Written By: Lauren Long
Date Published: January 24, 2024

“I don’t want to talk to anybody else. I don’t like anybody else.”
Jess Mariano to Rory Gilmore
Hello, dear readers, and Happy Wednesday! I hope you all had a great weekend and a good start to the week! I don’t know what it is this month, but my brain seems to be on a Gilmore Girls kick because this is the third piece I’ve written about one of the show’s characters. After I published “It Takes Two To Tango” last week, I was talking to a friend about it and I came to the conclusion that if I wrote about Logan and Dean, it was only fair to write about Jess. With that being said, let’s dive into Rory’s second boyfriend.
In the beginning, I did like Jess; he was the bad boy and I definitely had my moments as a teenager where I liked the bad boy, even if it inevitably led to my heart breaking. Had I watched the show as a teenager, maybe I would have been a diehard Team Jess, but since I watched it as an adult in her late twenties, I have a very different opinion. The perspectives we have as teenagers and adults are vastly different.
My feelings towards Jess started to change as I realized he wasn’t good at communication and how he treated people. He showed blatant disrespect towards Luke, Lorelai, Rory and Rory’s relationship with Dean. He shamelessly pursues Rory when she’s in a relationship with Dean, disregarding her efforts to set boundaries, as well as entering her room without consent the first time he meets her, which gives off major creepy vibes.
For Jess, it was always about the chase with Rory, he only wanted Rory when he couldn’t have her, first with Dean and later with Logan. It always bugged me that Jess treated Rory more like an object instead of a person, and once they started dating, he even said he felt like he didn’t have to put the effort in because he had her. The relationship between Jess and Rory was never one of equals, it was always her waiting for him by the phone, and then when she made the choice to not wait around anymore and do things with other people, Jess would show up and expect her to be waiting for him and be angry when she wasn’t.
These are all major red flags, but the moment where I completely lost my respect for him was when he sexually assaulted Rory at the party. So many people gloss over that or say it wasn’t sexual assault, and I feel as though their dismissal allows for the continuation of perpetuating rape culture in television, film and society.
RAINN’s definition of sexual assault is as follows: “The term sexual assault refers to sexual contact or behaviour that occurs without explicit consent of the victim.” Rory repeatedly tells Jess to wait, he doesn’t listen and continues to kiss her while unzipping her jeans, and when Rory pushes him off of her, Jess gets angry at her for saying no. Not cool, no means no and stop means stop.
I’ve read a lot of people’s opinions online which say that Logan is Rory’s Christopher, but I believe that Jess is actually Rory’s Christopher. He was unreliable, he left Rory more than once without saying a word or letting her respond, he wouldn’t take no for an answer, and he came in and out of Rory’s life when he felt like it.
Another thing that bothers me about Jess is the hypocrisy and judgment he shows towards Rory about Yale. In Season 4, Jess asks Rory to run away with him and leave Yale and her family behind. Still, in Season 6, he yells at her and shows a pretty serious holier-than-thou attitude towards her decision to take time off of school, even though he asked her to run away with him and do the very thing he is judging her for. Jess remembers Rory as the 17-year-old girl he fell for and doesn’t realize she is not that young anymore.
It’s hinted more than once that Rory is the one who got away for Jess, and the revival shows that he is still not over her, even after they haven’t been a couple for 15 years. After the events of the revival, that is, the marriage of Lorelai and Luke, it would be weird if Rory and Jess ended up together because they are kind of related now.
Thanks for reading!
Until next time, xoxo