Guilt, Possession and Secrets in Cassandra Clare’s The Mortal Instruments: City of Fallen Angels, Book 4

Written By: Lauren Long

Published: December 29, 2022

Photo by Sebastian Arie Voortman on Pexels.com

“Hearts are breakable. And I think even when you heal, you’re never what you were before.”

Isabelle Lightwood, The Mortal Instruments: City of Fallen Angels, Cassandra Clare

Hello all! I hope you all had a Merry Christmas and a wonderful holiday season! 2022 is almost over, and a new year means new possibilities and new adventures just waiting to be discovered. That being said, let’s dive into book 4 of Cassandra Clare’s Mortal Instruments series, City of Fallen Angels.

16-year-old Clary Fray has just helped the Nephilim win a war that would have resulted in catastrophic consequences for all living creatures. At the end of book 3 of Cassandra Clare’s The Mortal Instruments: City of Glass, we saw Clary’s father Valentine be brought down by the Angel Raziel as well as his own greed and ambition. We also learned that Clary and Jace were not brother and sister, Valentine just told them that because he liked messing with their heads, and at the end of the third book, they are finally free to be together. Jace’s adoptive siblings Alec and Isabelle have their own romances going on with Magnus Bane and Simon Lewis, respectively, and everyone in Idris, the home country of the Shadowhunters, is enjoying some well-deserved happiness and fun time at the victory party.

  Cassandra Clare is really good at creating a world that is believable but also realistic, there are no fairy-tale-like vibes where everyone rides off into the sunset and lives happily ever after. That’s not what real life is like, it’s a balance between positive and negative shifts, and Cassandra echoes that in her writing.

   New dangers, mysteries and characters await in City of Fallen Angels, book 4 of Cassandra Clare’s The Mortal Instruments.

   When the series began with City of Bones, Clary had just been introduced to the Shadow World after a fateful night at the Pandemonium nightclub. In books 2 and 3, she’s still learning about this world and her Shadowhunter heritage, and for a while, she’s a player on the sidelines until her father’s war plans force Clary to use her power to create new runes to ally the Shadowhunters and the Downworlders to protect the Shadow world and the human world.

  In City of Fallen Angels, Clary has fully embraced the world of the Shadowhunters. She’s left the mundane world and high school behind to pursue her training full-time and become a Shadowhunter. Whereas she went through a bit of an identity crisis in the earlier books, Clary has found the place in the world where she truly belongs. She always felt like she didn’t quite fit in in the human world, and now that she’s found the place where she does, Clary doesn’t want to let that go.

  Of course, because Jocelyn, Clary’s mother, tried so hard to raise Clary away from the Shadow World, she’s very reluctant for her daughter to become a Shadowhunter. Clary’s desire to train causes a big argument between mother and daughter, Jocelyn’s point of view is that the Shadowhunter culture is violent, isolationist and cruel. A year prior to the start of The Mortal Instruments series, the Law that says if a child born of Nephilim parents who have left the Clave decides that they want to be trained as a Shadowhunter, they can never see their family again. We first heard of this law in the Infernal Devices trilogy. The Nephilim are a very proud, very traditional people, but the outcome of the war against Valentine, the Mortal War, has forced them to reconsider a few things, and that law is one of them. The Shadowhunters put aside their differences and their pride to work with the Downworlders to save the world from destruction.

   Clary eventually wins the argument by telling Jocelyn that the Clave is reviewing the outdated Laws and that she needs to know how to defend herself. I found myself agreeing with Clary when she said that, everyone should know how to defend themselves because you never know when a good punch will save your life.

  Meanwhile, Simon is casually dating both Isabelle and Maia, with both of them having no knowledge of the fact. In every language, this points to a big, fat “Uh oh.” A secret can only stay hidden for so long, and when Isabelle and Maia find out, Simon’s love life comes crashing down around him. I think unconsciously, the reason Simon doesn’t tell Isabelle and Maia that he’s seeing them both is because until he and Clary became aware of the Shadow World, he had really low self-esteem when it came to girls. Simon only ever had eyes for Clary, and his love for her made him oblivious to the fact that there were girls who were interested in him. I’m not excusing his behaviour, he definitely went about it the wrong way, he should have been honest with both Isabelle and Maia from the start. No one likes to be cheated on and no one deserves to be, and Isabelle and Maia both have their own reasons for being so angry with Simon.

  In City of Fallen Angels, we finally find out why Isabelle has the attitude she does towards guys. She dates a lot but it’s never serious and never for long, and the reason for that is a secret she’s been carrying, a secret that her mother told her when she was 13 years old. After she finds out he’s been cheating on her, Isabelle tells Simon that her dad cheated on her mom and that he was going to leave but stayed because of Max, the youngest Lightwood.

By Maryse sharing this story with her daughter, Isabelle has carried this secret with her for several years, and it explains a lot about who she is as a person. She’s built walls around her heart so she can protect herself, and she didn’t trust Clary and Simon when she first met them but little by little those walls started to lower as she got to know them. Simon is wracked by guilt when he hears this story from Isabelle because he realizes that his actions make him no better than Isabelle’s father. After Maryse told Isabelle that her husband had cheated on her, she told Isabelle that you couldn’t really trust men, and unfortunately, Simon’s cheating on Isabelle has proven Maryse’s words right. Isabelle opened up to Simon and he broke her heart and her trust.

  “Hearts are breakable. And I think even when you heal, you’re never what you were before,” Isabelle says, and she’s right. Heartbreak is an unavoidable part of life, and yes, we can heal from it, but the pain and the sting of the heartbreak always stays with us, and it affects every experience that we have after. If we’re like Isabelle, we lock our hearts away or pick romantic partners that aren’t looking for anything serious.

  Maia is similar to Isabelle in the fact that she has had her heart broken before, not just romantically but also because of her family and the homelife she had. We learn a bit more of her backstory in book 4 from a new character named Jordan Kyle, who is Maia’s ex-boyfriend, and the person responsible for turning her into a werewolf in the first place. The reunion between Maia and Jordan takes place right after both Isabelle and Maia find out that Simon has been seeing them both. The anger, betrayal and hurt that Maia is feeling towards Simon for cheating and Jordan for turning her into a werewolf cause her to have an explosive reaction to seeing Jordan again. Throughout the story, we learn about the history between Jordan and Maia, and how the moment he Turned her into a werewolf led to him joining the Praetor Lupus.

   The Praetor Lupus. If that sounds familiar, it is because we met the founder of the organization, Woolsey Scott, in the Infernal Devices trilogy. Woolsey started the Praetor Lupus in memoriam of his brother, and its mission is to aid Downworlders like werewolves, newly born vampires and warlocks who don’t know anything about the Shadow World and/or what they are. The Praetor Lupus helped Jordan learn to control his emotions and himself so he would never hurt anyone again.

  At the time of City of Fallen Angels, Jordan has completed his training and becomes Simon’s guard. He took Simon’s case because he saw Maia’s name in the file and he hoped that he would be able to redeem himself in her eyes and earn her forgiveness.

  The werewolves, or the Moon’s Children, are not the only creatures we become more informed about in book 4, we also learn more about vampires. Camille Belcourt, who we became acquainted with in the Infernal Devices, makes an appearance in City of Fallen Angels because she is interested in Simon, the sole reason being the Mark of Cain Clary put on him to protect him in book 3. We later learn that Camille is being possessed by Lilith, but she’s not the only character who is being possessed by the Mother of Demons. Jace is as well, and Lilith’s control of him and Camille is where the theme of possession takes shape.

  Camille is a very old vampire, she’s been around for a long time, and because of her long life, she knows how to turn any situation to her advantage. She’s incredibly manipulative and incredibly charming, which makes her very dangerous, and when you add her possession by Lilith to the mix, you’ve got a recipe for disaster.

  Jace’s possession by Lilith is a consequence of Clary asking for him to be brought back from the dead after Valentine kills him in book 3: City of Glass. When a Nephilim child is born, a protection ceremony is conducted by the Silent Brothers and the Iron Sisters to protect the child from demonic influences such as possession. When Jace comes back to the land of the living, the protection that was placed on him at birth has been stripped away. Because of that, Lilith is able to reach into his mind, whether he is awake or asleep, and she sends him dreams of hurting or killing Clary. Pretty disturbing, if you think about it.

  With Lilith, demonic influence is more prevalent in book four of Cassandra Clare’s Mortal Instruments series. City of Fallen Angels is also where we learn about Lilith’s history and that Lilith is just one of her many names. Talto is another one, other names include Lady of Edom, Ita, Kali, Batna, Satrina, Abito, Amizo, Izorpo, Kokos, Odam, Podo, Eilo, Patrota, Abeko, Kea and Partash. The first time we hear the name “Talto” is when Clary goes to the Church of Talto, which is a place for the satanic cult that worships and recognizes Lilith because she is a Greater Demon. It is here that Clary and Isabelle learn that someone is trying to make more babies like Jonathan Morgenstern, Clary’s brother (aka Sebastian). Valentine summoned Lilith in the hopes of using her blood to turn Jonathan into a child not of angel blood, but of demon blood. Because of his father’s experiments, while Jonathan was in the womb, Jonathan was born with everything that makes us humans burnt out of him; love, kindness, empathy, and the list goes on. The demonic qualities of Lilith’s blood corrupted Jonathan so that he never had the chance to be good or even know how to be a good person.

  Because of her mind control of Jace and the demonic blood that runs through Jonathan, Lilith carries out a ceremony where Jonathan is brought back to life by way of mixing his blood with Jace’s in a twinning spell, which is a darker version of the parabatai bond.

  The book ends with Jace being completely under the control of Sebastian, or Jonathan, whatever you want to call him, and we are left on a cliff-hanger as we wait to see if the fifth book in the Mortal Instruments series, City of Lost Souls will reveal the questions to the answers that book four has left us hanging on. New dangers and betrayals await in book 5, with the main question being this: how far would you be willing to go to save someone you loved?

  That’s it for now, guys!

   Until next time, xoxoxo

Leave a Comment