Debutantes and Drama in Gossip Girl: 1×10

Written By: Lauren Long

Date Published: April 5, 2024

Photo by Matheus Oliveira on Pexels.com

“Hey Upper East Siders, it’s that time of year again. When the mere act of descending a staircase means you’re a woman. That’s right: Debutante season. And from what we hear, there’s been some changes to the lineup.”

Gossip Girl, 1×10: Hi, Society, Gossip Girl

Hey Upper East Siders, word on the street is it is debutante season in Manhattan, and Blair, Chuck, Nate and Serena are preparing for cotillion. In Season 1’s tenth episode, Hi, Society, drama and long-hidden truths emerge amidst the dazzling backdrop of the young men and women on the Upper East Side entering society.

   Before we dive into today’s post, allow me to give some background on debutante balls. These formal events span through history, going back to the eighteenth century. Traditionally, they were intended as an opportunity for young women to be presented into society and focused on marriage prospects with high society partners. Today, young women between 16 and 22 are introduced into society as a rite of passage, which signifies the transition from young adolescence into mature adulthood.  Maturity is something that Blair shows throughout the episode as she and Chuck continue their secret romance, which has become hot and heavy since her seventeenth birthday.

  However, there are still some feelings between Nate and Blair. They are each other’s first loves, and with first loves comes a certain nostalgia. Through a conversation with Chuck, we learn that Nate has noticed the changes in Blair: she’s lighter and happier. “I think I might miss her,” he admits. On Chuck’s part, he’s beginning to feel more for Blair. What started as intrigue has shifted to more, and he doesn’t want anything to get in the way of his burgeoning relationship with Blair, which is thrown for a hoop when Blair and Nate agree to go to the ball together as friends.

  Meanwhile, Dan and Jenny are out of their league at one of the ball’s dance rehearsals. Lily has softened significantly towards the younger Humphreys’, even inviting Jenny to volunteer on the night of the society event. As much as Jenny feels out of her depth, she can’t help but be enthralled by the grace and elegance of the cotillion dance, something I share with her. When you see something beautiful, it’s hard to tear your eyes away.

 Unfortunately, Jenny’s fascination and desire to be part of the world that Blair and her friends were born into causes her to clash with her mother. The more time Jenny spends in the world of the Upper East Side, the more she loses herself because she is reminded every day of the differences in their socio-economic status, and her sense of inferiority causes her to lash out at Alison, saying, “The kids I go to school with shop at Saks and Bendel’s. I can’t be seen walking around in someone else’s old shoes.” Alison grounds Jenny, although I’m not sure if it’s because of her impertinence or because she wants to keep her away from Lily after Lily reveals that she asked Jenny to volunteer at Cotillion, which is the same night as the opening of Alison’s art show at the Humphreys’ gallery. Maybe it’s a mix of both. Either way, after Lily’s speech about how debutante balls and the preparation that goes into them teach young girls good social graces, Alison departs.

   The topic of good social graces comes up more than once in Hi, Society. Their importance is first referenced by Serena’s maternal grandmother, Celia “CeCe” Rhodes. “The cotillion teaches the good graces that women should always have in their arsenal.” A few scenes later, Lily paraphrases her mother’s words in her conversation with Alison. 

   While I was writing this, my mom and I talked about social graces and how they seemed to have become a lost art. No matter our gender or how we’re communicating with someone, politeness, compassion and assertiveness go a long way. In recent years, that’s been forgotten, and I think it’s a shame.

   CeCe comes from a time and generation where the people from the upper class didn’t really mix with those of the middle- and lower class. She is very set in her ways and holds fast to the beliefs that she was raised with: a woman has to earn the right to create her own rules, and women raised in high society should marry within their own social circles. She doesn’t approve of Serena’s relationship with Dan, much like how she didn’t approve of Rufus with Lily, because of their class differences and different social status. To make Serena take part in the debutante ball and enter into society, CeCe arranges for Carter Baizen to be Serena’s escort, then manipulates her granddaughter and daughter by saying the doctors may have found something in her lungs.

    CeCe isn’t shy in letting Dan know of her disapproval of his and Serena’s relationship, which is shown in her brutally honest dialogue when she points out all of the class differences that exist between Dan and Serena and have already caused problems in their relationship. The world of wealth and privilege that Serena and her friends are part of, they were born into, you can’t buy your way in. CeCe knows this because she has already experienced this with Lily and Rufus when they were Dan and Serena’s age.

  Through all the hints dropped since the season began, it has been very evident that Rufus and Lily have a history. In episode nine, Blair Waldorf Must Pie, it was explosively revealed that Rufus and Lily dated, and Alison has always been jealous because Lily was Rufus’s first love and they’ve never really gotten over each other.

  In Hi, Society, Rufus is shown to be aware of CeCe’s disapproval of him, but he refuses to be bought off as part of CeCe’s efforts to ensure Dan doesn’t escort Serena. He also knows how manipulative she can be, but what he doesn’t know is how far CeCe was willing to go to stop his and Lily’s romance from going any further. She was so against them being a couple that she gave Lily an ultimatum. She told her daughter to choose between Rufus and her inheritance which, sadly, is something that happens in real life. This shocks Rufus, as he was always under the impression that Lily left him for another man. It is mind-boggling, the lengths that some parents will go to make sure their children choose what they think is the right choice, without considering that the very thing they are forcing them to choose between could be what makes them the happiest.

   Finally, I want to talk about the formal attire when the debutantes and their escorts are lined up on the staircase as they wait to be presented to society. The men are all dressed in tuxedos and wearing gloves, while the women wear beautiful floor-length gowns, gloves and corsages. Traditionally, debutante dresses are white, as we saw in Gilmore Girls when Rory has her coming out into society.

   On Gossip Girl, however, the dresses of Blair, Serena and their fellow debutantes are different colours and styles. I think that the wardrobe department and the writers made this choice so that the audience wasn’t looking at a sea of white, but also to reflect the personalities of the characters.

   For example, Serena’s gown is gold, which is the colour of success, achievement, triumph, wealth and high status, and is linked to luxury, quality, reputation, sophistication and elegance. These are reflected in the accessories of Serena, Lily and CeCe, who both wear black. While black can be connected with mortality, mourning, dark magic, and obscurity, it represents elegance, power, control, and affluence as well.

  Blair’s silver gown is also related to riches, as well as modernity, allure, poise and elegance. Every time we see Blair on screen, she’s very well put-together and she always looks chic and sophisticated. She has that Old Hollywood glamour look about her, which is not surprising since Audrey Hepburn inspired her in all areas of her life, including her personal style.

  Well, that’s it for today. But never fear, I’ll be back soon with another update about our favourite Upper East Siders.

   Thanks for reading!

   Until next time, xoxo

Leave a Comment