Written By: Lauren Long
Date Published: July 24, 2024

“No. They Don’t. Why Should They?” ~Katniss Everdeen to Peeta Mellark, The Hunger Games, 2012
The post you’re about to read is one of my university essays that I revised to be able to share here.
Introduction To the Girl On Fire
Katniss Everdeen, the protagonist of Suzanne Collins’s dystopian series The Hunger Games, has the makings of a true modern heroine. Through her determination to save her sister, Prim, Katniss proves her strength, independence and survival knowledge when she volunteers as tribute for the 74th annual Hunger Games.
Besides being an influential female character, what makes Katniss so endearing to readers and her country? Every human being has something that draws people in. What’s attractive about Katniss is her relatable strengths and weaknesses, her relationship with Peeta Mellark, District 12’s male tribute, her survival skills and instincts, and her disgust at the Capitol’s materialism.
These aspects of her character are instrumental in her ability to stand up to the Games’ brutality and mark Katniss as a role model. Katniss’s fierce personality and Cinna’s stunning, fiery costumes give her celebrity status as “the girl on fire,” a title that she carries throughout the series.
Katniss Everdeen is the girl on fire because, by her defiance of the Capitol, she is a beacon of hope to Panem. Through repeated demonstrations of courage, Katniss offers the possibility that the Games, and the Capitol’s brutal oppression of the Districts, could end for good. The Hunger Games is a chilling tale of a young woman struggling to find herself and maintain her identity in a corrupt world as she fights for survival, becoming a symbol of rebellion in the process.
Strengths and Weaknesses
Katniss has many strengths, but she also has weaknesses. She is a skilled hunter, which goes hand-in-hand with her ability to be her family’s sole provider. At eleven years old, Katniss became head of the family after her father was killed in a mine explosion and her mother was incapacitated by grief. In a way, Katniss and Prim lost both parents that day.
Traumatic events cast a pall of darkness over our lives, but for every bad thing that happens, a positive sign appears when we need it most, reminding us that life will be good again. In The Hunger Games, a dandelion’s growth gives Katniss hope for her family’s survival. The dandelion symbolizes rebirth and gives her the courage she needs to begin trading at the Hob. “It was frightening to enter that place without my father at my side, but people had respected him and they accepted me. Game was game, after all, no matter who’d shot it” (Collins 52). By overcoming her fear of District 12’s local trading station, and remembering people’s respect for her father, Katniss becomes a fighter and a survivor. However, one of her weaknesses is refusing help from anybody, including her mother, who she withdrew from after her father’s death. When her husband died, Mrs. Everdeen suffered a severe depression that made it impossible to take care of her daughters.
Besides hunting and providing for her family, Katniss’s strengths and weaknesses manifest in her relationship with Peeta Mellark.
The Deep Bond Between Katniss and Peeta
Katniss’s relationship with Peeta is a contradiction. On one hand, it is an asset because by convincing the Capitol that they are “star-crossed lovers,” they can return to District 12.
Their chance to go home gives Peeta and Katniss the courage and confidence they need to believe they can win the Games. Peeta also gives Katniss hope and bravery at various points in the story, the first being when they are eleven years old. When they meet, Katniss is at her lowest point. It’s mere months after her father’s death, her mother is catatonic with grief, and her entire family is close to dying from starvation when Peeta comes to their rescue.
Katniss recalls, “The boy took one look back to the bakery as if checking that the coast was clear, then, his attention back on the pig, he threw a loaf of bread in my direction. The second quickly followed” (Collins 31).
Peeta is the saviour of Katniss and her family because he risks his mother beating him to give Katniss the bread. His act of kindness represents his feelings for Katniss and fuels Katniss’s optimism and determination for her family’s survival, and she returns his compassion in the arena.
In Rachel Stark’s “Why Katniss is A Feminist Character (And It’s Not Because She Wields a Bow and Beats Boys Up),” Stark suggests Katniss “forces herself to remember the way her mother cured sick patients, Katniss saves Peeta time and time again – first recognizing his blood poisoning, drugging him and getting the medication that he needs, and finally tying the tourniquet that saves Peeta’s life in the game’s final hours” (1).
By nursing Peeta back to health, Katniss not only repays him for five years earlier but risks her life when she goes to the Cornucopia to retrieve the medicine needed to treat Peeta’s wound. These actions show their deep bond, even though they hadn’t interacted much until the reaping.
Is Katniss’s affection for Peeta genuine or fake? Katniss genuinely likes Peeta. If she didn’t, she wouldn’t have done everything she could to save him. When it’s announced that two tributes from the same District can win, Katniss finally understands that since the Games started, Peeta has fought to keep her alive. “Shaking his head to keep me from running to the Cornucopia. Fighting Cato to let me escape. Even hooking up with the Careers must have been a move to protect me. Peeta, it turns out, has never been a danger to me. The thought makes me smile” (Collins 248.).
Katniss’s realization that Peeta’s love for her has been his main motivation for her protection is what drives her to find him and form the alliance that saves them. Abigail Myers, author of “Why Katniss Chooses Peeta: Looking at Love through a Stoic Lens,” believes that Katniss “comes to appreciate Peeta’s loyalty to her and even starts to believe that he might love her as he says he does” (Myers 142). Katniss’s gratitude for Peeta’s loyalty grows as they spend more time together; nonetheless, their relationship has its drawbacks.
Katniss and Peeta’s connection both ensures their survival and makes them vulnerable. Peeta’s admirable determination to protect Katniss drives him to extraordinarily risky lengths, such as allying himself with the Careers. This shocks Katniss in the arena when she overhears, ‘“We’re wasting time! I’ll go finish her and let’s move on!’ I almost fall out of the tree. The voice belongs to Peeta,’” (Collins 168).
Katniss’s surprise at this discovery is comprehensible, because the night before, Peeta confessed his love for Katniss on worldwide television. It is reasonable that, after making such a public statement, Katniss would be stunned by Peeta cooperating with the Careers, because he knows their ultimate goal is to kill her.
Peeta’s injury inflicted by Cato puts Katniss and Peeta at risk when they become allies. He is unable to walk without help, and he’s incredibly weak when she finds him camouflaged in the river bank. Had Katniss been someone who didn’t value life, she easily could have killed Peeta. Shoshana Kessock echoes this in “WWKD (What Would Katniss Do): The Moral and Ethical Issues of The Hunger Games”: “When push comes to shove, Katniss cannot separate her feelings for either Rue or Peeta to do either of them harm. Her empathy and ethics will not allow her to become the ruthless killer that the Career Tributes easily embrace” (1).
This statement pinpoints why Katniss cannot kill Peeta. To kill another human being without hesitation goes against her beliefs and identity.
However, Katniss does put herself in danger on the riverbank. “I let Peeta doze off while his clothes dry out, but by late afternoon, I don’t dare wait any longer” (Collins 259). Katniss knows by letting Peeta sleep out in the open, even for a short time, the likelihood of the remaining Careers discovering them rises. Katniss’s resolve to keep Peeta and herself alive, and the distinct possibility that both of them may make it home, is what sharpens her survival skills and instincts.
Survival Doesn’t Just Mean Food, Water and Shelter, But Relationships Too
When the book begins, it is evident that Katniss has formidable survival proficiencies and reflexes. The moment she enters the arena, everything she relies upon to stay alive at home is put to the test. She is well aware that the 23 other tributes share her goal of leaving the arena a survivor.
Kessock remarks, “She is especially tested when confronted with Rue, a little girl very similar to her sister, and Peeta, her fellow District Twelve Tribute, friend and love interest” (1). Katniss is challenged when faced with Rue, but once their alliance is formed, she automatically becomes Rue’s protector.
Her alliances with Rue and Peeta strengthen Katniss, become part of her arsenal for survival, and save her life. Stark asserts in her article, “When Katniss befriends Rue, she forms a feminist archetype: an alliance of women who support each other in the face of oppression” (1).
Katniss and Rue’s relationship is a deep, emotional bond of sisterhood. Katniss even says, “I can almost hear Haymitch groaning as I team up with this wispy child. But I want her. Because she’s a survivor, and I trust her, and why not admit it? She reminds me of Prim” (Collins 201). One survivor knows another.
Katniss doesn’t have faith in many people, so for her to be sure about Rue is a major strength in her personal development. Katniss’s trust issues stem from the emotional trauma of her father’s death, but she managed to turn that pain and sadness into something positive: her will to live and overcome the daily obstacles that she faces.
In another article, “Team Katniss: The Only Real Team for The Hunger Games,” Kessock says that Katniss:
…embodies a complicated female protagonist who relies heavily on herself to solve her own problems, utilizing her talents and her mind to independently decide her fate. She certainly does not base her future upon the decision of what man to end up with – she’s simply too busy trying to survive through one life-threatening situation after another. (1)
Where Katniss and Peeta’s relationship is concerned, they provide each other with comfort, company and security. An example is Katniss slowly but successfully nursing Peeta back to health despite having limited resources. A recovered Peeta takes on the role of caretaker when he tends to Katniss’s wounded forehead after she is attacked by the District 2 tribute, Clove, at the Cornucopia. After the cannons go off on the first day of the Games, signalling the deaths of the tributes, Katniss reveals that she is:
… relieved Peeta’s alive. I tell myself again that if I get killed, his winning will benefit my mother and Prim the most. This is what I tell myself to explain the conflicting emotions that arise when I think of Peeta. The gratitude that he gave me an edge by professing his love for me in the interview. The anger at his superiority on the roof. The dread that we may come face-to-face at any moment in this arena. (Collins 157).
Although Katniss’s romantic feelings for Peeta are not strong yet, they are starting to develop, but she is too afraid to admit that he means something to her, because she knows it is likely that she and Peeta will cross paths in the arena. Katniss was also scared of having to kill Peeta because not only would she have to live with that guilt, but she would face District 12’s hostility for the rest of her life.
In their article “‘Killer’ Katniss and ‘Lover Boy’ Peeta: Suzanne Collins’ Defiance of Gendered-Genred Reading” Ellyn Lem and Holly Hassel avow, “Katniss’s ingenuity, cleverness, quick and strategic thinking ultimately save their lives” (Lem and Hassel 124).
The final facet of Katniss’s survival impulses/competencies is after she has destroyed the Careers’ supplies and she sees Foxface, the District 5 tribute, rummaging around in the ruins. While hiding in the bushes, Katniss notes:
No, it’s Foxface, standing in the rubble of the pyramid and laughing…I’m perplexed by her amusement until I realize that with the Careers’ stores eliminated, she might actually stand a chance. Just like the rest of us. It crosses my mind to reveal myself and enlist her as a second ally against that pack. But I rule it out. There’s something about that sly grin that makes me sure that befriending Foxface would ultimately get me a knife in the back (Collins 227).
While having a second ally against the Careers would be beneficial, Katniss listens to her gut instinct telling her to keep the alliance with Rue as it is. On Laura Simmons’s “20 Novels with Fierce Female Characters We Love,” Katniss is ranked second on the list of literature’s strong female leads. “Katniss essentially defines “strong woman.” She’s independent, smart, savvy, and a hunter/fighter! Definitely not a weak character” (Simmons 2).
Katniss’s traits of independence and intelligence, as well as being a hunter and warrior, tie into her loathing of the Capitol’s cupidity. At the same time, she is drawn to it, and her unwilling fascination with the Capitol is what steels her to brave the consequences of being in conflict with them.
Katniss’s Hatred of the Capitol and its Materialism
Katniss’s hatred of the Capitol and its greediness is plausible. She despises that the Districts must send their children to certain death, knowing that only one will survive. In “Violence and Entertainment in The Hunger Games,” author Myke Bartlett accurately describes the purpose of the Hunger Games:
At its core, The Hunger Games extrapolates on the timeworn notion that an entertained populace is a docile populace…fused with current trends for on-screen talent competitions, such as Australian Idol…a nation’s youth battle to win the favour of a panel of judges…In The Hunger Games, however, the battles are made literal. As a result, the Games oppress the nation in two ways: firstly, by distracting the citizenry with brutal, stylized entertainment; and secondly, through the fear of viewers who know there’s a good chance that they or a loved one might one day take part. (10)
Katniss has watched the Games every year, knowing that she may be chosen to compete, no matter how much she opposes this. The very idea is terrifying to her, and how could it not be? To leave her family and friends behind, knowing she could potentially die and leave her family without a provider is heartbreaking and scary.
Katniss volunteering for Prim comes from a place of love. She knows that Prim would not last a second in the Games, whereas she stands a better chance of surviving. Katniss accepts that being District 12’s female tribute means she must go to the Capitol and begin the covetous preparations that will ready her for the Games. While she rebels against greed, Katniss accepts that she must participate in something she detests to increase her chances of living.
The first time Katniss’s hatred/appeal towards acquisitiveness arises is when she arrives in the Capitol. Katniss, Peeta and the other tributes are taken to the Remake Center. In ‘“The Final Word on Entertainment:” Mimetic and Monstrous Art in the Hunger Games,” Brian McDonald describes the difference between Katniss and the beauticians assigned to her:
During Katniss’s first trip to the Remake Center, Flavius declares to the laughter of the other members of her prep team, ‘“You almost look like a real person now.” By any normal definition, the only “real person” in the room is Katniss. She alone has a core: a stable identity formed from deep and abiding relationships that define who she is, such as her responsibilities to her sister, Prim, her friendship with Gale Hawthorne, and her memories of her father. It is precisely her refusal to subject her identity to constant makeovers that make her real (16-17).
This analysis of Katniss’s character is accurate. During the preparation week, Katniss manages to hang onto her distinctiveness, even though her pride in her self-identity is looked down upon by the narcissistic citizens of the Capitol, except Cinna. When Katniss and Cinna lunch together for the first time, Katniss wonders “. . . What do they do all day, these people in the Capitol, besides decorating their bodies and waiting around for a new shipment of tributes to roll in and die for their entertainment?” (Collins 65).
Katniss is right to wonder this because most of the Capitol’s population are grasping their wealthy lifestyles, they don’t know what it’s like to live the way the Districts do. Correspondingly, Katniss notes the differences between District 12 and the Capitol:
They do surgery in the Capitol, to make people appear younger and thinner. In District 12, looking old is something of an achievement since so many people die early. You see an elderly person, you want to congratulate them on their longevity, ask the secret of survival. A plump person is envied because they aren’t scraping by like the majority of us. But here it is different. Wrinkles aren’t desirable. A round belly isn’t a sign of success. (Collins 125).
Katniss is conscious that in District 12, some people are fortunate enough to celebrate their health, unlike the Capitol people who repeatedly alter their bodies to create their ideal form. In addition, Katniss loathes the clothes provided by the Capitol as they are fancier than what she would wear back home, especially the costumes designed by Cinna.
Cinna’s costumes contribute to Katniss’s aversion to avarice and her insurgence. Katniss is in awe of the interview attire that she wears for her televised conversation with Caesar Flickerman. It is a beautiful dress, but she hates the reason for which she is wearing it and when her interview is over, she is relieved to take the dress off and remove the make-up so that she can return to her natural self (Long).
It is easy to empathize with Katniss and her conflicted feelings. Cinna’s designs are stunning, but none of them reflect Katniss’s identity. When she’s wearing the gown of flames, she becomes who the Capitol wants her to be. She puts on the mask and removes it when the cameras are gone.
However, though Cinna is responsible for the sensational costumes that gave Katniss the name “girl on fire,” he does not want her to be like everyone in the Capitol. Right before her interview, he tells her, ‘“Remember, they already love you,’ he says gently. ‘Just be yourself’” (Collins 123).
Cinna realizes how important it is for Katniss to maintain her identity in a world full of people who are reworked to please themselves and others. Katniss being a woman of substance is important to Cinna because he’s one of the few people that Katniss is herself around. Rue is drawn to Katniss for the same reason; her authenticity is what makes Rue trust and become allies and friends with Katniss.
Katniss and Rue’s relationship is vital to both the series and Katniss’s identity. Even for the brief time that they are allies, they form a sisterly relationship with one another, “. . . Katniss takes care of Rue, both by sharing food and shelter and by honouring her death with flowers and song” (Lem and Hassel 125-126). Not only has Katniss found someone that she can give her affection and care, but Rue’s murder is the spark that ignites Katniss’s decision to rebel against the Capitol. In the heat of the moment after Rue dies, Katniss decides:
I want to do something, right here, right now, to show them, to make them accountable, to show the Capitol that whatever they do or force us to do there is a part of every tribute they can’t own. That Rue was more than just a piece in their Games…Slowly, one stem at a time, I decorate her body in the flowers… “Bye, Rue,” I whisper. I press the three middle fingers of my left hand against my lips and hold them out in her direction. (Collins 237)
This funerary action charges the scene emotionally, demonstrating what Rue meant to Katniss in the short time they knew each other. By lining Rue’s body in flowers and giving District 12’s salute of respect; Katniss unknowingly sparks the beginning of the revolution against the Capitol. Her defiant act in honouring one tribute’s death has placed her in a precarious position. Because she acted in the heat of the moment, Katniss did not stop to consider the consequences, which may lead to her own possible demise. Katniss’s reaction to Rue’s death, and her abhorrence for the wealthy, cruel Capitol, are what make her a character that the book’s audience roots for. Even though she risks her own life by showing respect and kindness to Rue, she shows that she will do whatever it takes to overthrow the Capitol.
Finally, Katniss’s hatred for the Capitol and the multiple layers of inequality that divide them and the Districts is the strongest point of her anger. Katniss is absolutely appalled by the Capitol’s materialism and opulence while the people in the Districts are starving to death (Long). This is fathomable, as the Capitol has resources and financial security while the people in the Districts can barely afford enough supplies to last for even a couple of days. However, Katniss says:
Almost all of the boys and at least half of the girls are bigger than I am, even though many of the tributes have never been fed properly. You can see it in their bones, their skin, the hollow look in their eyes…The exceptions are the kids from the wealthier districts, the volunteers, the ones who have been fed and trained throughout their lives for this moment. The tributes from 1, 2, and 4 traditionally have this look about them (Collins 94).
The tributes from these Districts are closer to the Capitol; therefore, they live with the same luxuries. Since Katniss, Peeta and the other tributes come from the poorer Districts, they are at a disadvantage because they do not have the same privileges.
Katniss’s knowledge of a bow and arrow is her only advantage. She and the other tributes have to rely on their intellect and courage if they hope to leave the arena alive. The living conditions in the Districts are horrifying, reminding one of the Nazis and the Holocaust. This is a terrifying comparison. The idea of the Hunger Games is disturbing enough, with kids killing other kids, but when the living conditions are added into the equation, it becomes even more appalling (Long).
Comparing The Hunger Games to the Holocaust: Horrifying Similarities
In a lot of ways, the Hunger Games and the Reaping are exactly like the Holocaust. Katniss, her friends and family, and the other Districts are being persecuted, whereas the Capitol and its citizens can be compared to the Nazis. McDonald quotes the late cultural critic Phillip Rieff: “. . .Hitler’s death camps were part of a Nazi aesthetic of power whose intent was not to just destroy the Jews but to defile and humiliate them… to so degrade them that in accepting this second death and its indignities, they were resistless” (16).
Are the similarities between the Holocaust and the Hunger Games clear from this analysis? Upon Katniss and Peeta emerging as victors, they are healed all of their injuries, but when the time comes for the final interview and Katniss is dressed, she says, “I immediately notice the padding over my breasts, adding curves that hunger has stolen from my body. My hands go to my chest and I frown . . . ‘I know,’ says Cinna . . . ‘But the Gamemakers wanted to alter you surgically. Haymitch had a huge fight with them over it. This was the compromise’” (Collins 354). This reminds the reader of the experiments performed on prisoners of the concentration camps, making the similarities between the Hunger Games and the Holocaust even more real. The Capitol is covering up the physical suffering Katniss endured in the Games.
Conclusion
Suzanne Collins’ suspenseful futuristic thriller The Hunger Games features Katniss Everdeen, a girl from the poorest of 12 Districts, who is suddenly thrust from being her family’s sole provider to a competitor in her country’s annual Hunger Games. Katniss is a heroine long before she emerges as a victor.
The Hunger Games is a bloody and violent competition that strengthens Katniss’s survival skills and instincts and makes her more aware of her identity while reinforcing her convictions against the Capitol. Katniss’s character traits of bravery, strength, speed and intelligence make her an important role model to her literary audience and those around her. Her independence, quick thinking, and devotion to her family and friends make her a memorable icon of female empowerment. Katniss is not a literary figure that will be forgotten anytime soon, on the contrary, she lives on in the minds and hearts of the audience. Also, Collins presents a positive moral lesson in her depiction of the harsh conditions and daily suffering of the Districts. She is mindful that not everyone is fortunate enough to live in comfort and many people must go to extremes by breaking the law to survive, much like Katniss hunting to feed her family; a punishable act as deemed by the Capitol. This is what makes Katniss a strong female character. She is by no means a damsel in distress; she can look after herself and others.
Works Cited
Bartlett, Myke. “Violence and Entertainment in The Hunger Games.” Screen Education 66 (2012):8-17. Film and Television Literature Index with Full Text. Web. 5 March 2013.
Collins, Suzanne. The Hunger Games. United States of America: Scholastic Inc, 2008. Print.
Kessock, Shoshana. “Team Katniss: The Only Real Team for The Hunger Games.” 8 March 2012. http://www.tor.com. Web. 15 March 2013
—. “WWKD: The Moral and Ethical Issues of The Hunger Games.” 26 March 2012. http://www.tor.com. Web. 15 March 2013.
Lem, Ellyn with Holly Hassel. ‘“Killer’ Katniss and ‘Lover Boy’ Peeta: Suzanne Collins’s Defiance of Gender-Genred Reading. Pharr 118-227. Pharr F., Mary and Leisa A. Clark, eds. Of Bread, Blood, and The Hunger Games: Critical Essays on the Suzanne Collins’ Trilogy. Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland and Company, Inc, Publishers. 2012. Print.
Long, Ken and Megan. “The Hunger Games.” Quesnel. Canada. 2013 March. Discussion.
McDonald, Brian. “The Final Word on Entertainment:’ Mimetic and Monstrous Art in The Hunger Games.” Dunn 8-24. Dunn A., George and Nicholas Michaud, eds. The Hunger Games and Philosophy: A Critique of Pure Treason. Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley and Sons, Inc. 2012. Print.
Myers, E. Abigail. “Why Katniss Chooses Peeta: Looking at Love through a Stoic Lens. 134-143 Dunn.