Written By: Lauren Long
Date Published: September 4, 2024

“Sweetie, if I’ve learned anything in life it is that sometimes things get in your path, and you have a choice. You can either smash right into them, or you can adjust and move around, but you have to do one or the other in order to move forward.” ~Lily van der Woodsen, Gossip Girl, 1×17
Woman on the Verge, episode 1×17 of Gossip Girl, focuses on drug abuse, the devastating consequences it can have, and the importance of listening before judging someone. When we judge without knowing the whole story, it causes a lot of hurt feelings as well as a lack of belief that we can turn to anyone. This is the plotline of episode 17, and Serena is at the heart of it.
The entire season, Serena has been carrying something painful, and it resurfaced in episode 14 when she received the risqué gifts. The sender? Georgina Sparks, the undisputed bad girl of the Upper East Side, who has hooked her claws, black nails and all, into Dan and Vanessa.
In days gone by, Georgina was the person who Serena would party with. They would drink, do drugs, and get up to a lot of other activities. Georgina is even more manipulative than Blair, but the difference between the two is that Blair has a conscience and is remorseful when she acts without thinking, such as when she outed Serena in episode 3, mistakenly believing that Serena was a patient at the Ostroff Center, when in reality it was her brother Eric.
Georgina, on the other hand, has no remorse, and she enjoys causing trouble and doesn’t care who she hurts. She too has the opportunity to tell the truth but chooses to lie because she takes pleasure in manipulating people and playing on their weaknesses. Georgina’s reappearance in Serena’s life affects not only Serena’s relationship with Dan but also the effort that Serena has been making to live her life differently.
The newfound strain on his relationship with Serena causes Dan to confide in Rufus, who tells him, “Most times if people don’t offer the truth, they’re afraid of what someone might think.” I’ve touched on this before, the truth can make people uncomfortable, and in Serena’s case, she fears that if she tells Dan what is troubling her so much, she will lose him. She’s afraid that he will be so disgusted with her that he will never speak to her again. It’s for this reason that she opens up, after much encouragement, to Blair, Chuck and Nate.
At the time that all of this is happening, Nate and Chuck are still on the outs, but Blair calls them both to her penthouse because she needs their help. Nate, aware that Blair has a flair for the dramatic, asks her if it’s a ploy to get him and Chuck in one room, but it is much more serious than either of them anticipated when they see Serena panting on the floor of the elevator. Right away, we know something is not right, and this is reinforced when Blair says that she was out all night looking for Serena, suggesting that all of them have experienced something like this before.
Blair shows a lot of maturity in this episode because she tells Nate and Chuck that they need to put aside their differences and help their friend. She might be the Queen Bee of the Upper East Side and of Constance, but when push comes to shove, Blair drops everything to be present for the people who need her most, something she learned from Dorota.
Dorota not only cares about Blair but her friends too. With Eleanor away and Harold living in Paris with Roman, Dorota assumes the role of mother/older sister to Blair and her friends and acts as a concerned parent when she calls Lily to let her know what’s going on. “Miss Serena is like the old days… I think you should have worry about your daughter. Worry like before she went away.”
Meanwhile, Dan has been looking for Serena and calling her all morning, and when he confronts her at Blair’s, Serena has an opportunity to tell him what’s wrong, but instead lies and says that she cheated on him the night before. Serena is so afraid of what Dan will think of her secret that she would rather let him think she was unfaithful than know what she did, and she’s reluctant to tell Blair, Chuck and Nate too. What they have that Dan doesn’t however, is a shared history.
The four of them have been raised in the same world and, to a certain extent, have not had a lot of parental supervision. But this life experience has bonded them together in a way that no outsider, like Dan or Jenny, could understand. “None of us are saints,” Nate says, with Blair adding, “We don’t judge. We’re the non-judging breakfast club. We’re your best friends. Anything you do is something we did too.”
It is these statements of support and promises of no judgment that finally convince Serena to open up and let her secret into the light. We find out that a year before, after her tryst with Nate at the Shepherd wedding, Serena went to meet Georgina at a hotel, not knowing that Georgina was planning to set her up with a “genuine Serena van der Woodsen sex tape.” As Serena narrates the story, Lily watches part of the tape on a laptop but draws her own conclusion and shuts it off.
Part of it is that she’s horrified Serena has said no to having sex with the guy in the video, but he doesn’t respect her and keeps pawing at her, and no parent wants to see their child taken advantage of like that. However, because Lily turns it off at that point, she doesn’t see Pete Fairman’s overdose, Serena’s frantic behaviour, and Georgina stopping Serena from calling 9-1-1.
Georgina is really good at getting in people’s heads and making them comply through fear, so she feeds Serena lies about how they have to split up because people are looking for them. Serena leaves the hotel room, but she waits across the street because the only thing she wants is to see the paramedics helping Pete, but instead, she sees them bring his body out in a body bag. This whole experience, coupled with Serena and Nate’s infidelity to Blair, traumatizes her to the point of leaving the city. We finally know why she left.
Serena then tells Blair, Nate, and Chuck that while she is happy to be out of that lifestyle, Georgina is still in it and she doesn’t like that Serena has moved on from it. Serena fears that if she doesn’t do what Georgina wants, her old friend will show Dan the tape of Pete’s attempt to have sex with Serena and his fatal overdose.
Despite his playboy persona and, at times, dangerous behaviour, Chuck cares about Serena. He knows what Georgina has done and is doing is wrong, and he says that they need to find her, only to be met with Serena pleading with them not to do anything. Blair, Chuck and Nate are all horrified and angry, but not at Serena. They’re angry that Georgina’s actions cost a young man his life, and she’s using it to control their friend.
A while later, Lily confronts Serena at her and Bart’s rehearsal dinner. Making her own assumptions about the situation based on Serena’s past as a party girl, Lily doesn’t stop to listen to her daughter but instead tells her she’s going to send her to reformatory school.
Once again, Blair comes to Serena’s defence and reminds Lily that while she may be a highly respected member of New York’s high society, she’s also a mother, and that comes first. Blair tells Lily that Serena is in a lot of pain because of a secret she’s been holding in, and Blair can only do what she’s done, now Serena needs her mother.
It’s not shown on screen, but Blair tells Lily Serena’s story, and Lily realizes that her daughter needs her support.
She takes Serena to see Pete Fairman’s parents, who are expecting her. Serena is terrified at the thought of having to tell her story again and that she can’t face the parents of the young man who died, but Lily gives her some touching advice about life. “Sweetie, if I’ve learned anything in life it is that sometimes things get in your path, and you have a choice. You can either smash right into them, or you can adjust and move around, but you have to do one or the other in order to move forward.”
Serena is comforted by her mother’s words, but it isn’t until Lily assures her that she’s going to be by her side that Serena finds the courage to go in.
While Serena is at the Fairmans’ residence, Nate, Blair and Chuck discover the whereabouts of Georgina, thanks to a phone call Nate has with Vanessa. After he reveals Georgina’s true identity to Vanessa, she tells Dan with Nate’s promise that he will tell her everything when he gets to the concert.
When Serena and Lily come out of the Fairmans’ house, Serena doesn’t feel lighter, but still guilty. Even though she blames herself, Pete’s parents don’t hold her responsible because their son was an addict for ten years and they couldn’t get him to stop, so there was no way a sixteen-year-old could have.
Lily may not have been there for her daughter when Pete’s overdose happened, but she couldn’t be because she didn’t know what was going on. Now that she does, Lily is there for Serena, telling her that she doesn’t need to blame herself, and once again imparts her wisdom when Serena asks why she still feels guilty. “Because contrary to what I said earlier, you are a good person, who since that night has been living your life with care and compassion and respect, for yourself and for others. I’m sorry I doubted you.”
As far as touching moments on the show go, this one is in my top ten. It brings tears to my eyes every time and shows the importance of giving your children the space and the confidence they need to come to you when something they can’t handle on their own happens. More than that, it shows how important it is to not judge before you know the full story and listen.
Have you ever had a moment in your life when someone didn’t listen to you or vice versa, only to realize you were wrong later?
Thanks for reading!
Until next time, xoxo