Written By: Lauren Long
Date Published: January 7, 2023

“You raised her to be a good person. Someone with values, who believes in good and evil and strives to be good. Like you always have. You can’t raise a child to believe in the opposite of what you do. I don’t think she doesn’t believe she can die. I think, just like you always did, she believes there are things worth dying for.”
Lucian Graymark (aka Luke Garroway), The Mortal Instruments: City of Lost Souls, Cassandra Clare.
Hello and Happy New Year! I hope you all had a fun and safe New Year’s Eve and an enjoyable first week of 2023. This is the eighth book review for the Shadowhunter Chronicles, and we’ve got ten more books to go, eleven if you count The Last Hours: Chain of Thorns, which comes out on January 31st. City of Lost Souls is the fifth book in the Mortal Instruments series by Cassandra Clare, and the dangers the main characters have faced are about to be upped to a whole new level.
Just for a quick recap: at the end of book 4, City of Fallen Angels, Clary managed to break Lilith’s control over Jace and Simon destroyed the Mother of Demons using the Mark of Cain, which she coveted him for. However, Lilith’s ritual to bring Sebastian back succeeds, and he abducts Jace before the two of them can be found by the Clave.
City of Lost Souls opens two weeks after the events of Book 4, with Clary and Isabelle waiting for Clary’s verdict in Isabelle’s bedroom. When Clary asked the angel Raziel to bring Jace back to life in book 3, City of Glass, she set in motion a chain of events that has dire consequences. Because Jace’s protection against demonic influence was stripped away when he died and then was brought back, Lilith took advantage of his vulnerability and possessed him. Clary and Jace both agreed to never tell a soul of his death and resurrection, but Clary is tried by the Mortal Sword, which compels the Nephilim to tell the truth. Jessamine Lovelace was tried by the sword in the Infernal Devices when she betrays the London Institute to Mortmain, and remember the name “Mortal Sword” because it’s going to come up again.
The sword is like Wonder Woman’s Lasso of Hestia, both are tools of truth, and if you try to hold anything back or lie, neither weapon harms you significantly but it does cause discomfort. Clary describes the sensation of holding the sword as feeling as though there are small fishhooks implanted in your skin, hooks that pull the truth out of you.
Because both Isabelle and Clary are 16, which is considered underage in the Shadowhunter World, they both have to wait until Alec comes to tell them the verdict. Alec is 18, the age that Nephilim children are recognized as adults, and he is permitted to sit in on Council meetings. Alec tells Isabelle and Clary that Clary has been cleared, but this does nothing to assuage her guilt and fear for Jace, and her relief dwindles when Alec tells the two girls that the Clave has decided to deprioritize the search for Jace and Sebastian.
Because of Jace’s bond with Sebastian, what makes Jace good has been overshadowed by Sebastian’s control over him. Sebastian’s hold on Jace is so powerful that the things Jace would be repelled by, for example, the murder of innocent people, don’t faze him at all. The things that Sebastian thinks, Jace thinks, he has no free will of his own and he shares Sebastian’s lack of morals.
Sebastian/Jonathan wants to burn down the world, he doesn’t value the lives of anyone who has different views and different beliefs than he does, and he betrays his allies. Remember, Sebastian has demon blood running through his veins, so everything that would have made him human, like having a conscience, having morals and understanding the importance of kindness and compassion, as well as consent. He can’t feel love, he doesn’t understand it, but he is very lonely and you sympathize with him because of this, to live without love is a very lonely thing, but at the same time, you dislike him because he does things that no person in their right mind would do.
Cassandra Clare has talked about the importance of consent in earlier books, and she revisits the theme in this book. Clary makes the decision to go with Jace and Sebastian in hopes of finding out what they’re planning and also figuring out a way to separate the two of them, to undo the twinning spell. She takes on the role of woman on the inside while Magnus, Alec, Isabelle and Simon resort to the desperate measures of bargaining with the Seelie Queen, demons, and finally seeking the help of the Iron Sisters.
The Iron Sisters are like the Silent Brothers in the way that both have taken Marks for their own individual purposes. You may remember from The Infernal Devices that Jem Carstairs became a Silent Brother as a way to save his life from the demon poison that he was tortured with as a boy. The Silent Brothers are the doctors, scholars and archivists of the Nephilim and the caretakers of the Nephilim dead both in the Silent City and the cemetery in the Shadowhunters’ home country of Idris.
Like their silent counterparts, the Iron Sisters are a reclusive order, but while the Silent Brothers are the medics, researchers, and historians of the Nephilim, the Iron Sisters are the makers of the weapons, armour and other tools the Nephilim will use in battle to keep themselves alive and protected. Both the Silent Brothers and Iron Sisters do not age as they give up that part of their humanity when they become part of their respective monastic orders, and they do not marry.
The Iron Sisters seldom leave their fortress, the Adamant Citadel, and this fortress is only open to female Shadowhunters, and only women are permitted to speak to the Iron Sisters.
“Ignis aurum probat. Fire tests gold.” The Motto of the Iron Sisters
Up until now, Clary has had the backup of her friends and Jace to help save the world from the forces that seek to wreak havoc and destruction. This time, she is entirely on her own. She spends time alone with Jace and her brother, but things turn sinister when Sebastian tries to rape Clary. This is where the theme of consent and non-consent comes in. Because Clary is his sister, Sebastian/Jonathan believes that she should be his in every sense. He quotes a passage from “The Song of Solomon” in the Bible: “Thou hast ravished my heart, my sister, my spouse; thou hast ravished my heart with one of thine eyes, with one chain of thy neck,’’” and tells Clary that the rulers of ancient Egypt used to marry their siblings to strengthen the bloodlines and keep them pure. Clary is, understandably, horrified by this. She knows this is wrong, but because Sebastian has no morals or sense of decency, he doesn’t care that the way he’s treating her is immoral, nor does he care that the act of raping his sister would leave scars on her psyche and her soul. Thankfully, Sebastian doesn’t rape Clary, but the fact that he was willing to is horrifying enough.
While Clary is in the role of a double agent, the relationships between Alec and Magnus, Isabelle and Simon and Maia and Jordan are explored more. You may remember from book 4 that Simon was casually seeing both Isabelle and Maia, which blew up in his face when both of them came to one of his band’s performances, and it was here we discovered that Maia and Jordan had a history.
Simon has been attracted to Isabelle since day one, even when he had feelings for Clary. There was something about Isabelle that drew Simon in, and as the series progresses, that feeling grows stronger. Isabelle, for her part, is attracted to Simon as well, and she lets herself be vulnerable with him at more than one point in the book because Simon has proven to her that he knows he messed up and he’s been working towards earning Isabelle’s forgiveness. The attraction between them is like a magnet, there is a magnetic pull between the two, and the stronger it gets, the harder it is for both Isabelle and Simon to stay away from each other. This is true for Maia and Jordan as well. Jordan has never stopped loving Maia, and in City of Lost Souls, Maia not only forgives Jordan but she also realizes that she is still in love with him as well, there are still feelings there for both of them.
Whereas the relationships between Isabelle and Simon and Maia and Jordan are smoother than they were in City of Fallen Angels, the relationship between Magnus and Alec is not. The two officially got together in City of Glass when Alec kissed Magnus on the mouth in front of everyone in Idris. They had a honeymoon phase, but that ended when they were called back to New York and it was revealed that Magnus and Camille Belcourt were lovers, a very, very long time ago. Alec has always known that Magnus is immortal, but this is the first time that the magnitude of that really sinks in for him, as well as the fact that Magnus has a romantic past. These two things affect Alec and Magnus’s relationship negatively because, in a way, Alec reverts back to how he was when we first met him in City of Bones. He becomes very short-tempered and he allows his insecurities to affect his relationship with Magnus, to the extent that he considers trying to find ways to end Magnus’s immortality and make him mortal like Alec, an idea put in his head by Camille. Magnus finds out at the end of the book that Alec has been seeing Camille and learns that she told Alec there was a way for him to end Magnus’s immortality. Magnus, understandably so, is very hurt by this and he breaks up with Alec.
Jace is saved, but only just, by the heavenly fire in the sword of Glorious when Clary stabs him with it. The heavenly fire breaks the connection between Sebastian and Jace, and Jace becomes himself once again because the fire represents all that is good and burns away what is evil. Sadly, Sebastian has succeeded in making an Infernal Cup, and he mixes the blood of demons in it and forces Shadowhunters to drink from it, the first being Luke’s sister Amatis. The Infernal Cup strips away the Shadowhunters’ humanity and their ability to wear angelic runes. Had Clary not stabbed Jace, Jace would have drank from the Infernal Cup. He almost loses his soul because of Sebastian’s plan and has a big scar across his chest from being stabbed, but Jace is, not grateful, but he does feel as though having a scar is right. “ . . . but he was thinking that it was right, somehow, that he have a scar: that he should be marked by what had happened to him, physically as well as mentally. He had almost lost his soul, and the scar would serve to remind him of the fragility of will, and the difficulty of goodness.”
The main theme of the book is that everything has a price, and that theme carries forward into the sixth book of the Mortal Instruments series, City of Heavenly Fire, where the Nephilim will have to fight harder for their survival than ever before as the never-ending battle between good and evil reaches an all-time high no one could have imagined.
Till next time, xoxoxo