Written By: Lauren Long
Date Published: February 7, 2024

“There’s plenty of upside to being the spawn of the fabulously wealthy. But the downside? Super successful parents expect nothing less from their offspring. And when it comes to college, that means the Ivys. It’s more than just getting into college, it’s setting a course for the rest of your life. And for those few who aren’t legacies, the pressures are no less. When parents have sacrificed for their children’s futures, what kid would want to let them down?”
Gossip Girl, Episode 1×03: Poison Ivy
Hello dear readers, or should I say Upper East Siders? It’s been a while since my last post for Gossip Girl, and I figured it was time for another update about Manhattan’s elite On the screen today: episode 3 of Season 1, Poison Ivy, where the students of Constance Billard and St. Jude’s find themselves under familial pressure as they take part in Ivy Week, which will determine their chances of getting into Ivy League colleges and, by extension, their futures.
But familial pressure about what comes after high school isn’t the only thing on their minds. Serena and Lily are worried about Eric, Blair wants to know why Serena came home with no notice, Chuck is B’s partner in crime, and Nate struggles with familial expectations. Meanwhile, in Brooklyn, Dan worries about getting into Dartmouth, his dream college. My, my. There’s lots packed into episode 3, so who’s ready to dive in?
To quickly recap, Blair and Serena reconnect, only for the bridge to burn when Nate tells Blair about his affair with Serena. In episode 2 The Wild Brunch, Blair reveals to Serena that she knows of their infidelity. A public confrontation followed, and not only has Serena managed to alienate herself from Blair, Nate, and Chuck, but Dan as well, who decides he wants nothing to do with her after finding out she doesn’t fit the image in his head.
I think that’s a very human reaction. We get so used to seeing one side of someone or having this idea of who they are that when we find out there is more to them and that they have flaws, it’s difficult to grasp. That’s why it’s important not to put people on a pedestal and to look past the surface and see what’s on the inside.
Following the events of episode 2, things between Serena and Blair are still ice-cold, but the heat of familial pressure is turned up to the max as the younger set of Upper East Siders prepares for the finish line of Ivy Week.
Your university years are the ones where you discover yourself, and when you begin receiving acceptance letters to colleges, you begin to set the course for the rest of your life. For Ivy Week, everyone has expected roles, the girls in the junior class are in charge of the Friday night mixer, whilst the boys compete for the coveted usher spots for visiting school representatives. Dan is hopeful that he will receive the Dartmouth usher spot.
When I watched this episode, something that really stood out to me was, “Remember, you’re not only representing the school but your family and yourselves.” I didn’t grow up in the world of the Upper East Side, but I think that the reminder of all sides of representation applies to us all, no matter what social class we come from.
Nate’s father is pushing him toward Dartmouth, reminding his son of the plan that the Captain and his wife came up with for Nate. “Dartmouth, law school, Blair.” I felt for Nate here because, even though we’re only three episodes in at this point, he is shown to be a bit of this lost soul in this world of privilege he’s been born into, and he wants to carve out his own path, but he also wants to make his family proud. It’s a tough position for anyone to be in because we all want to find our place in the world, but we also want the approval and acceptance of our family, and it’s difficult when we feel like we’re being pushed through one door without having the chance to open the others.
Whereas Nate is struggling with his family’s expectations, Blair is going full-steam ahead. She has known from a very young age that she wants to attend Yale because that’s where her father went, and she thinks fondly of the Yale sweatshirt her dad gave her.
Serena wants to attend Brown, but on the morning when the ushers are being interviewed, she misses the assembly. Yikes. The frostiness between the two shows in Blair’s verbal aggression when she says to Serena, “Oh! Too bad you missed the assembly. Not that it matters. Brown doesn’t offer degrees in Slut.”
Teenage girls can be very aggressive towards each other, especially when it comes to boys, and the hostility between Blair and Serena becomes physical on the field hockey field. Physical confrontations are never good, nor are they a constructive way to solve problems.
Meanwhile, the St. Jude boys go through the interview process of why they should be chosen as an usher to the Ivy League representatives. Once again, the class differences come into play. Chuck and Nate have trust funds and familial connections, but Dan doesn’t. The offspring of legacy families like the Waldorfs, Basses, van der Woodsens and Archibalds are given first choice. It isn’t fair, but money and influence play a big role in scenarios like this.
After finding out that he didn’t get the Dartmouth spot, Dan takes his anger and frustration out on Serena and his dad. We saw a glimpse of how judgmental he can be in The Wild Brunch, but this episode is where that personality trait really rears its head because he judges Serena at the mixer and after the assembly.
The class difference I mentioned earlier and not having familial influence and connections is summed up by Jenny to Rufus when she says, “We’re Humphreys, Dad. We’re not exactly royalty uptown.” Even though Rufus and his wife Allison have made sacrifices so that Jenny and Dan can attend schools like St. Jude’s and Constance and go to the college of their choice, Dan is ungrateful when his father tries to get Dan the Dartmouth usher position. Rufus has the best interests of his children at heart, and he does this for Dan because the Dartmouth representative also happens to be an author that Dan loves.
Meanwhile, Chuck and Blair put their heads together to figure out why Serena came home, and Chuck followed her to the Ostroff Center. Chuck and Blair are on the same intellectual level, and they’re both tenacious when they want to know something. That tenacity clouds their judgment and they don’t realize that what they think is going on is actually not the case at all.
Lily and Serena are butting heads over Eric’s recovery, and Eric feels like he doesn’t have a voice. He feels like all the decisions are being made for him, and he’s completely capable of speaking for himself. Counselling sessions are tough because there are a lot of emotions involved as well as trying to make sure that everyone feels heard. Constructive communication can be really difficult when one person wants one thing, and the other person wants something else.
At the mixer, Serena tries to sabotage Blair’s chances of getting accepted into Yale, and Eric is asked by Bart Bass and Howard Archibald how he enjoyed his time in Miami. No one knows the truth, and even though Eric and Jenny have only met once, they have a bonding moment. I think the reason they connect is because they’re both outsiders in a way. Eric feels really lonely and Jenny can sympathize and relate because she’s on the outside looking in at the glamour and fashion of this world that is very different from the one she was born into. Eric tells her his mom says she chose the Ostroff Center because they have the best counsellors, “But what they really get paid for is to keep their mouths shut.”
Having been in counselling for almost six years, I know firsthand the value of having a counsellor who you know is going to keep what you tell them in confidence private because I’ve come across some who don’t. So, while Eric may seem cynical about the counsellors’ true intentions, I can say with utmost certainty that having professionals who keep the subjects their patients divulge in their sessions is relieving. I can talk to my counsellor and know she’s not going to repeat anything I say to anyone else, the only exception to that being if she thought I was going to hurt myself or someone else.
The whole episode has been fraught with tension, and two major things happen at the mixer. Nate sees how much Dan wants to go to Dartmouth, gives him an opening to go talk to the Dartmouth representative, and tells his father to back off when the Captain sees his son walking away, finally telling him that he doesn’t want to follow his father’s plan for him.
Chuck invites Dr. Donald Ostroff from the Ostroff Center, and Blair, who is the chair of the Community Outreach Committee, incorrectly outs Serena as being a patient at the treatment center. The horrified van der Woodsens look on as Eric begins to approach the stage but Serena, desperate to protect her brother, stops him and walks up herself. “Don’t try to deny it, Chuck saw you,” Blair says.
As Serena speaks, Dan finds out the truth from Jenny that Eric is the one at the center, and Dan realizes his mistake in being quick to judge. Acknowledging that he was wrong, he goes after Serena to apologize and offers to listen if she wants to talk.
Blair isn’t the only one whom Serena has had tension with since she came home, things have also not been great between her and Lily. Serena has a reputation, and her mom still sees her as the person Serena was before she went away. Lily realizes how distant she is from her daughter when they have words after Serena’s speech, and she tells her, “We are still a family,” which is why Serena did what she did.
Eric, furious that Serena’s protection of him came at the cost of potentially blowing her future, confronts Blair. She’s so angry at Serena that she attempts to brush Eric off when he defends his sister, but that anger dissolves when Eric reveals he’s a patient at the Ostroff Center and shows her his cut wrist.
This moment is a really good bit of acting between Leighton Meester and Connor Paolo. Blair’s expression goes from smug to remorseful as she instantly realizes she went too far. When she tries to apologize, it’s Eric’s turn to brush her off. “Well, It must be a shock for someone who thinks she has everything,” is his parting shot.
Blair’s rashness and desire to get back at Serena ended up hurting three people who she is very well-acquainted with. It’s a classic moment of not only recognizing that she went too far but also that she judged before knowing the full story.
The episode ends with Blair and Serena making amends. Blair knows Serena well enough to know she can find her at the fountain in Central Park whenever something is bothering her friend, and it’s here that they reconcile, with Blair emotionally reading a letter that she wrote, but never sent, to Serena when she was at boarding school.
The letter reveals how much Blair misses and needs Serena, and they both acknowledge that they have made mistakes.
What were your thoughts when you watched Poison Ivy for the first time?
Thanks for reading!
Until next time, xoxo