It Takes Two to Tango: Rory and Dean’s Affair

Written By: Lauren Long

Date Published: January 19, 2024

Photo by Ron Lach on Pexels.com

“I think that they had created this character who was so seemingly perfect, that they had to throw something at her, but I think we overcorrected. Clearly, we overcorrected.”

Alexis Bledel on her character Rory’s affair with Dean to Jimmy Fallon in 2016.

As I continue writing my Gilmore Girls fanfiction, more stuff comes up from the show. That is, more things that weren’t resolved. One such thing was the affair between Dean and Rory, and the resulting fallout of the situation.

   Many fans have yet to let Rory live it down, with some even taking the side of Theresa Lister and placing the blame solely on Rory. Others, however, show logic and reasoning in the realization that Rory wasn’t the only one involved. Something that seems to be glossed over is that Dean is just as much to blame as Rory, if not more.

  It takes two to tango, yet society seems to blame the other woman instead of the cheater. Dean was definitely more at fault because he was the one to initiate the near kiss at the Dragonfly Inn and the instigator of the kiss between him and Rory in her bedroom later that day.

  Rory isn’t innocent in this either, she had a choice to stop the kiss and tell Dean to leave, and she should have. But again, she is not solely to blame. Dean was the one to pursue Rory, and the truth is he took advantage of her naivety at a moment when she was vulnerable.

Watch Rory’s body language in this clip

  Dean is the one to show disrespect towards his marriage. More than once, Rory reminds Dean about Lindsay at her dorm and Lorelai’s house, even offering suggestions, like counselling and going away together, to improve Dean and Lindsay’s marriage. She did that, and Dean chose to lie to Rory and Lindsay, playing them both. He lies to Rory, saying that he and Lindsay aren’t happy, their marriage is over and they are getting a divorce, and then he gaslights and emotionally and verbally abuses Lindsay at home after he sleeps with Rory.

 The writers made a huge mistake in having Rory throw away her morals and values the way she did at that moment, all because they wanted her to lose her virginity to her first boyfriend. Alexis Bledel even said that she thinks they went too far with that and it shouldn’t have happened that way because it wasn’t who Rory was.

  As a side note, Lindsay’s mother was far too involved in her daughter’s marriage. I honestly believe had the affair not occurred, the marriage between Dean and Lindsay would have ended eventually because of how much her parents were around. It was a doomed marriage from the beginning. A relationship sinks when it has too many passengers.

Thanks for reading!

Enjoy your weekend and I will be back next week! Stay safe and stay warm!

Until next time, xoxo

Leave a Comment