Written By: Lauren Long
Date Published: July 11, 2023

“I’m no longer the Winter Soldier. I’m James Bucky Barnes, and you’re part of my efforts to make amends.”
James (Bucky) Barnes, The Falcon and The Winter Soldier
James Buchanan (Bucky) Barnes debuted in the Marvel Universe in the 2011 film Captain America: The First Avenger. Set in 1941, the film premiered on July 22, 2011, and follows Steve Rogers and Bucky Barnes, two kids from Brooklyn, New York, and how they are changed by their experiences of being in the army during the Second World War.
When we met Bucky, he was a young man full of life and about to ship out to Europe to fight in World War II for the freedom of his country and the world. HYDRA, the rogue Nazi science division, took that man and turned him into their puppet.
There is a great controversy that surrounds Bucky Barnes/The Winter Soldier. On one side of the debate, fans declare him a villain, while others say he is a victim. I believe that Bucky Barnes is a victim as much as the people who he was forced to eliminate by his captors.
Bucky is a victim because he had his free will taken away. He was stripped of his identity, autonomy, and everything that made him human by a group of bullies who sought world domination and resorted to murder, underhanded tactics, and corruption to get it. HYDRA took a good man, a decent human being and twisted him into someone they could hide behind while they ordered him to obliterate anyone who stood in their way, including innocent people who were in the wrong place at the wrong time.
Bucky doesn’t strike me as the kind of person who would allow someone to take away who he is without a fight and the reason I say that is because when Steve finds him on the table in the lab, Bucky is repeating his name, rank and serial number. This reiteration shows Bucky still knows who he is and will hang on to his identity with all his might. His character traits of determination, bravery, and steadfastness play a large part in his friendship with Steve Rogers and Bucky’s decision to join Steve’s team, the Howling Commandos.
The terrible things Bucky was forced to do went against his belief system and moral code: to do the right thing and stand up for others. From the moment Bucky breaks free of the people who held him captive for seven decades, he begins to try and piece together who he is again and joins the fight against Thanos.
What do you think? Is James Barnes the villain, or is he a victim?
Thanks for reading!
Until next time, xoxo