Expected Duties and Social Issues in Sword Catcher

Written By: Lauren Long

Date Published: May 3, 2024

Photo by Pixabay on Pexels.com

“I am the Prince’s shield. I am his unbreakable armor. I bleed that he might not bleed. I suffer that he might never suffer. I die that he might live forever.” ~Cassandra Clare, Sword Catcher

  Hello all, and Happy Friday! It’s time to revisit one of my favourite authors but with a new story. Sword Catcher is Cassandra Clare’s first novel for adults and the first of the Castellane Chronicles. I received this novel for Christmas, and it kept me up at night as my brain ran through the possible routes the story was going to go. There was more than one evening where I stayed up reading past my bedtime because I just had to know what was going to happen next!

  Garnering praise from authors like George R.R. Martin and Leigh Bardugo, Cassandra Clare once again proves herself a master wordsmith and storyteller as she brings her writing mastery to new heights.

 Sword Catcher centers around Kel Saren and the Crown Prince of Castellane, Conor Aurelian. The first time we meet both boys is in the prologue when they are 10 years old. Kel is brought to the Palace from the kingdom’s orphanage, saving him from a life of poverty, to become Conor’s Sword Catcher, or bodyguard. The two of them grow up together and have forged a strong bond that lasts into adulthood. When the story picks up 10 years later, they’re in their early 20s.

  Both Conor and Kel have their own set of struggles. As the future King of Castellane, Conor must wed so that he can provide heirs for the future, thus ensuring that the House of Aurelian will not fall. Conor knows what is expected of him as heir to the throne, but he is very reluctant to get married and expresses this to Kel. Conor is an only child, so he is the only one who can ascend the throne, which is where Kel comes in.

  Kel is an orphan, Conor’s confidant, and the prince’s body double, Sword Catcher. He’s known, since coming to the Palace at the age of 10, that he has to die in Conor’s place, should the worst happen. Kel has accepted this, but as the book goes on, he begins to question if he knows Conor as well as he thinks he does, due to a series of events, and he also realizes a desire to have his own life and his own identity. He’s been taught to act like the crown heir and dress like him, and in doing so, Kel hasn’t had an opportunity to discover who he is outside of that.

  Also entering the story is Lin Caster, an Ashkari woman who, despite the protestations of her tradition-bound society, is a physician. Throughout the Shadowhunter Chronicles, Cassandra Clare always made a point of having strong female characters as part of the cast, whether they were lead or supporting roles.

  I was really glad to see that she continued that in Sword Catcher because it’s not only great to have literary role models to look up to, but through them, Cassandra continues to show the importance of knowing who you are and being confident in your autonomy. As with Clary, Isabelle, Sophie, Tessa and the other female characters who came before her, Lin is a woman who knows her self-worth and, despite the odds and obstacles placed in her way, uses her skills as a physician to care for those outside of the Sault walls as well as within, particularly her friend Mariam.

 Like Conor and Kel, Mariam and Lin have grown up together and they have a close relationship. They are best friends, sisters and orphans. Their people, the Ashkar, they don’t have a single place to call home but have communities throughout the lands surrounding Castellane. The Sault, where Lin, Mariam and the other people of Ashkarian descent live, is a walled community within Castellane. They’re not permitted to own property outside of the Sault walls, and they’re not treated very well by the people of Castellane, so racism is a large theme in the book. Both Lin and Mariam lost their parents when they were children, so they and Lin’s brother Josit have become each other’s family.

  Internally, Lin struggles with finding a cure for Mariam, who is chronically ill with a disease that she’s had nearly her whole life, and the main reason Lin became a doctor was in the hopes that she would be able to heal Mariam completely, thus saving her friend’s life.

  Lin’s external struggle is the gender discrimination she faces. Though she passed the physician’s tests with flying colours, she isn’t allowed to use the laboratory in the Sault because she’s a woman while the male physicians are. Through the course of the book, Lin meets characters who say it’s silly that she is not permitted to use the Sault’s laboratory.

  However, these are greatly outnumbered by those narrow-minded individuals who believe that women should not be permitted to practice medicine. Among them is Oren Kandel, a spurned suitor of Lin’s who has never gotten over her rejection of his marriage proposal.

  Oren’s proposal was not made out of love, however, but as a means of control. He doesn’t believe in women having more choices than being wives and mothers, and he doesn’t like that Lin is someone who not only knows her own mind but has bigger aspirations than what is expected of her societally.

  Oren’s character reminded me strongly of Gaston from Beauty and the Beast because they shared the same views on what a woman should be. Both Belle and Lin reject their suitors because they know that once they become engaged and married, the respective men will strip away everything that makes up Belle and Lin’s identities until they are moulded into who the men want.

  Something I’ve always loved and respected about Cassandra Clare is when it comes to her books, she doesn’t shy away from diving into topics that some in society consider taboo. She continues to tackle social issues in Sword Catcher, such as misogyny and child marriages, prompting the thought that the conversations around them also need to be carried on.

  Child marriage or betrothal is shown in Princess Luisa of Sarthe, a neighbouring kingdom. Instead of sending Luisa’s older sister, who is around Conor’s age, the Sarthe monarchs and ambassadors send Luisa, who is only 11 or 12. She’s a mere child, and she is a pawn in a game of power between adults that ends in tragedy.

  Finally, Cassandra discusses class differences. Having spent the first 10 years of his life in the orphanage, Kel has more empathy and sympathy towards those less fortunate than Conor and the other young nobles that make up their social group do. He has experienced both worlds. As he spends more time outside of the palace and witnesses the conditions in the poorer parts of Castellane, Kel begins to develop a disdain for the frivolity that Conor and their acquaintances display regularly. For example, he doesn’t join in the sport of pitching meat pies off the highest tower to see who can throw them the furthest, because he knows that there are families who would appreciate those pies.

   Kel also shows understanding towards the palace servants when Conor and his friends begin wine archery, breaking many bottles of wine and spirits with a bow and arrow. The big mess is of no concern to them because they aren’t the ones who have to clean it up, so privilege and wealth also play a big role in the story.

   That’s it for this week! Have a great weekend and I will be back next week!

   Thanks for reading!

    Until next time, xoxo

Leave a Comment