Written By: Lauren Long
Date Published: January 26, 2023

“We are all the pieces of what we remember. We hold in ourselves the hopes and fears of those who love us. As long as there is love and memory, there is no true loss.”
James Carstairs, The Mortal Instruments: City of Heavenly Fire, Cassandra Clare
The Mortal Instruments: City of Heavenly Fire is the sixth book and concludes the Mortal Instruments series. In this gripping conclusion, Clary, Jace, Simon, Isabelle and Alec must prepare for the war against Clary’s brother, who has the Infernal Cup in his possession.
While The Mortal Instruments series is ending, the scene is being set for The Dark Artifices, the next series in the Shadowhunter Chronicles. Our story begins in California, at the Los Angeles Institute. 12-year-old Emma Carstairs has just been dropped off at the Institute by her parents for the day’s training with her best friend Julian Blackthorn. Her moments of arrival are the last few moments of familiarity that Emma has before her world is changed forever. What starts as a normal day quickly turns into a nightmare for everyone at the Institute.
Sebastian and his forces attack the Institute and turn the Shadowhunters there into the Endarkened, including Julian’s father. Julian’s older brother Mark is taken by Sebastian’s forces, and Emma, Julian, twins Livvy and Ty, Drusilla, and Tavvy all escape to Idris through a Portal, but only just.
The Endarkened are no longer Shadowhunters and they aren’t really human. They have human faces and human bodies, but because they drank from the Infernal Cup, the mix of Sebastian’s blood and the blood of Lilith has burned out what is good and what makes them human. Whether they drank willingly or unwillingly from the Infernal Cup, the moment they drank they became like Sebastian: they don’t know how to show mercy or goodness, they can’t love and they don’t have any free will, all of that has been taken from them.
I can’t imagine having my free will taken away or losing my ability to love and show compassion, mercy and goodness, that is something I hope I will never experience.
Meanwhile, in New York, Jace is trying to learn how to control the heavenly fire from the sword Glorious. When Clary stabbed him with the sword in City of Lost Souls, she succeeded in severing the bond between Jace and Sebastian, but no one thought it was even possible that the heavenly fire would become trapped in Jace’s body.
Because he has the heavenly fire, Jace has to be careful with his friends, with Clary and with his emotions. Every time he touches someone, like Clary or Alec or his other friends, he’s afraid he will burn them, and the fire coursing through his veins influences his emotions, particularly if he’s angry or if he’s excited by something.
The moment in the park and the following moments are the last moments where Clary, Jace and their friends can go about their day as they normally would. Clary and Simon’s Christmas shopping and Jace’s attempt to get Magnus to get back together with Alec are interrupted by a summons for Clary and Jace to go to the New York Institute right away.
We are then taken to the Institute, where we learn that the Los Angeles Institute was not the only one that was attacked by Sebastian. He has also attacked the Institutes of Berlin, Bangkok, and Moscow, decimating them completely and leaving no survivors. The only survivors of the attack on the Los Angeles Institute were Emma Carstairs and the Blackthorn children.
Because this is a fantasy series with one of the main themes throughout the books being the battle between good and evil, it doesn’t come as any surprise that there’s a lot of danger in City of Heavenly Fire. Danger and betrayal, both have been constant companions for not only the characters of the Mortal Instruments series but also the Infernal Devices. With each book, the stakes are raised, and relationships are tested.
The biggest betrayal the Nephilim have ever faced is the betrayal of the faeries, who are revealed to be playing both sides. The faeries have said “yes we are your allies” to the Nephilim, but this turns out to be a lie. The Seelie Queen, the ruler of the Seelie Court, has double-crossed the Nephilim by also swearing allegiance to Sebastian. The Seelie Queen is a very tricky woman, she’s someone who doesn’t think about what is best for others, but rather what is best for her people and for her. She’s someone who is always thinking ahead and who is ultimately going to go after the opportunity that suits her best. Her allegiance with Sebastian backfires on her when the Clave receives a message from Mark Blackthorn, who ran into Clary, Jace, Isabelle, Alec and Simon on their way to the demon realms to rescue Luke, Magnus, Jocelyn and Raphael, who were kidnapped from the dinner party they were attending at the house of the Fair Folk.
Mark tells the Clave that the Seelie Queen has aligned herself with Sebastian and that the faeries are not the allies of the Nephilim. Sadly, the Nephilim are not grateful for the help from Mark, but rather become suspicious of all faerie folk, including Mark and Helen. Mark and Helen are biological siblings, their father met their mother while he was on assignment in the land of Faerie. Because of their faerie lineage, the Clave doesn’t trust Mark and Helen after the Seelie Queen’s betrayal is revealed, even going as far as to suggest that the rest of the Blackthorn children are not safe with Mark and Helen. A character by the name of Sedgewick arrogantly claims that, by banishing Helen to Wrangel Island and leaving Mark to the Wild Hunt, the Clave is protecting the rest of the Blackthorn children from the possibility of betrayal by their older siblings.
The Nephilim are furious with the Fair Folk’s betrayal, and that fury bleeds into unforgiveness. It is these two things that lead the Nephilim to invoke the Cold Peace and tear the Blackthorn family even further apart.
The Blackthorn family, as well as the families who were decimated in Sebastian’s attacks on the Institutes, are not the only ones who face the loss of things being how they have always been. Isabelle, in a moment of anger, reveals to her father that she knows about him being unfaithful to Maryse, shocking and repulsing Alec, who didn’t know. Isabelle is somebody who feels a lot, even if she doesn’t always show it, and of all the Lightwoods, Max’s death at the hands of Sebastian struck Isabelle the hardest. She went through a tremendous amount of guilt and anger and hatred. Hatred at Sebastian for murdering an innocent child who was in the wrong place at the wrong time, and anger and guilt with herself for not being there to protect Max, for not being there for him to hang on to. The foundation of the Lightwood family is already on shaky ground from Max’s death, with Maryse and Robert still being legally married but separated, and Isabelle’s revelation that she has known about Robert’s infidelity not only topples her parents’ world but also threatens their future as a family. The emotion of anger is a dangerous one, and for Isabelle, her anger is combined with fear, uncertainty, and many other emotions. Our emotions can cloud our judgment, and sometimes as a result, we pick the worst moment to reveal that we know something that someone was not aware that we knew.
On a lighter note, Isabelle and Clary have some really nice moments in City of Heavenly Fire. Their relationship has reached the point that Clary is one of the people Isabelle shows her softer side to, the loving and worried side. After Magnus, Luke and Jocelyn and Raphael are kidnapped by the Fair Folk and Sebastian, Isabelle takes care of Clary by taking over the braiding of her hair and also just being there for Clary to talk to. On Clary’s part, she has gone through a massive journey of self-discovery and self-acceptance throughout the six books. She’s grateful to have gained Isabelle, and she has gone from wishing that she was like Isabelle to accepting herself for who she is and being grateful that Isabelle is who she is. Clary’s grateful that Isabelle is making the world fiercer.
In City of Heavenly Fire, Clary also becomes a friend and mentor to Emma. Clary shows Emma the compassion, sympathy and empathy the younger girl needs after Emma tells Clary that her parents were murdered and that she and the Blackthorn children were all tried by the Mortal Sword upon their arrival in Alicante. Clary, and by extension me, were both horrified that the Clave used the sword on children.
Emma is carrying a great deal of anger, guilt and sadness. She’s lost her parents, Julian has lost his brother and his father, and Emma is the kind of person who wants to protect herself and those around her. She’s had far too much to deal with than a child her age should, and the thing about life is that we all have moments in our childhood where we leave the world of childhood behind forever and begin to take our place in the world of adults. Emma feels guilty because she didn’t do anything to save Mark or his and Julian’s father, saying that because of her failure, she’s not a hero when Clary tells her that heroes are people who carry famous swords like Cortana, Joyeuse and Durendal. Cortana is Emma’s sword and it has been carried by the Carstairs family for generations.
Clary comforts Emma with these wise words: “I can see what a good Shadowhunter you are,” Clary said. “I see your Marks. I see your scars. And how you hold your sword. If you’re that good, I can only imagine they were really good too. And something that could have killed them both isn’t something you could have saved them from.” She touched the sword lightly. “Heroes aren’t always the ones who win,” she said. “They’re the ones who lose, sometimes. But they keep fighting, they keep coming back. They don’t give up. That’s what makes them heroes.”
You don’t have to carry a literal sword to be a hero, you can carry a metaphorical one too. If you’ve gone through some hard times and you’ve picked yourself up and dusted yourself off, you’re a hero. If you suffer from mental health illnesses like depression and anxiety and you’re still here and you’re still fighting, you’re a hero.
The final instance of loss that I want to talk about is the loss faced by Sebastian or Jonathan Morgenstern. By trapping the heavenly fire that runs through Jace’s veins into her sword Heosphoros, which means dawn-bringer, Clary stabs Sebastian and the fire burns out what is evil in him. He turns back into Jonathan, but sadly, there was too much of the demon nature for him to have a chance at redemption, to have a better life. Jonathan has lost the chance to truly know his mother and his sister, a chance he never had thanks to Valentine’s experiments, and he has also been robbed of the chance to have a life that was filled with love and kindness instead of one that was driven by hate and a desire to burn down the world.
Jonathan’s loss is the loss of innocence, the loss of a normal childhood, and the loss of being raised by a family who loves him and guides him. He dies in Jocelyn’s arms and, though he was responsible for the Endarkened and the attacks on the Institute, the Clave redeems and forgives him in death by following the traditional burning of a Shadowhunter’s body when they die.
We have reached the end of the Mortal Instruments series, but our journey through the world of the Shadowhunters is far from over.
Thanks for reading.
Until next time, xoxoxo