Written By: Lauren Long
Date Published: June 27, 2023

“I want to love glitter and also stand up for the double standards in our society.”
Taylor Swift, Miss Americana
Hello, lovely readers! I’m back with another post about none other than the Queen of humility, versatility, and compassion herself, Taylor Swift. Last month, I published a piece on Taylor’s phenomenal Reputation stadium tour. If you have been searching for something to watch on Netflix and are overwhelmed by the never-ending scrolling, I fully recommend Reputation. Grab your friends, your significant other, your pets, and your family and get ready to sing and dance along with Taylor!
Miss Americana and Reputation both show Taylor’s sweet soul, as well as being deeply personal and vulnerable. In Miss Americana, Taylor invites us not only into her home but also the recording studio where all the magic happens. We see her excitement when she has a creative breakthrough in her songwriting, and as a writer, I can relate! When you have had an idea swimming around in your mind for a while and put pen to paper, it is gratifying. What makes it even more exciting is when you push past the creative block and the words finally come out the way you want them to.
Taylor’s storytelling is what sets her apart because she writes original songs. For Taylor, her songwriting is a creative outlet and a mental/emotional release because she is writing about what she’s going through and then putting music to it. Any creative outlet that encourages self-expression is a form of catharsis because by opening ourselves up to this, we give ourselves a safe place to feel and express our emotions while at the same time making others feel something. We may not know it, but a song or story we have written or choreographed a dance to might help someone realize that they are not alone, that there are people who have been through what they are going through and understand what it’s like.
Taylor mentions that she went through a quill and ink phase for songwriting, before going on to talk about the moral code that she has followed since she was a kid: to be thought of as good. Her belief system was to do the good thing and do the right thing. “The main thing I always tried to be was just the good, good girl.”
That really resonated with me, doing the right thing, and being seen as good. My whole life, I have tried to do the right thing and be a good person who upholds her morals and values. It is important to have a moral code and treat others the way you want to be treated while ensuring you do not lose yourself in the process.
Until I watched Miss Americana, I never realized how much of myself I saw in Taylor. I have previously said that I grew up with Taylor Swift in a way because her career started when I was in high school. At sixteen years old, she was the youngest person to write and perform a #1 country song that would change her life forever, and that song was “Tim McGraw.”
While I was trying to survive high school, Taylor was navigating her way through fame while still being a teenager, and holding onto that belief system I mentioned earlier. She hits on a very strong truth when she says that we are trained to be happy when we get a lot of praise and are fulfilled by approval. “Those pats on the head were all I lived for,” Taylor reveals. It is nice to receive recognition for our hard work, but by living for others’ approval, we lose ourselves bit by bit. “I became the person who everyone wanted me to be,” Taylor says.
The first time I watched this documentary and listened to Taylor’s honest words, I was hit by a revelation that struck hard and fast like lightning. How many times had I basked in the praise of others and sought out their approval, forsaking my own happiness in the process?
For a long time, like Taylor, I lived for the approval of others, and I recognized it in the last year of my 20s. I realized that living my life for others and bending over backwards to please them was detrimental to my mental health, and the many years that I lived by this pattern had resulted in me losing who I was. Like Taylor, I became the person the world wanted me to be instead of being myself.
“When you’re living for the approval of strangers and that is where you derive all of your joy and fulfillment, one bad thing can cause everything to crumble.” The bad thing is the moment at the 2009 MTV Video Music Awards when Taylor won the Moon Man for Best Female Video award with her music video for “You Belong with Me.” Kanye West interrupted her acceptance speech by taking the microphone and saying that Beyonce’s video was better and that she should have won instead of Taylor. On what should have been one of the best nights of her life, Taylor was publicly humiliated. The audience booed Kanye for his open display of disrespect, but Taylor thought they were booing her. Kanye’s public denouncement and dismissal of Taylor’s talent and hard work made waves in the news and the music industry and greatly impacted the mental paths she went down, both positive and negative. Jimmy Kimmel, CNN, Dr. Phil and former US President Barack Obama all commented on the rap singer’s actions.
How do you get through that? How do you move past a moment in time where you were on cloud nine and having your hard work rewarded, only to have someone tell you publicly that you didn’t deserve to win, that someone else’s work was better than yours? There are two ways this can be handled: You let that person’s opinion define any future projects, or you shake it off and keep going.
The reason Taylor has made it this far is that her dreams of being a singer and performer were bigger than one person’s opinion. That, and she has an incredible work ethic: “I’m here because I work hard and I’m nice to people. I’m going to prove myself. I’m going to make sure people know I deserve to be here.”
Hard work and being kind will take you a lot further than stabbing people in the back and stepping on them to get to where you want to go. Taylor knew that, and because she stuck to her values and put in the work, she bounced back and came out stronger than ever. She used that experience to inspire new songs that her fans would be able to relate to and became more successful in her career because of it. “I can’t change what’s going to happen to me, but I can control what I write.”
No matter in what capacity success is found, it always feels good when it happens. Now that I am following my dream of being a writer, I understand what Taylor means when she says how great it is to share every little milestone with your family and friends, who are there to share in the joy of your achievements as well as the trials and tribulations faced along the way. I also relate to her when she says that she was experiencing success in her career, but was missing a partner to share it with. I have yet to find the person who I want to call or text the second I get good news and celebrate with him. I have a great family and friends, but it’s hard when everyone has a partner to share those moments with, and you’re the odd one out. As rewarding as accomplishment can be, it doesn’t give you someone to come home to at night, and your career isn’t worth sacrificing everything good in your life.
As successful as Taylor is, she knows that family and friends are important. “You gotta be able to prioritize what really matters to you. For me, it’s my family and friends.”
When I had the idea to start writing these articles, starting with my piece about She Said, it was because I wanted to branch out into more serious topics. I wanted to write about women in the public eye because a lot of what they experience, women who are not in the entertainment industry go through it too. For example, body image shaming.
Taylor opens up about how looking at pictures of herself triggered a dangerous self-critique of her body. “There is always a standard of beauty that you’re not meeting,” she says. “If you’re thin enough, you don’t have the ass everyone wants, but if you have enough weight on to have an ass, your stomach isn’t flat enough.” It’s a double-edged sword for people everywhere, no matter what industry you work in or where you live. I’ve been body shamed for being skinny, but I’ve also been body-shamed for having gained a few pounds and then losing them. There’s no winning with some people because no matter what you do, they will always find something to criticize.
Because Taylor was triggered by the standards of beauty, she stopped eating. She exercised a lot, but our diets play a role in our health as well as exercise because they give us energy. For Taylor, she was struggling with not having the energy to perform on stage without feeling like she was going to faint. Taylor talks about how she realized what she was doing wasn’t healthy, and she told herself to eat food, get stronger, and not starve herself. “It’s better to think you look fat than to look sick.” She addresses the pressure to have the “perfect body,” if there is such a thing, in her music video for “Anti-Hero,” when she’s standing on the scale and the critic (played by herself), shakes her head. This is a moment where the dangers of body dysmorphia and other eating disorders are shown truthfully, and how we can take the abusive opinions of others inside and start to self-offend. I find it hypocritical that Taylor got backlash for this video when the people who judged her for it were the ones who pushed her to that point in the first place.
There are so many dialogues that support the toxic eating cultures in our society and encourage body shaming. We are hit from all sides by others’ opinions of our bodies, from random strangers we meet on the street to the judgements of friends and family, and, of course, the photoshopped and airbrushed covers of magazines and fashion ads. Everyone has a different idea of what true beauty looks like, but when we don’t fit that idea, people criticize and shame us, not just on what our body looks like but also on what our personality is like.
As if being judged for the body you were born with isn’t enough, some people were making comments like “Taylor Swift is annoying” and “She’s too good,” in addition to “She’s too skinny.” Just as there is a double standard for beauty and the ideal body, there’s a double standard for our personality. If we are too nice, people say we are fake, that our compassion isn’t real. If we are shy, we’re labelled as cold and uncaring.
No matter the circumstance, whether it is the way we look or act, people always have something to say. Because Taylor is such a big name and a very well-known artist, her privacy is often disrespected in more ways than one. Her love life is of great interest to the public and was shown to be a target for discussion on Miss Americana. She was criticized for her dating, with one person even going as far as to say “She’s going through guys like a train.”
You would think that after Kanye West had so many people, from celebrities like Pink and Beyonce to talk show hosts and the president of the United States, call him out on his behaviour towards Taylor at the 2009 MTV music awards, he would have learned his lesson. Instead, he recorded a song with certain offensive lyrics where he claims the credit for Taylor’s fame. The truth is, Taylor was already famous by the time that incident happened, he was jealous and made a choice to try and claim some of her spotlight, which backfired spectacularly because it fuelled Taylor’s desire to work harder and show up for herself.
One thing that really bothers me is how catty women can be toward other women. How instead of lifting each other up, they backstab and trash-talk their friends and people they do not even know. This is shown in footage from “The View”, where the hosts are more than happy to diss Taylor after she spoke out about Kanye’s song, saying “I think she saw an opportunity to be victimized here and she thought everybody was going to get on her side.”
I am on Taylor’s side, I always have been, and she doesn’t deserve any of the shade people have thrown at her and she certainly didn’t deserve Kanye West leading people in a “F Taylor Swift” chant at one of his concerts. If I went to a concert and the artist who was performing endorsed and led the audience in that kind of behaviour, I would turn around and walk out. People can love your music, but the thing that makes them admire and respect you is your ability to be a decent human being.
Unfortunately, in the days that followed, headlines that painted Taylor in a negative light became more prominent. Headlines with articles that promote everything I hate about the media and entertainment industry. But it didn’t stop there. There were countless Tweets of people saying that they hated Taylor, with the hashtag Taylor Swift Is Over Party.
Every experience that we go through in life has the potential to make us stronger or break us apart. We can be strong and let those experiences make us stronger, but we can only be tough for so long before something happens to break us open and send us crashing to the ground. The weight of the backlash Taylor was facing took a toll on her, and she did what was best for her: she stepped away from being in the public eye to go to a place where she felt safe. I commend Taylor for looking after herself and giving herself time to regroup and reset. “I had to deconstruct an entire belief system for my own personal sanity.” While our morals and beliefs can stay the same, we change as people. Our life experiences change us. In those quiet moments of self-reflection, Taylor discovered that her happiness did not need the input of others to happen, and this was especially important as she was falling in love with someone.
When we take that time to disconnect from the world and reconnect with ourselves, it’s only a matter of time before the fires of inspiration are stoked again. The backlash Taylor faced was her inspiration for reputation, which is iconic as Taylor’s comeback, and what critics have called “her boldest statement yet.” She took back her career and her life.
Our creative pursuits and passions have a way of spilling into our everyday lives. The emotional release we gain from cathartic practices helps us to find our voice and start speaking up, while simultaneously breaking apart the chains of others’ expectations. When Taylor rose and took back her place in the music industry, she began to use her voice to speak up for social issues and shared her opinion on politics for the first time. “Throughout my whole career, label executives and publishers would just say “Don’t be like the Dixie Chicks,” and I loved the Dixie Chicks,” after the Dixie Chicks were publicly shamed for voicing their political opinion about President George Bush. This moment in history, where the Dixie Chicks spoke out, impacted the society we live in because people who still believe in outdated gender norms were threatened by the idea of women having a voice and using it to challenge the way things have been for too long because it meant that they were no longer in control. As a result, they forced the “nice girl” persona on everyone.
Taylor supports this by saying, “A nice girl doesn’t force their opinions on people. A nice girl smiles and waves and says thank you. A nice girl doesn’t make people feel uncomfortable with her views.” You can be a nice girl and still stand up for yourself and what you believe in. Some people will shove their opinions down your throat in an attempt to make you agree with everything they say, but some people will express their opinions respectfully and listen to what you have to say. As for the discomfort that sometimes accompanies someone expressing their views, Saul Silva from Fate: The Winx Saga said: “Discomfort is where growth lies.” If someone is uncomfortable with something you have said, it’s usually because deep down, they know what you’re saying has truth to it. The truth makes people uncomfortable, especially when they know someone has done something wrong, as Taylor found out when she was groped by a former radio DJ.
Seven people saw him put his hand up her skirt, and after Taylor spoke up about him doing this and he was fired, he sued her for a million dollars, and Taylor countersued for one dollar. He was the one in the wrong, and instead of owning up to his actions, it became a classic case of blaming and shaming the victim while the perpetrator is protected.
Taylor was asked in court “Why didn’t you scream? Why didn’t you react quicker? Why didn’t you stand further away from him?” My question is why were you questioning Taylor when you should have been questioning the man who dared to do what he did? Why are women taught that we are responsible for governing men’s behaviour because we’re not. What we are wearing or how we look is not an invitation.
While there were witnesses to this disgusting act, there were still people who tried to force Taylor to take the blame, even though she had done nothing wrong and there was a photo of him doing this. I share Taylor’s sentiments when she says “I’m angry that this happens to women.” I’m angry that there are people who think it’s perfectly acceptable to violate another person’s space and disregard their feelings and boundaries. I’m angry that there are people who are more interested in protecting those who abuse their power instead of speaking up for those who have been hurt. I’m angry that we don’t feel safe enough to not be constantly looking over our shoulders. “You don’t feel a sense of any victory when you win, because the process is so dehumanizing,” she says before going on to say “This is with seven witnesses and a photo, what happens when you get raped, and it’s your word against his?”
While Taylor was on the Reputation tour, she spoke candidly about how the year before she was on this tour, she was in a courtroom for a sexual assault case, where the jury believed her and ruled in her favour. “I’m sorry to anyone who ever wasn’t believed, because I don’t know what turn my life would have taken if people didn’t believe me when I said that something had happened to me,” she says over the soft notes of the piano.
In addition to Taylor sharing her experiences with disordered eating, sexual assault and the other topics I’ve mentioned, she shows the moment where she expresses her support for basic human rights. She vehemently stated that she didn’t care if the media wrote bad things about her because she was speaking out against Donald Trump and Marsha Blackburn. “I need to do this; I need to be on the right side of history.” She publicly backed two Democrats on Twitter, finally breaking her silence on politics and lifting a heavy weight from her shoulders and her soul. In her “Artist of the Year” award, she encouraged her fans and everyone in the audience to vote in the political election.
There are so many reasons I admire Taylor Swift: her generosity, her love towards her fans, her vulnerability in her music, and her honesty. She’s honest all the way through Miss Americana about everything, including the fact that “It’s a lot to process because we do exist in this society where women in entertainment are discarded in an elephant graveyard by the time they’re 35. Everyone’s a shiny new toy for like two years. The female artists that I know of have reinvented themselves 20 times more than the male artists. They have to, or else you’re out of a job.” Why is that? Why do women who work in entertainment have a time cap on their careers? Why do female artists have to recreate themselves? We all age, so what’s the difference?
“I want to work really hard while society is still tolerating me being successful,” Taylor says. I don’t think success should have a time limit, and if the comments I’ve read on social media are anything to go by, Taylor’s success won’t be ending any time soon, because there are people who are listening to her earlier music, including yours truly, and embrace her newer albums with the same love they did for Taylor’s initial albums from the beginning of her career.
I want to touch a little bit more on the gender norms that are referenced throughout Miss Americana. Taylor talks about her disbelief in Marsha Blackburn becoming the first female senator in Tennessee because “She is Trump in a wig. She represents no female interests. She won by being a female applying to the kind of female that males want us to be in a horrendous 1950s world.”
A world where women don’t have a voice or push back and challenge stereotypes and societal expectations. We’re not at a place where there’s equality for everyone yet and the only way to change that is to encourage conversations about what being equal really means. If you’re waiting for the right moment to step into your power and affect the kind of change you want to see in the world, the time is now. “Resist. If you can shift the power in your direction by being bold enough, then it won’t be like this forever,” Taylor says.
One of the ways to embrace your power is to not allow yourself to be silenced. We all have a voice, and using our voices to speak up and fight for what we believe in is how we break the cycle of silence that others have inflicted on us.
I relate to Taylor when she says “It feels really good not being muzzled anymore, and it was my own doing. It’s time to take the masking tape off of my mouth, forever.” For the longest time, I kept my head down and stayed quiet, because I thought flying under the radar would keep me safe, but as activist Audre Lorde said “Your silence will not protect you.” By not allowing the suppression of our voices any longer, we begin the steps in the journey of becoming the person we want to be, the person we truly are.
“I want to love glitter and also stand up for the double standards that exist in our society. I want to wear pink and tell you how I feel about politics. And I don’t think that those things have to cancel each other out,” Taylor says before adding “I’m trying to be as educated as possible on how to respect people, on how to deprogram the misogyny in my own brain. Toss it out, reject it, and resist it. There is no such thing as a slut. There is no such thing as a bitch. There is no such thing as someone who’s bossy, there’s just a boss. We don’t want to be condemned for being multifaceted.” When you’ve been exposed to misogyny your whole life, it’s hard to take it apart. I’ve always said a lifetime of bad habits is hard to break, like people pleasing, but the first step in the destruction process is recognizing those habits and then taking a sledgehammer to them.
There has been a great deal of hope among Taylor’s fans that she will be asked to perform at the Superbowl Halftime show, and after seeing her performances on Reputation and at the 2019 AMAs, where she performed after winning the Artist of the Decade award, I’m inclined to agree! I think she would be excellent at the Superbowl. What do you think, dear readers? Will we see Taylor on the Superbowl stage within the next few years?
Taylor is one of my biggest role models and inspirations because she shows what can happen when you stay humble and work hard. She showed her lack of ego when she invited other artists such as Idina Menzel, Avril Lavigne and Jennifer Lopez to perform with her on her tour, and they sang their own songs, with Taylor joining in. She sang “Complicated” with Avril, gosh does that take me back, Jennifer’s “Jenny from the Block,” and donned an Olaf costume to belt out “Let It Go” with Idina.
After watching these performances, it just made me respect Taylor even more because by inviting other artists to sing their songs on her tour, she showed that she hasn’t let fame go to her head and that these women and other artists have put in the same work and made sacrifices to get to where they are, just as Taylor herself has. She’s hung onto who she is through everything she has been through when it could have turned out very differently, and she could have let those bad experiences turn her into someone she wasn’t. We always have a choice in how we react to the less-than-positive experiences we go through in life, for better or for worse.
When I think of Taylor Swift, the phrase that comes to mind is “A true Queen builds her empire with the same stones that were thrown at her.”
Thanks for reading.
Until next time, xoxo