High Emotions, High Stakes, Broken Trust and Truths Revealed in Cassandra Clare’s The Mortal Instruments: City of Glass, Book 3

Photo by Pixabay on Pexels.com

He smelled like blood and flannel and smoke, and for a moment she closed her eyes, thinking of the way Alec had grabbed onto Jace the moment he’d seen him in the Hall, because that was what you did with family when you’d been worried about them, you grabbed them and held onto them and told them how much they’d pissed you off, and it was okay, because no matter how angry you got, they still belonged to you.

Cassandra Clare, The Mortal Instruments: City of Glass, Book 3

We are now on book 3 of the Mortal Instruments, and on book six of the Shadowhunter Chronicles. Our journey into this world began with The Infernal Devices, which was set in Victorian London and followed the adventures of Tessa Gray, Will Herondale, and Jem Carstairs.

   The Mortal Instruments: City of Glass continues to follow the lives of Clary, Simon, Jace, Alec, Isabelle, and Magnus Bane. Unlike Books 1 and 2, City of Bones and City of Ashes, which were set in New York, City of Glass is set largely in Idris, the City of Glass and the home country of the Shadowhunters.

   The stakes that set the foundation for the series have been rising steadily with each book, and the battles that took place in Books 1 and 2 between Valentine Morgenstern, Clary and Jace’s father, and Clary, Jace, and their allies are small-scale compared to the conflict in Book 3. There’s a HUGE showdown between good and evil, and every single one of the characters that we’ve met must make a choice on where they wish to fall. Valentine is consumed with the desire to cleanse the world of not only warlocks, vampires, faeries, and werewolves, but also any Shadowhunters who do not view the Downworlders as Valentine himself does.

   Cassandra Clare is one of those authors who knows how to grab at your heartstrings and pull so hard that you can’t help but sympathize with the characters. Our main characters are betrayed by someone they thought they could trust, Sebastian Verlac, who is not who he says he is. When we first meet Sebastian, at first glance, he seems like a good guy, but as the story goes on, you get a gut feeling that there’s something not quite right with this guy. Have you ever experienced that in your own life? An instance where you meet someone and you think they are a nice person at first, but then as time goes on, your perception of them begins to change? Or maybe your gut instinct kicks in right away and sets off the alarm bells in your head.  The only person to see Sebastian for who he really is is Jace. Right from the get-go, we see that Jace doesn’t trust Sebastian, he doesn’t like him, and he follows his gut instinct where Sebastian is concerned, especially when it comes to Clary. Something is telling Jace “don’t leave Clary alone with this guy,” and Jace is the kind of person who trusts his instincts to lead him in the right direction.

  As it turns out, Jace is right not to trust Sebastian, who not only reveals himself to be in league with Valentine but also a cold-hearted monster who will kill anyone in his way. He murders Max Lightwood, the younger brother of Alec, Isabelle and Jace because Max is in the wrong place at the wrong time. With Max’s death at the hands of Sebastian, we’re all reminded that there are people who are truly sadistic and cruel, with no light in them and won’t exercise restraint if their victims are children.

   Max’s death brings a great deal of grief and guilt to his family, there’s a loss of innocence there, he hadn’t even begun to be trained as a Shadowhunter, but the one who is the most affected is Isabelle. She goes through anger; she goes through sadness and she goes through guilt. “I should have been there,” is what she says to Simon, who is the only person she will talk to. All of the main characters go through huge emotional moments in City of Glass, and Isabelle’s is her grief for Max, the survivor’s guilt she feels, and also fear for Jace, who decides to go after Valentine and Sebastian. All of those result in Clary and Isabelle sitting at Amatis’s, Luke’s sister’s, kitchen table crying over Jace for reasons that are different but also the same. There’s anger there, there’s sadness and there’s fear, but with Simon playing peacemaker and the arrival of Jocelyn, Clary’s mother, Isabelle quickly forgets her anger and moves in front of Clary to act as her protector.

  Clary has two huge emotional moments in the novel. From the end of Book 1, all the way through Book 2, and now into Book 3, she’s been fighting her feelings for Jace with little to no success. She couldn’t truly allow herself to give a relationship with Simon a real chance because she knew deep down who her heart truly wanted. Jace, for his part, he’s known that he loves Clary from the beginning, and there’s a part of him that wonders if Valentine wasn’t telling the truth when he told Jace and Clary in Book 1 that they were brother and sister because they don’t feel the way you’re supposed to feel about your siblings, they have mutual romantic feelings for each other.

   The night before the battle, Jace goes to Clary. He goes to her because he already knows he’s planning to go after Sebastian and Valentine and that there’s a good chance he won’t come back. It’s funny how life works, but when you’re going to do something that you know has high risks, it’s easier to say the words that you haven’t been able to speak before. And that’s what Jace does with Clary. He tells her, with no uncertainty and doubt, “There is no pretending,” Jace said with absolute clarity. “I love you, and I will love you until I die, and if there’s a life after that, I’ll love you then.”

   I don’t know what it’s like to love someone romantically, but I hope that when I do, I’ll have the same certainty that Jace has for his love for Clary. The confidence that I will love that person in the life after this one.

   I really liked the scene between Jace and Clary because it’s one of the most vulnerable scenes. There’s no camouflage and there’s no denial, they just lay everything out on the table and there are no words left unspoken between the two.

  After the one she has with Jace, Clary’s second emotional moment is when her mother shows up. Up until now, everything Clary has done has been in the interest of saving her mother and bringing her back from the self-inflicted coma that Jocelyn put herself into as a method of self-protection from Valentine. When her mom comes to Amatis’s house, Clary realizes that under every emotion that has surrounded saving her mom, there is anger there too. She’s blocked out her anger and hasn’t fully focused on it up until now, but now that her mother’s life is no longer in jeopardy, the anger hits Clary like a freight train.

   She’s angry because her mother paid Magnus to remove Clary’s memories of the Shadow World, without Clary’s consent. She left Clary with no way to understand what was going on when she saw something out of the ordinary and she left her largely unprotected. Jocelyn never showed Clary how to defend herself, and Clary tells her “If it hadn’t been for Jace and the others, I’d be dead. You never showed me how to protect myself. You never told me how dangerous things really were.”

   I’ve talked before about consent, with Tessa expressing her views on being touched non-consensually, and I’m going to talk about it again. No matter what the situation is, if you do something without someone’s consent, someone that you are close to, you’re setting yourself up for a tense relationship with them because they will no longer trust you. That’s precisely what has happened with Clary and Jocelyn. “You stole my memories,” Clary said. “You took them away from me. You took away who I was.”’ “That’s not who you are!” Jocelyn cried. “I never wanted it to be who you were –” “It doesn’t matter what you wanted!” Clary shouted. “It is who I am! You took all that away from me and it didn’t belong to you!”

  With these words, Clary gets the point across to her mother and the audience: Jocelyn screwed up in a big way, and the consequence of that is her daughter now no longer trusts her and no longer sees her the same way she once did.

  We’ve covered the emotional moments of Clary, Jace and Isabelle, which means that we only have Alec and Simon left. It’s hard to choose which character to talk about first, because they have both changed so much since City of Bones, all of our characters have, but I think Alec is the one who has changed the most.

   If you remember from City of Bones, Alec is very quiet and reserved at the start of the series, though he’s not shy about expressing his distaste for Clary. Alec was hiding his sexuality in Books 1 and 2 because he was afraid of what would happen if he revealed his true self, but in Book 3, he finds the courage to say “this is who I am, and I’m not ashamed or scared anymore.” Alec comes out in the Accords Hall, which is where the Shadowhunters and Downworlders have met to join forces against Valentine. In a huge step of character strength and bravery, Alec reveals his confidence and acceptance of himself and his sexuality when he kisses Magnus on the mouth in front of everyone. He’s come quite a way from the angry, solitary boy who was afraid to be himself.

   Simon has also really changed, and not just because he’s become a vampire. He’s not the same person we met in Book 1. Clary realizes this when she is looking at Simon after Max’s funeral and she, Simon, Alec and Jace are downstairs discussing who should go to talk to Isabelle, who didn’t attend Max’s funeral because of the guilt and shame she was feeling.

  “’ Maybe because I’m not family,” Simon said. He was standing with his hands in his pockets, his shoulders back. Earlier, when Clary had been sitting close to him, she had seen that there was still a thin white line circling his neck, where Valentine had cut his throat, and scars on his wrists where those had been cut too. His encounters with the Shadowhunters’ world had changed him, and not just the surface of him, or even his blood; the change went deeper than that. He stood straight, with his head up, and took whatever Jace and Alec threw at him and didn’t seem to care. The Simon who would have been frightened of them, or made uneasy by them, was gone.”

   The Shadowhunters and Downworlders win the fight, and it is revealed that Clary and Jace are not brother and sister. They begin a romantic relationship at the victory party being held to celebrate the victory over Valentine, finally free to be together in the way they’ve wanted since Book 1.

  Valentine may be gone and Jace and Clary and their friends are finally happy, but this is the Shadowhunting world, and just like the real world, new challenges are awaiting our characters. What could be afoot now for Clary, Jace and their friends and loved ones? The story continues to unfold and the plot thickens in Book 4: The Mortal Instruments: City of Fallen Angels.

   Thanks for reading! Until next time, xoxoxo

Leave a Comment