She Said: How Investigative Journalism Brought Down One of The Most Powerful Men In Hollywood

Written By: Lauren Long

Original Date Published: May 2, 2023

Updated: March 19, 2024

Photo by Jessica Lewis Creative on Pexels.com

“The only way these women are going to go on the record . . .” “Is if they all jump together.”

Carey Mulligan as Megan Twohey and Zoe Kazan as Jodi Kantor in Maria Schrader’s film She Said

The above quote is spoken by Carey Mulligan and Zoe Kazan in She Said, who play Megan Twohey and Jodi Kantor, respectively. Jodi and Megan are the two New York Times investigative journalists whose perseverance of the truth revealed the crimes of Harvey Weinstein and caused his downfall.

I was familiar with both actresses; I had seen Carey in Pride and Prejudice and The Dig and Zoe in The F Word. From the moment I saw the trailer for She Said, I knew I would be watching the film because it gives you just enough to be intrigued. I eagerly awaited the film’s theatre debut, but it did not come to my city. When I saw the DVD at the grocery store a few months later, I immediately picked it up.

  She Said is based on Jodi and Megan’s book of the same name, published in 2019, two years after their investigation into the disgraced movie tycoon’s reign of offences against women was published.

  It is chilling to think that this vicious cycle of sexual aggression went on for 30+ years. What makes it even more disturbing is how far Harvey and his enablers were willing to go to cover their tracks. I knew the film was only one piece of the puzzle. Because any form of sexually transgressive behaviour is a sensitive topic, I had a moral obligation to learn as much as I could for this article. I watched countless videos and read numerous articles about the Weinstein case, all of which provided elaboration on the stories covered in the film.

She Said is not a documentary. To quote Megan Twohey, “It is a really inspiring movie, and it is a wonderful depiction of journalism, the pursuit of the truth. Truth matters.” The truth does matter and it always comes out.

Journalists are society’s watchdogs. When they start getting close to the truth, people, like Harvey Weinstein, who have used their influence for evil start getting nervous, because the moment their offences become public knowledge, they’re finished.

  This is shown in the scene when Harvey Weinstein and his team come to The New York Times to kill the story. This is not their first attempt to stop publication, but it is the first time we see Harvey in the daylight instead of the monster lurking in the shadows.

   When he is trying to prevent the story’s publication, Harvey resorts to the tactics he has used in the past to get out of trouble: threats, lies, and denial. His ranting in the meeting with his team and Megan is driven by fear. He knows that the empire is crumbling.

   In a massive show of restraint, Megan calmly observes Harvey as he actively denies any wrongdoing. She does not see a famous man, but a monster and predator who discredits the actresses. She doesn’t respond to his fearful rage because she knows that they have him. The evidence is stacked against him, making his long-deserved conviction inevitable.

 In the film’s “Breaking the Story” featurette, Jodi asks an important question: “How do you really confront a bully? The answer is to do it together.” I agree with Jodi, if we try to take on a bully by ourselves, there is a chance we will not be believed, but standing together and refusing to be silent is when change happens. Bullies only respond to strength, and when we say, “I will not tolerate or accept mistreatment from anyone,” that is the moment where we reclaim our voice and power, one of the major themes in the movie.

How did Harvey and his cohorts avoid punishment for so long? Their most common tool to exercise power and control over women was an NDA. For lack of a better term, these documents were gag orders and were rarely investigated. The lawyers who provided legal representation for the victims received 40% of the settlement, providing financial motivation to keep Harvey’s system of abuse going.

Harvey was a domineering man, and some people in his employ went along with what he wanted out of fear. Fear that they would become the next target, so they looked the other way even when they knew the abuse was happening. It does not matter how old we are, whether we are adults in the workplace or students in the school hallways, there are always people who are afraid to speak up because they don’t want to be the bully’s next target.

    Something that I found very moving and emotional in the movie was the expressions of relief on the faces of the women who had been silenced by Harvey: “Finally, somebody is listening. Someone who wants to address this issue head-on is willing to listen to me and make a change in the world for the better.”  After being forced into silence for years, these women were given the support they should have had all along.

   In addition to the Hollywood actresses he worked with, Harvey also targeted his female assistants. Through the accounts of former assistants Laura Madden, Rowena Chiu and Zelda Perkins, the mountain of evidence that would result in Harvey’s fall from grace begins to be built.

  “This is about more than Weinstein, this is about the system protecting abusers,” Zelda tells Jodi before giving her the letters and court document with conditions she was presented with upon her resignation from Miramax, with instructions for Jodi to use them.

Zelda’s testimony reveals the horrifying truth of how far Harvey and his legal team went to ensure the crimes would stay under the rug: they made it impossible for anyone, employees or Hollywood actresses, to seek help for their mental health. Once the NDAs were signed, they were not permitted to speak to their families or doctors about Harvey’s abuse. They needed permission from him or one of his enablers to talk to a counsellor, with the mental health professional being obligated to sign a confidentiality agreement approved by Harvey and his team, thus ensuring their silence as well.

 We also learn about Harvey’s get-out-of-jail-free card: every time he was accused of sexual harassment, sexual assault or rape, he would swear on the lives of his wife and children that he did not touch the women who accused him of doing so.

   Can you imagine finding out that your husband and father, for years, swore on your life that he never attempted to violate another human being? I feel so much sympathy for his ex-wife and children. I cannot even begin to imagine how they must have felt when that came out, along with the allegations of sexual assault and rape.

   I thought the filmmakers and actors did a fantastic job of portraying the emotional and mental toll that this investigation took on everyone involved. When the team working on the story receives a memo, penned by Lauren O’Connor to bring awareness to Harvey’s treatment of women and his employees, you can see their horror at what they’re reading. Their horror then shifts to anger and disgust at Harvey’s continued lies and denial that he has done anything wrong. The more you lie, the more people start to doubt your credibility as a human being.

    I felt so emotional watching these women agreeing to speak out against the monster who abused his power because I saw myself in them. It takes a great deal of courage to stand up and advocate for yourself, but when you do, you inspire others who have been silenced to do the same.

  The film ends with the team reading the article one last time before a zoomed-in shot of the ‘publish’ button being clicked puts the story out into the world.

  While Megan and Jodi were working on their investigation, another investigative journalist named Ronan Farrow was also working on a story about Harvey Weinstein, and the soon-to-be disgraced movie mogul knew the three reporters were looking into his history. In his efforts to derail their investigations and scare them into silence, Harvey hired Black Cube, a Creative Intelligence organization, to tail both Ronan and Jodi.

  One of the women Ronan spoke to was Ambra Battilana Gutierrez, an Italian lingerie model who Harvey and his lawyers paid off with a million-dollar settlement because they were positive it was enough to keep her quiet. However, unbeknownst to them, she had a police wire hidden on her person and recorded a taped confession between her and Harvey that helped take him down.

This recording is played in She Said, making the montage of empty hotel hallways and closed doors even more unsettling.

  After NBC decided not to run Ronan’s story about Harvey, he took the story to The New Yorker. His moral compass and childhood memories of watching his father sexually abuse his sister drove Ronan’s conviction that this was the right thing to do.

Five days after The New York Times published Jodi and Megan’s investigation into Harvey’s crimes, Ronan’s piece was published in The New Yorker. In 2018, the three journalists, The New York Times and The New Yorker were awarded the 2018 Pulitzer Prize for Public Service. It was a humanitarian act that broke the dam on 30+ years of silence, abuse and suppression.

Jodi and Megan’s determination to uncover the truth inspired women around the world to come forward and share their stories for the first time. The work of these journalists ensured that not only was a voice given back to those who had been silenced for so long, but their courage stoked the fire that ignited conversations about workplace reforms, law changes, known and clandestine reckonings over sexual harassment and violence that are still present today.

In the month following the article’s publication, more than 82 women came forward with allegations of sexual assault, harassment and rape against Harvey.

In February 2020, Harvey was convicted of rape and sexual assault in New York, with additional charges in Los Angeles and London. In August 2022, Harvey and his lawyers attempted to delay his trial on October 10, 2022. They were concerned that the marketing and publicity for She Said would turn the Los Angeles jury against him, but their efforts to delay the trial were denied by Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Lisa Lench. In February 2023, Harvey was sentenced to 16 years in California prison. Upon completion of his sentence there, he must serve 23 years in New York.

Thanks for reading.

Until next time.

Leave a Comment