Honest Opinion: Gilmore Girls Straub and Francine Hayden Are the Absolute Worst

Written By: Lauren Long

Date Published: January 5, 2024

Photo by Beyzaa Yurtkuran on Pexels.com

“Christopher’s parents are somehow colder and more obsessed with status than the Gilmores.”

Sarah Schweppe’s “85 “Gilmore Girls” Characters From Worst to Best” On Buzzfeed

Hello and Happy Friday! This is my third blog post about Gilmore Girls, which I am slightly surprised about, but when your brain presents you with an idea you have to run with it. Today, however, I’m not talking about Rory’s love life or her life choices, but about Francine and Straub Hayden, her estranged paternal grandparents.

  The inspiration for this post hit while I was writing my piece “Looking Back, Kindness was a Theme for December,” and in part of the review I received on my fanfiction. I made the choice to write Francine and Straub Hayden into my Gilmore Girls story “You’re My Happily Ever After,” because I wanted to give Rory the chance to stand up for herself to her paternal grandparents, a chance she never got in the show.

   Although the Haydens only appeared in two episodes of the entire series, they managed to make me greatly dislike them. It really bothered me how indifferent, cold and judgmental they were to Rory the one time they met her at the Gilmore residence, and my heart broke for her when she was trying to start a conversation with them and they were looking down their noses at her.

    There have been a lot of fictional characters who have gotten under my skin, which is a sign of good writing. If the writer manages to make you dislike the characters, they’ve done their job. Francine and Straub took that to a whole new level. The abominable way Straub and Francine treated Lorelai and Rory horrified me, and that horror grew even more with how they acted when Lorelai was pregnant, making suggestions about abortion and sending her away. How heartless can you be?!

  Emily and Richard Gilmore may have had their flaws, but they loved Rory and Lorelai. One of my favourite scenes in the series is when Emily and Rory are sitting in the kitchen after the disastrous meeting with the Haydens, and Emily tells Rory that her existence and her person have never been included on the list of past disappointments that were brought up that horrible evening. It’s a really sweet moment, we see a more tender side of Emily, and Rory realizes she can depend on her maternal grandmother.

Emily and Rory share a tender moment 🥹🥹❤️❤️

   I believe that Rory’s catastrophic one-time meeting with her paternal grandparents left a huge psychological scar on her, because how could it not? To only be referred to as “that girl” or “that baby” and never by name would be damaging to anyone’s psyche, especially that of a sixteen-year-old girl who just wanted to get to know her paternal grandparents. I think that’s where Rory’s desperation to be liked by everyone came from because her paternal grandparents didn’t accept or acknowledge her as their grandchild. They cared more about social appearances and standing, and their hearts were just too cold and bitter to love Rory.

   All of that being said, Francine and Straub Hayden are my least favourite characters on Gilmore Girls, and after the way they acted, they didn’t deserve to know their oldest granddaughter.

Leave a Comment