Written By: Lauren Long
Published: August 8, 2022

“Everyone has choices to make; no one has the right to take those choices away from us. Not even out of love.”
Luke Garroway, Book 2: The Mortal Instruments: City of Ashes. Cassandra Clare
In Book 1, The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones, we met Clary Fray, her best friend Simon Lewis, Jace Wayland and his adoptive siblings Alec and Isabelle Lightwood. We became reacquainted with Magnus Bane from The Infernal Devices and discovered another story of young adults as they move through the challenges that we all face: insecurities about their looks, unrequited love, developing romantic feelings for someone for the first time, the list goes on and on.
I hope you’re ready for another journey into the Shadow World, I know I am!
Book 2 is just as electrifying as the first, with twists and turns you don’t see coming. We see more of Luke and Valentine in the City of Ashes, and we meet new characters in the forms of Robert, Maryse and Max Lightwood, as well as Bat Velasquez and Maia Roberts, two werewolves, or lycanthropes, whichever term you prefer, who are members of Luke’s wolf pack.
Valentine made his first appearance at the end of City of Bones, he was mentioned in conversation after Jace brings Clary and Simon to the Institute and Hodge is telling them about the Circle and how Jocelyn, Clary’s mother, was married to Valentine. For the past 15 years, he’s been believed to be dead because charred bones were found in the manor house where Valentine and his family lived, but he reveals himself to be very much alive when he reveals to Clary and Jace that they are brother and sister.
Because of Jace’s connection to Valentine, he is under suspicion not only by the Inquisitor but also by his adoptive mother Maryse. The Inquisitor’s job is to investigate Shadowhunters for the Clave and confirm that the Law hasn’t been broken by the Nephilim. Imogen Herondale, and remember that name because it’s going to come up again, is the Inquisitor who we meet in City of Ashes.
While the Inquisitor has her eye on Jace because she’s convinced he is on Valentine’s side, Clary is becoming more entrenched in the Shadow World. Isabelle gives Clary her first Marks, the Voyance rune, which allows Shadowhunters to fully see the Shadow World, symbolized by its open eye. Every Shadowhunter has this Mark on their hand, and the other Mark that Isabelle gives Clary is a Rune of Protection. While Clary is struggling with her feelings for Jace and giving a romantic relationship with Simon a try, she’s also developing tentative friendships with Isabelle and Alec. You might remember from Book 1 that Isabelle and Clary were insecure around each other because they each had what the other wanted; Clary wishes that she was taller like Isabelle, while Isabelle wishes she was small and delicate like Clary. I think it’s really great that Cassandra Clare has captured the insecurities that, no matter how old we are, we all experience.
There’s also a bit of friendly sibling rivalry between Alec and Isabelle for Clary’s friendship. Remember, they and Jace haven’t grown up with a lot of contact with people their own age, and now that Isabelle has realized it’s nice to have another girl around, we see her making more of an effort with Clary. We see her tell Alec that Clary should come with them to the Silent City where Jace is being held for a night, on the orders of the Inquisitor, and that Clary needs a chance to learn how to defend herself as well as the fact that Clary knows her way around the Silent City after going there in Book 1.
A little later in the book, when Alec says he’ll call Clary, Isabelle bats his hand away with the statement “No. She likes me better.” Typical sibling!
Alec’s relationship with Clary in Book 2 is so vastly different than the way it was in Book 1. He hated her at first, but at the end of the book the two of them had made amends and he was making an attempt to joke around with Clary, and we learn that Alec actually has a dry sense of humour.
The great thing about sequels is that we see the characters develop even more. City of Bones was the foundation for our introduction to the lives of Clary, Simon, Jace, Alec and Isabelle, while also allowing us to reacquaint ourselves with Magnus, who we met in the Infernal Devices trilogy. We learn that Magnus and Alec have been secretly seeing each other. They’re keeping their relationship a secret because Alec isn’t fully ready to come out and Magnus is a warlock. You may remember from the Infernal Devices, with the relationship between Jem and Tessa and later Will and Tessa, that a relationship between a Shadowhunter and a warlock is tolerated, but not fully accepted. There’s also the fear on Alec’s part that if he comes out, he will not be welcome to stand along with his fellow Shadowhunters anymore.
Meanwhile, the budding romantic relationship between Jace and Clary has come to a grinding halt. At the end of Book 1, Valentine tells Jace and Clary that they are siblings. Both of them are struggling because they have feelings for each other, feelings that, despite this news, are growing stronger with every passing day. Jace and Clary know that they love each other in a way that a brother and sister don’t love each other. Clary is trying to forget her feelings for Jace by dating Simon, but Jace can’t get Clary out of his head.
In the Seelie Court, Clary accidentally consumes fairy food, which puts her and her friends at risk of staying in the Faerie Courts. The Fair Folk like to play games with mortals, the Seelie Queen most of all. She tells the group of Shadowhunters and Simon that Clary can be freed with a kiss. “The kiss that will free the girl is the kiss that she most desires,” says the Seelie Queen. When Jace angrily questions why the Queen is doing this, she tells him “I rather thought I was offering you a boon.” She can see the feelings between Jace and Clary, and she is using that for her own twisted pleasure. Once Jace kisses Clary, she is freed, but it makes things complicated with Simon.
When Isabelle, Clary and Jace return to the Institute, Clary goes with Jace to his room after he offers to lend her something to wear. All three of them are soaked because they entered the Courts of Faerie through a body of water. Things get tense between Jace and Clary because she’s fighting her feelings to save herself the heartbreak, even if it means both lying to herself and to Jace. We can all try to lie to ourselves, but in the end, the truth is always better, no matter how painful it is.
Jace says to Clary: “You don’t understand,” he said. His voice shook. “I’ve never felt this way about anyone. I didn’t think I could. I thought – the way I grew up – my father – “. Valentine taught Jace that to love is to destroy, and because of that lesson, Jace has always believed that maybe some part of him is broken. When he met Clary, that changed. He’s started to realize that maybe he’s not as broken as he thought he was, and he actually does have the ability to love someone. Jace tells Clary that he’s willing to run away, to keep their relationship a secret, but Clary tells them that people would find out. I have to agree with Clary on this point, if the Seelie Queen can tell that they have feelings for each other, it would be easy for others to see it too.
With Clary and Jace’s kiss fresh in his mind, Simon goes back to the Hotel Dumort, which he was taken to in the City of Bones, and he is turned into a vampire. Unfortunately, this places him in the position to be used by Valentine, who seeks to make new Shadowhunters with the Mortal Cup and Sword. To complete the ritual, Valentine needs the blood of a warlock child, a faerie child, a vampire child and a werewolf child. What they all have in common is they are all Downworlders, and Valentine takes Maia Roberts prisoner to collect the blood of the Moon’s Children, which is what werewolves, or lycanthropes, are called.
With the capture of Simon and Maia, so that Valentine can use their blood in the ritual, time is of the essence. Clary, Luke, Magnus and the Shadowhunters of the New York Institute, as well as reinforcements called in from Idris, the home country of the Shadowhunters, set the ball in motion to take down Valentine on his ship. It is on the ship where Jace and the Inquisitor come face to face. The interactions between Jace and Imogen throughout the book have been tense and anything but friendly, and Jace is fed up with the Inquisitor’s repetitive questions. She sees a star-shaped scar on Jace’s body, which takes her by surprise. What could this mean? Is Jace who he thinks he is, who the world thinks he is or is he someone else entirely?
Imogen, who has been terrible to Jace from the start, redeems herself in the eyes of the reader when she steps in front of Jace to save him from a demon. But why? Why would she sacrifice herself for someone who she’s treated so horribly?
We’ve reached the end of the City of Ashes, but the twists and turns are far from over. Questions will be answered and the story will continue in Book 3: The Mortal Instruments: City of Glass. See you next time!
Until then, xoxoxoxo