Redemption and Coming Clean in Cassandra Clare’s The Last Hours: Chain of Thorns

Written By: Lauren Long

Date Published: June 8, 2023

Photo by Hunter Harmon on Pexels.com

“Guilt is one of the most sickening feelings there is. Most people will do anything to avoid feeling it. One can either refuse to accept it, push it away and blame others, or one can take responsibility. One can bear the unbearable weight.”

Alastair Carstairs, The Last Hours: Chain of Thorns, Cassandra Clare

 Well, hello lovely readers! I’m back with a new blog post about the adventures of James and Cordelia Herondale and their friends in the third installment of Cassandra Clare’s The Last Hours series, Chain of Thorns.

   Chain of Thorns picks up where Chain of Iron left off. At the end of Chain of Iron, Cordelia saw Grace Blackthorn embrace James, and she mistakenly assumed that James was still in love with Grace. While initially, James and Cordelia’s marriage was to salvage Cordelia’s reputation and save James from going to prison, the two of them had no say over the growth of their feelings and desire for each other. Before we carry on, I feel as though it is important to mention that James and Cordelia’s marriage, to begin with, is a mariage blanc, which is French for “white marriage.” A white marriage means that there is no consummation between spouses, and reasons may include the rescue of one or both from persecution or damage or to protect a woman from a perilous situation. Other reasons include benefits of an economic, social, or legal nature.

 Because James and Cordelia never had a conversation about their feelings for the other, their miscommunication drives Cordelia to run to Matthew, James’ parabatai, and the two of them leave on the train to Paris at the end of Chain of Iron. While Cordelia and Matthew are in Paris, there are plenty of other things going on. On the same night that they left, Grace was arrested and sent to the Silent City and Lucie, James’ sister made the decision to raise Jesse Blackthorn from the dead. Because the Nephilim are against necromancy, Lucie, Malcolm Fade and Jesse Blackthorn are at Malcolm’s house in Cornwall while they try to figure out how to introduce Jesse when everyone knows that he died receiving his first mark. While Lucie’s intentions were good, she didn’t stop to think about the consequences of her actions. No matter what we do, whether we’re making a decision with good intentions or bad, there is always a price to pay. Lucie is someone who follows her heart and decides in the heat of the moment.

   In addition to Cordelia’s uncertainty about the future of her marriage, she also goes through an identity crisis. In Book 2, she was tricked by Lilith, the mother of Demons, into being her Paladin. Cordelia thought that she was swearing fealty to Wayland the Smith, who made Cortana and its siblings, but Wayland was Lilith in disguise. Because Cordelia was duped by Lilith into becoming her Paladin, Cordelia cannot wield Cortana or any other weapon. Every time she does, Lilith appears. Weapons and defending the world against demons are a large part of a Shadowhunter’s lifestyle and identity, and Cordelia feels lost being not able to use any weapons. She also has quite a bit of anger at herself for being fooled by Lilith.

 Because Chain of Thorns is the third book and the conclusion of the Last Hours series, it means that everything that has been left open needs to be resolved, but before that can happen, the characters must go through the wringer. Because of the tension between James and Matthew, the friendship between James, Matthew, Thomas and Christopher, or the Merry Thieves as they have dubbed themselves, is strained. When we are close friends with more than one person and we all spend time together, the tension between two or more people in the group affects us all. James and Matthew’s friendship is rocky because Matthew left James a letter saying that he and Cordelia were going to Paris before confessing he is in love with Cordelia.

  The friendship between Cordelia and Lucie is also affected by the uncertain state of James and Cordelia’s marriage. Lucie and Cordelia have had a very strong bond since the day Cordelia saved Lucie’s life, and the two of them have been inseparable since the Carstairs family relocated to London. Up until now, their friendship has been full of positive moments, but there comes a time in every friendship and every relationship when we hit rough patches. We are not meant to be perfect and striving to have that picture-perfect relationship, familial, friend or romantic, where no one fights or argues is not realistic. In every single one of her books, Cassandra Clare has mixed reality with the world of the Nephilim. Just because the Nephilim are blessed with angelic abilities and have a mandate to serve and protect the world from the threat of demons, at the end of the day they are just like everyone else. They go through the same ups and downs that we do.

  In addition to the tension between Cordelia and James and Cordelia and Lucie, the friendship between Cordelia and Matthew suffers a blow when Cordelia discovers that Matthew has been lying to her about not drinking while they have been in Paris. Ever since Cordelia found out that her father’s alcoholism was the reason the Carstairs family moved so much, as well as the impact it had on Alastair, Cordelia has very strong feelings about Matthew drinking away his pain. When she finds out he has been lying to her the whole time, she starts to question if she can trust him at all.

  Phew! There is a lot of tension between the characters in this book, but just as we go through ups and downs in life, there must be positive and negative shifts in writing. You cannot have your characters go through life with no obstacles and no setbacks, because that’s not what real life is like. You must let your characters get hurt and then figure out how to move forward, because that’s life, as is the case with Grace Blackthorn. From the very beginning, Grace has been her mother’s blade and the reason for James not being able to confess his true feelings for Cordelia.

  Grace is just as much a victim of her mother’s manipulation as James, Cordelia, and the other men that Grace has used her power on, and while she is no longer her mother’s blade in Chain of Thorns, she does have to face the consequences of her actions. Oddly enough, when Grace is imprisoned in the Silent City, that is the first time in her life that she’s completely free to be herself. While she was not trained as a Shadowhunter, it is revealed that Grace has a scientific mind and is interested in science. We first saw this in Chain of Iron when she asked Christopher to show her what he was working on in Henry Fairchild’s lab, and in Chain of Thorns, the two of them bond over their shared love of scientific pursuits. Because Christopher has found a kindred spirit in Grace, he is the first person to stand up for her and say that he believes her when she escapes from the Silent City with the news that Tatiana is planning something.

   Grace has a redemption arc in Chain of Thorns that begins when she tells Cordelia the truth about what happened between her and James that fateful night, but she also tells her about the bracelet. Grace’s redemption continues through the rest of the book as she and Jesse aid the Merry Thieves, Lucie, Cordelia, Alastair, Anna Lightwood and Ariadne Bridgestock in the race to save London from permanently falling into the hands of Belial, the maternal grandfather of Lucie and James.

 After Grace tells Cordelia the truth, Cordelia and James reconcile and the sexual tension I mentioned in my post for Chain of Iron bursts into flames in the form of steamy love scenes. The thing about the love scenes in Cassandra Clare’s books is you never know what you’re going to get: Some are quite low-key but still romantic, and others are “if we don’t turn down the heat, we’re going to make a baby.”

   When James and Cordelia finally confess their love for each other, it turns the pulse from negative to positive. Friends reconnect and Christopher, after seeing Matthew suffer severe withdrawal symptoms, uses his brilliant mind to create a concoction that helps Matthew to recover from his alcoholism.

Of course, because Cassandra Clare likes to keep us on our toes, things stay good for a while before taking a turn for the worst. From the very beginning of The Last Hours, Tatiana Blackthorn has been the main antagonist. Her bitterness and anger towards losing her husband and her son have erased anything that might have been good about her, so much so that she acts without regret. Her immorality is shown when she kidnaps Alexander, the youngest of Cecily and Gabriel’s three children, from the Institute’s Christmas party and attempts to put a rune on him. This is a dangerous process for children under the age of 12, and Tatiana’s feeling is if she cannot have her son, Cecily and Gabriel’s youngest shouldn’t have the chance to grow up.

 As if kidnapping a child, your own nephew to boot isn’t bad enough, Tatiana and Belial show just how evil and twisted they really are when they steal the bodies of entombed Silent Brothers and Iron Sisters. This is a serious offence because the Silent Brothers and Iron Sisters are the reason the Nephilim have survived. Silent Brothers provide medical services as well as library resources, while the Iron Sisters forge the weapons for the Nephilim to be able to serve the cause. The stolen bodies are called “Watchers” and patrol the city of London in its apocalyptic state.

  By the end of the book, all the issues that were prevalent earlier have been resolved, because the young Shadowhunters whom the Last Hours focused on were able to put their differences aside and realize that they work better together than they do alone. Being egocentric and thinking you know better than everyone else gets you nowhere, and when there are lives at stake, egoism can be costly.

  Redemption and honesty on the other hand can make all the difference in what the outcome of a situation will be.

 Thanks for reading!

  Until next time, xoxoxo

Leave a Comment