Written By: Lauren Long
Date Published: April 12, 2024

“Hear those silver bells? It’s Christmas time in the city. Some families actually do make the yuletide gay, managing to leave their troubles far away.”
Gossip Girl, Gossip Girl, Episode 1×11: Roman Holiday
Hey Upper East Siders, is there anything more wondrous than the streets of New York at Christmastime? Gossip Girl’s eleventh episode Roman Holiday shows the hustle and bustle of the city as New Yorkers on both sides of the bridge prepare for the festive season amidst the twinkling lights.
But not everything sparkles during the holidays. Sometimes, it can be the moment when secrets come out and the dynamics of our family lives shift, changing our world once more. The Waldorfs, Humphreys and van der Woodsens all experience this in Roman Holiday.
When the episode begins, Blair is excited because she’s seeing her dad for the first time since he left town, and she is planning to convince him to stay in New York. Blair is someone who doesn’t like change, which I can relate to, I have difficulty adjusting to new routines and having new people around, and even though Blair’s parents are separated and in the process of getting divorced, she still wants everything to be as it was. She doesn’t want her dad to be across the ocean in Paris, she wants him to stay in New York so she can have the stability of having both parents in the same place. Blair is, I feel, closer to her dad than to her mom, and she feels betrayed when she arrives home and discovers that her father has brought Roman with him so that he and Blair can get to know each other.
I feel as though this is a poorly thought-out move on Harold’s part, springing something like that on your kids, no matter how old they are, can be unsettling for them because it causes them to start questioning what their place in your life is. We saw this in Ann Brashares’ Sisterhood of The Traveling Pants when Carmen’s dad didn’t tell her he was getting married but instead surprised her with a new neighbourhood, a new house and his fiancée and her two children.
Both Blair and Carmen lash out because they’re feeling hurt and because their world has suddenly shifted on its axis and they’re trying to find their footing again. I often wondered why Carmen and Blair didn’t tell their dads how they were feeling right away and instead let their emotions take over, in Carmen’s case, she threw a rock through the window and Blair invited Freddy, an old flame of Roman’s, to her mother’s Christmas Eve party in hopes of breaking her father and Roman up. After a lot of thought, I realized that at the time, they were both still teenagers figuring out who they were and how to react to certain situations.
Our emotions can be a really tricky thing, and in those moments where we’ve had a curveball thrown at us out of left field, it’s easy to let them take over, which makes it difficult to speak up for ourselves. Eleanor, who, understandably, still hasn’t forgiven Roman for stealing Harold, becomes her daughter’s champion when she figures out that Blair invited Freddy intentionally. She’s not happy with how her daughter chose to handle it, but at the same time, she understands why. Their moment in the kitchen on Thanksgiving helped Eleanor grow closer to her daughter, which helped in this moment. Eleanor recognizes that Blair is lashing out at Harold non-verbally, and instead of being hard on Blair, she talks her ex-husband down from doing so. She reminds him that Blair is a mix of them both and that even though she’s 17, she’s not a full-fledged adult yet. “She tries really hard to act all grown up, but don’t you be fooled. She’s still a little girl. Who needs her daddy.”
Harold realizes his mistake in hoping that if everyone was thrown together, Blair would instantly love Roman too and he reconciles with Blair. It’s a really nice moment between father and daughter because just as Blair and Eleanor had an open, honest conversation at Thanksgiving, Harold and Blair have one on Christmas Eve. She tells him how she feels like there’s no place for her in her dad’s life anymore, and Harold reassures her that he is. Just because he and Eleanor aren’t married anymore, it doesn’t mean Blair isn’t his daughter anymore and no matter who he’s with, it doesn’t mean he’s going to stop loving Blair.
I said at the end of my post for Blair Waldorf Must Pie! that Blair and Eleanor both realize that just because they went through the painful experience of having a husband and father leave them for someone else, it doesn’t mean they’ll never be happy again. In this episode, both of them realize that their family has expanded with Roman and that Blair now has three parents who love her.
As the Waldorf family dynamics shift in Manhattan, so do the Humphreys at the loft in Brooklyn. When Rufus, Alison, Dan and Jenny are putting up the Christmas decorations, it’s revealed that even though Alison asked Rufus to stay away from Lily so they could make their marriage work, Alison herself has continued to be unfaithful. She’s shown a great deal of hypocrisy because she’s been carrying on with Alex, the neighbour in Hudson with whom she slept, and she hasn’t been honest with Rufus, which in turn hurts both her children. Both Rufus and Alison admit that no matter how much they might wish things were different, their marriage is over because the trust is gone.
Jenny is also someone who doesn’t like change and wants things to stay the same. “I thought that if I got them under the same roof, things would go back to the way they were,” she says to Dan. It’s a difficult thing to accept, but change is part of life, positive or negative. And when change happens, we have two choices: we can hang on to the way our lives used to be with all our might, or we can let go and change and evolve too. The first option sounds easy, but in reality, it’s really hard. We hang on because we want what’s comfortable and familiar, but in doing so, we inhibit ourselves. As scary as the second option is, because we’re leaping into the unknown, it allows for growth. A wise man once said, “Discomfort is where growth lies.”
The lives of the Humphreys are changed by Alison and Rufus’ decision to split up, but as Alison says to her children on Christmas morning, “We’re going to be okay.” Just as with Blair learning that her father doesn’t love her any less because he and her mother are no longer together, Dan and Jenny will continue to be loved by both their parents, their separation and imminent divorce doesn’t change that.
Finally, Lily, who has secretly been seeing Bart Bass, reveals to Serena and Eric that they’re dating, only to find out at the end of the episode that Bart has been thinking about more than just a committed relationship. He proposes to Lily, changing the lives of her, her children and Chuck forever. Quite the episode that shows the many ways that family dynamics can shift, and how families themselves can shrink and expand.
Thanks for reading!
Until next time, xoxo