Written By: Lauren Long
Date Published: November 29, 2023

“You climb up here with me, it’s one less minute you haven’t lived.”
Logan Huntzberger to Rory Gilmore, “You Jump, I Jump, Jack”
Hello dear readers, and welcome to my final post for November! It’s hard to believe the first of December is on Friday, thus commencing the final month of 2023.
In October, I wrote my first fanfiction in two years with another writer, and the positive attention and reviews it received encouraged me to get back into writing fanfiction. For the past two years, every piece of writing that I’ve done has been work-related or blog-related. I wasn’t doing any writing for fun, and I was beginning to experience burnout because of that.
Following the publication of two Fate: The Winx Saga fanfictions, I was inspired to go back and read two of my older works for Gilmore Girls, a one-shot fix-it of the revival’s fall episode, and an AU multi-chapter of Season 7, because I did not like the ending of the original series. Reading these two stories reminded me of why I started writing Gilmore Girls fanfiction, and it also reminded me of how much I love the relationship between Rory and Logan.
I’m aware that this is an unpopular opinion, but I’m Team Logan for Gilmore Girls. Don’t get me wrong, when Rory started her romances with Dean and Jess, I liked them at the beginning, but her relationship and romance with Logan was the one that stuck. Logan is Rory’s always and forever, in my eyes. They say the people you meet in college are the ones who have the biggest impact on your life, and Logan certainly had an effect on Rory’s life. He saw who she could be if she gave herself the chance to take risks and he encouraged her to get out of her comfort zone.
For the first time in Rory’s life, she had someone who wasn’t pushing her towards something they wanted, Logan was encouraging her to think about what she wanted to do. Because of her upbringing with a teenage single mother, Rory never had the chance to be a kid, she had to assume the role of the adult/parent because Lorelai never really grew up and still acted like a teenager even as an adult. Logan saw how sheltered Rory was, and he inspired her to try new things while also respecting her boundaries. With Logan, Rory learned that there was more to life than working hard and studying, she learned how to have fun and be adventurous. Instead of watching life pass her by, she jumped off the scaffolding into the unknown.
Logan was also very protective of Rory, particularly when it came to his family. He knew what his parents and grandfather were capable of, and when he brought Rory home for the first time, he was practically sitting on top of her to shield her from his mother and grandfather. Honor is the only one who accepts Rory right away, and when Shira and Elias insult Rory, her upbringing and her mother, Logan stands up to them and he gets Rory out of there. What would Dean or Jess have done?
When Richard had his heart attack later on in Rory and Logan’s relationship, Logan dropped everything to come and support Rory and her family. He stepped up like a husband would and made Rory’s well-being and her mental health his main priority while offering support in any way he could to Lorelai, Emily, and Richard.
Despite Rory and Logan’s first meeting, which was admittedly not the best, we soon saw a different side to Logan. Yes, he’s wealthy and the son of a successful public figure in the journalism world and he has a reputation as a ladies’ man, but he’s also sweet and caring. He cares about his friends and as he and Rory spend more time together, the more he cares about her.
Logan won my respect in the scene when he and Rory are in her dorm room, and he’s kissing her good night before she lets him know she isn’t ready to say goodbye to him just yet. Before they take things further than kissing, Logan waits for Rory to give him her verbal consent. By doing so, Logan shows Rory and the audience he isn’t the type to force himself on someone. He doesn’t emotionally manipulate Rory into sleeping with him like Dean did nor does he sexually assault her like Jess. These two incidents of sexual aggression have their own place on my list of zero approval because it really bothers me that Dean lied to Rory about his marriage being over to get her to sleep with him, and it irks me when people gloss over the fact Jess sexually assaulted her, and then say how he was Rory’s best boyfriend. My reaction to that is “Talk to the hand!”
If I was dating someone and he kept trying to get my clothes off after I’d already said no, it would be over before he realized it and I would never give him a second look.
It took me a year and a half to finish watching the series, including the revival. If Rory rejecting Logan’s proposal in Season 7 broke my heart, no scratch that, it tore it apart with a rusty knife, then the revival set it ablaze with a good dose of gasoline thrown on.
The Logan and Rory storyline in Gilmore Girls: A Year in The Life made NO SENSE to me. In the original series, they were in a committed relationship for three years and the fans in the Team Logan camp fell in love with their love story.
When Logan sees Rory with Robert at Finn’s birthday, he experiences something he’s never felt before. Jealousy. Until he met Rory, Logan was the guy who frequently had a different girl on his arm, but he slowly fell for Rory the more time he spent with her. The moment he sees her with Robert is the moment Logan realizes he could potentially lose her, and this realization is cemented when Rory comes to his dorm room to tell him they can go back to being friends, but she doesn’t want to continue being one of the many anymore. Logan knows if he lets her go, that will be it. He went from being with a different girl every couple of days to being a one-woman man because he knew a girl like Rory wouldn’t stay single for long.
The moment Rory moves in with Logan, they immediately fall into a domestic routine. Being together and living together was as easy as breathing for them.
In the revival, the character development of Rory and Logan, and the progress of their relationship in the later seasons was destroyed by the writers and Amy Sherman-Palladino because they completely ignored everything they had developed for the couple. After seeing the original series ending that consisted of Rory and Logan’s breakup because of the rejected marriage proposal, I was looking forward to the revival because I thought it would feature a Rory and Logan who had reconciled and were happily living together.
Instead, the regression of their character development led us back to the Season 5 storyline of Rory and Logan having a no-strings-attached arrangement while Logan is engaged to another woman.
The first words out of my mouth when I finished the revival were, “What the hell did I just watch?” That was in 2020. I haven’t watched Gilmore Girls since I finished it three years ago, because I know how it ends. How does that Taylor Swift song go? “I think I’ve seen this film before, And I didn’t like the ending, you’re not my homeland anymore, so what am I defending now? You were my town, Now I’m in exile, seein’ you out, I think I’ve seen this film before.”
Taylor’s song Exile makes me think of Rory and Logan in the revival. I’ll never watch the series again because I didn’t like the ending, I’ve been watching Rory and Logan clips on YouTube and reading fanfictions dedicated to the couple and that’s good enough for me.
In a conversation with a friend about Gilmore Girls, I shared with her some of what I’d found online in the comment section of the Rory and Logan videos. A couple of days ago, I read a comment that made a lot of sense to me. According to this individual, Alexis Bledel created her own backstory for Rory with all the successes of her 20s because she was unhappy with the script for the revival, and then I watched an interview with both Alexis and Matt Czuchry who shared the sentiment that they were surprised with the revival storyline for their characters. My friend then shared with me that she saw a conversation with Matt where he complained that the characters of Rory and Logan would never have had an affair because that wasn’t who they were.
Matt said in an interview that Rory and Logan have always had a love for each other and they’ve never been able to say goodbye. What must that be like? To find someone when you’re in your early to mid-20s and know with absolute certainty that they are your soulmate. In the case of Rory and Logan, they were ready to factor each other in for wherever they were headed next, only to break up a few episodes later. In the revival, it’s so clear they still love each other, that they are each other’s great loves.
Ann Brashares’ Lena Kaligaris, who was also played by Alexis, said to Tibby Rollins “There are some people who fall in love over and over, and there are others who can only seem to do it once.”
Rory’s relationships with Jess and Dean were the kind we all have in our teen years, the puppy love first relationship and the relationship with the bad boy, but her relationship with Logan and her love for him is the one that truly stays with her. He’s the person she sincerely falls in love with and she even says to Lorelai she feels like Logan is her one. The one she’s meant to spend the rest of her life with. The once-in-a-lifetime kind of love we all hope to find.
Thanks for reading.
Until next time, xoxo