is gay. He’s like any other teenager, he wants to be accepted and he wants to be seen for who he is, but he’s also very afraid of the very real possibility that once his parents find out, they will disown him and throw him out of the Clave. He’s afraid to lose everything that makes him who he is: his family, being a Shadowhunter, and serving a cause whose purpose is to protect and defend those who cannot defend and protect themselves. He’s afraid of losing Jace, and that’s why he’s so resentful and jealous of Clary because he sees her as a threat.

   Before we move on to Simon, I want to touch really briefly on the relationships between these five characters. Clary and Simon are coming from the human world, a world where vampires, werewolves, faeries and other supernatural creatures are merely fictional, beings you only hear about in movies, books and TV shows. When they meet Jace, Alec and Isabelle, they’re suddenly thrust into a world where those creatures are very real and in actuality do exist. There’s a colliding of worlds because Simon and Clary experience the Shadow world, whereas Jace, Alec and Isabelle experience a little bit of the human world. The difference in their upbringing is very evident because Simon and Clary, with their upbringing and normal teenager experience, have met a lot of people their own age, while Jace, Alec, and Isabelle have met very few people their own age. Jace, Alec and Isabelle have had a very isolated and very sheltered upbringing with very little to no interaction with people their age, and so their relationships with Simon and Clary don’t really get off to the best start.

   Simon is the one normal character in the whole book, he actually kind of reminds me of Eustace Scrubb from C.S. Lewis’s The Chronicles of Narnia series, because at the beginning, both of them have a very firm idea of normality. The only thing they have in common is that they are normal, whereas Clary and Lucy and Edmund all have ties to other worlds, even though Clary doesn’t realize it at first. That’s where the similarities end, though. Eustace is very resistant to accepting Narnia and its magic, while Simon after he gets over the initial shock, is kind of like “Okay, this is cool.” Simon’s a big fan of Dungeons & Dragons, and to him, he’s entered a real-life version of the game when he and Clary become aware of the Shadow World.

   Simon’s secret is that he is in love with Clary, and has been for ten years. He’s never really been able to tell her how he feels until he and Clary meet Jace and Isabelle and Alec, and for the first time, he has competition in hopes of winning Clary’s heart. I mentioned earlier that Simon, Alec and Isabelle can all see the attraction between Jace and Clary and their growing bond, and just as Alec sees Clary as a threat to his relationship with Jace, Simon sees Jace as a threat to any possible chance he has at a relationship with Clary.

   The tension between the love square, I don’t know what else to call it, of Jace, Clary, Simon and Alec come to a head after Magnus’s party. Clary confronts Alec about his feelings for Jace and he has a very strong reaction to the point where he shows violence towards Clary and he shoves her against the wall. Emotions are running high because Alec is struggling to deal with the fact that he didn’t go with Jace and Clary to the Hotel Dumort to save Simon, he feels as though Jace left him behind. Alec is someone who takes his duties and obligations as a parabatai very seriously, he and Jace are responsible for watching each other’s backs. Clary, for her part, is struggling to come to terms with that she’s not an ordinary teenager, so she’s experiencing some identity crisis, and she’s angry. When we’re angry at the world and at specific people, it really impacts our actions and words and we don’t think about what we’re saying before we say it, only to be left with a mix of regret and self-loathing. Cassandra did a really great job with the scene between Clary and Alec because she showed their emotions so clearly and we are taken into their heads and witness first-hand what they are thinking.

  I learned in one of my writing classes that for every negative shift in a novel, a positive one should follow it, with the pattern repeating in the opposite direction. The positive shift is that Clary spends time with Simon, and for a little while there’s a sense of normalcy even though their world and their lives have drastically changed.

  The positive shift continues when Jace comes to find Clary and he takes her to the greenhouse in the Institute, where there is a special flower that only blooms at midnight. As the clock strikes midnight, Clary turns 16 and she and Jace share their first kiss. A greenhouse at night, with flowers that bloom at 12, and the stars above. Sounds pretty romantic! Also, a fun fact, Clary’s birthday is August 23, 1991, and mine is August 24, 1991, so we’re both Virgos!

   Of course, once Jace and Clary go back downstairs and stop outside of Clary’s room, is when the shift turns from positive to negative. Another thing I learned in my writing classes is you can’t have your characters be happy all the way through the story, you have to let them get hurt. They have to experience heartbreak and anger and jealousy and hatred, just the same as they have to experience happiness, love, and all the other positive emotions. I think, sometimes, as an author, we write our characters to live their lives as we wish we could live ours. We put pieces of ourselves in our characters but we also try and draw some of their strength and courage into ourselves. Our characters experience the same emotions we do because they’re human, just like us.

   It’s the moment where Simon opens the door and sees Clary and Jace kissing that things go south. Up until this point, Simon has been trying to make Clary jealous by flirting with Isabelle, and I think Clary is slightly aware of Simon’s feelings for her, I think if one of your guy friends kissed you on the cheek in front of everyone, you would have some knowledge that what they feel for you is not strictly platonic, but Clary doesn’t really think much of it at the time.

   It’s not until Simon sees Clary kissing Jace that he becomes fully aware of the possibility he may not have a chance of winning Clary’s heart. He reacts in anger and jealousy and he and Clary have the worst fight of their friendship. Simon leaves in anger and Clary turns to her sketchbook, which is her diary because she draws her feelings instead of writing about them.

  The story moves pretty quickly from there, the Lightwoods, Jace and Clary go to Clary’s apartment because Clary has realized that her mother hid the Mortal Cup inside a painting, or, to be more accurate, a deck of cards that Jocelyn painted as a gift for Madame Dorothea, the prophetess who lives downstairs.

   Following the theme of the book that nothing is quite what it seems, Madame Dorothea is revealed to be the Greater Demon Abbadon, who gravely injures Alec. Hodge Starkweather, the tutor of Alec, Isabelle, and Jace, betrays them all upon their return to the Institute, but before escaping, he does what he can to save Alec by sending messages to the Silent Brothers and Magnus Bane. Clary reconciles with Luke and he goes with her to rescue Jace, who has been kidnapped by Valentine, a Shadowhunter extremist who plans to expunge the Shadow World of Downworlders.  Valentine is Jocelyn’s husband, Clary’s father, and the main villain of the story. When Clary and Luke arrive at Renwick’s, which is where Valentine is hiding, it’s discovered he has also been holding Jocelyn there. When Clary arrives to find Jace, Valentine reveals to her and Jace that they are biological siblings, horrifying them as they have kissed and their feelings for each other are growing stronger.

   Valentine returns to Idris through the Portal and Jace goes back to the Institute while Clary and Luke take Jocelyn to a hospital. A few days later, Clary goes to the Institute to find Jace and she and Isabelle take the tentative first steps toward becoming friends. Clary then makes amends with Alec as he walks her to the greenhouse where Jace is, and the two of them also start taking steps in the direction of becoming friends.

   I really liked how Cassandra Clare took the relationships between Clary and Isabelle and Clary and Alec from being antagonistic and insecure to realizing the potential possibility of becoming friends and learning how to interact with each other, particularly with Alec, Isabelle and Jace having more contact with people their age.

  Before I sign off, I just want to mention the film adaptation of The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones. When I saw the movie and the actors playing these characters, it really stuck with me. Now whenever I read the Mortal Instruments series, or any of the other Shadowhunter books where Jace, Clary, Simon, Isabelle, Alec, Magnus and their friends and family are mentioned, I see the actors who played these characters in the movie in my mind as I’m reading. I was and will always be very disappointed they didn’t make The Mortal Instruments: City of Ashes because I love this series so much and I was looking forward to seeing the rest of the books come to life on the big screen. Jamie Campbell Bower as Jace, Lily Collins as Clary, Godfrey Gao as Magnus, Robert Sheehan as Simon, Jemima West as Isabelle and Kevin Zegers as Alec will always be who I see in my mind when I’m reading these books, as will Jonathan Rhys Meyers as Valentine, Lena Headey as Jocelyn, Jared Harris as Hodge, and Aidan Turner as Luke.

I have two of the songs from the movie, “Heart by Heart” by Demi Lovato and “When the Darkness Comes” by Colbie Caillat. To me, both of these songs sum up everything in the movie and in the book as well.

   With that, dear readers, the review for City of Bones, the first book of The Mortal Instruments by Cassandra Clare, has come to a close, but our journey and adventures with Clary, Jace and their friends are far from over. The story will continue in Book 2, The Mortal Instruments: City of Ashes.

  As always, thank you for reading. Till next time, xoxoxo

Leave a Comment