Written By: Lauren Long
Date Published: March 29, 2024

“The real truth . . . divorce papers from your father and I’m supposed to sign them. I haven’t yet.”
Eleanor Waldorf to Blair Waldorf, Gossip Girl, “Blair Waldorf Must Pie!”
Hey, Upper East Siders. As we head into the Easter Long Weekend, I can’t help but think about the ninth episode of Gossip Girl, “Blair Waldorf Must Pie!” On the Upper East Side and across the bridge in Brooklyn, everyone is in the holiday spirit, but for how long? Family reunions for the Humphreys and Waldorfs are on the menu, but will they be satisfying or a disaster? One thing’s for sure, this will be a Thanksgiving to remember in more ways than one as secrets come to light and old rivalries resurface. Let’s not keep the holidays waiting, shall we?
In episode nine, there are so many things that happen that could have inspired a piece of writing. In my post last week for episode seven, Victor, Victrola, I said that these past three episodes are some of my favourites. When I first had the idea to write about “Blair Waldorf Must Pie!”, I knew that the focus would be on Blair, her eating disorder, and her relationship with her mom.
Throughout the past eight episodes, there have been hints dropped in three of those that Blair has an eating disorder, and through a series of flashbacks to those episodes, we see that it’s been going on since Serena came home. The eating disorder that Blair has been diagnosed with is bulimia nervosa, and in a flashback to Thanksgiving the previous year, Harold Waldorf is seen reassuring his wife that Blair is fine after their daughter has stated she’s not hungry. “Honey, she’s fine. She has been for two months,” Harold tells Eleanor.
In the present day at the Waldorfs’ catered Thanksgiving dinner, Eleanor pushes Blair into making herself purge. Blair’s struggle with bulimia is talked about in the books, and I thought the writers and showrunners of Gossip Girl did a really good job of showing Blair’s internal battle. She’s been working to not let her bulimia control her, but as with any mental health illness, you always have setbacks and you always have bad days. What matters is how you choose to deal with those.
For Blair, she chooses to deal with it by calling Serena, someone she feels safe with and whom she knows isn’t going to judge, and asking her to come. This is a very important message to send to viewers. Eating disorders, depression and anxiety are all defined as mental health illnesses, and part of the treatment/recovery is ensuring you have people around you who you know will not judge or shame you if you have a setback, but instead offer compassion, empathy and a safe space. “I didn’t mean for it to happen,” says Blair to Serena. Serena knows what’s going on, and she drops everything at the Humphreys to go to Blair’s. Their disagreement at the beginning of the episode is quickly forgotten as Serena comforts Blair and offers her the support and love she needs at that moment.
I only wish that we had seen more of Blair’s storyline with her eating disorder, including her therapy sessions with the counsellor she was seeing who helped her work through it. I think that would have done a lot for raising awareness about eating disorders and how important it is to know that it’s okay to ask for help. Blair’s battle with bulimia is her attempt to regain some kind of control, and I know that because I have experimented with bulimia in the past whenever I felt overwhelmed.
Eleanor may play a role in Blair’s setback in the episode, but she is shown to be remorseful when Blair returns home. This episode is where the relationship between the Waldorf women is explored more. We’ve seen little glimpses here and there, but there are more interactions between the two of them in this episode.
I previously said that Blair puts on the tough act to hide her vulnerability. Well, Eleanor is the same way. In all the other instances we’ve seen her, she’s been portrayed as this tough-as-nails, shrewd woman, but in this episode, we see her in a completely different light.
When Blair and Eleanor are talking in the kitchen, we see Eleanor let her guard down for the first time, and I feel as though it’s the first time Blair sees that too. Up until now, Eleanor has switched personas with her daughter, and the moment Eleanor tells Blair that Harold wants a divorce, we see a more sensitive side to her. She steps out of that cunning businesswoman role to show a woman who is grieving the loss of her marriage. Blair’s vulnerability comes from her mother, and when Eleanor shows Blair the divorce papers she’s meant to sign but hasn’t yet, it’s the first time she really opens up to her daughter. Eleanor has been acting like she’s fine, but the moment she shares her feelings about her and Harold’s divorce with her daughter, Blair realizes that her mom is hurting too.
When Eleanor says, “I couldn’t face him during the holidays. It was always our happiest time,” you feel for her. You feel her grief and her sadness at the loss of the life she and her husband shared for nearly two decades. Blair realizes this too, and she shows her softer side when she wordlessly pulls her mom into a hug and Eleanor hangs on. We all need a hug sometimes. When words fail, we all need some sort of physical contact to know that we’re not alone.
Blair and Eleanor take solace in each other, and their heart-to-heart in the kitchen is the beginning of the acceptance stage of the five stages of grief. For the first time, they’re accepting that just because nothing in their lives is ever going to be the same again, it doesn’t mean they won’t be happy.
On that note, have a Happy Easter and I will see you in April!
Thanks for reading!
Until next time, xoxo