Secrets and Class in The Fifth Avenue Artists Society

Written By: Lauren Long

Date Published: June 12, 2024

Photo by Samson Katt on Pexels.com

“Just as she and her siblings have become swept up in the society, though, Charlie throws himself back into her path, and Ginny learns that the salon’s bright lights may be obscuring some dark shadows.” ~Synopsis, The Fifth Avenue Artists Society, Joy Callaway

With characters inspired by Joy Callaway’s ancestors, she delivers a tantalizing tale in her debut novel The Fifth Avenue Artists Society.

    My mom recommended this book, and there were a few nights when I stayed up late because I was enraptured by the story. It was on one of these evenings that the night passed into the early morning that I finished the book, and even after I turned the final page, I couldn’t stop thinking about it.

  Set in 1891, The Fifth Avenue Artists Society follows Virginia “Ginny” Loftin and her family in the Bronx. Living in genteel poverty, each member of the family has their own talent that supplements the income, with some months where they barely get by.

  I found this book interesting because it shows the other side of what it was like to be a woman at a time in history when many opportunities were denied to them because of their gender.

  The themes of the book are heartbreak and learning how to heal from it, not being able to let go of your first love, being hesitant to love again when you’ve been burned once already, and class.

  In Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice and Helen Moffett’s Charlotte, it is demonstrated how class differences can have an effect on people’s lives. At that time, and at the time of The Fifth Avenue Artists Society, women were expected to get married and forsake everything else. Joy Callaway’s novel is the first book I’ve read that has views on both ends of the spectrum. Some men expect their wives to give up everything that they love to focus solely on wife- and motherhood, while on the other side of the fence, we have men who are supportive of their wives pursuing their passions. We also experience what it was like for men who were of a lower social station because if their fathers were dead and they were responsible for their mothers and sisters, marrying women of higher status provided financial security to them and their families.

 The final theme of the book is secrets and the power and potential they have to destroy even the closest bonds. Whether it’s among family, friends or lovers, the keeping of secrets slowly chips away at relationships, leaving nothing but broken trust behind as the revelation that shadows can exist even in the brightest lights.




Leave a Comment