Written By: Lauren Long
Date Published: September 6, 2024

“People aren’t so bad, really. It’s what the world does to them. Like us, in the arena. We did things in there we’d never have considered if they’d just left us alone.” ~Lucy Gray Baird, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes
Before Katniss Everdeen, Peeta Mellark and Haymitch Abernathy, there was Lucy Gray Baird and Coriolanus Snow. The same Coriolanus who became the tyrannical ruler of Panem, but he wasn’t always like that.
Suzanne Collins’ The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes is a prequel set 64 years before the fateful 74th Hunger Games, the origin story of Coriolanus Snow and how he became the villain of the Hunger Games trilogy.
When the book opens, Coriolanus is a young man whose family is barely scraping by. Before the war, Coriolanus and his family were part of the Capitol’s high society but lost their wealth when his father was killed by a rebel sniper. The death of the family patriarch meant that Coriolanus became the man of the house, and he witnessed the horrors of war and the burning of his family’s possessions so they don’t freeze to death.
Coriolanus, his cousin Tigris, and their grandmother are struggling to stay afloat on Tigris’s meagre income, and are living a double life so as to not let people see how badly they’re suffering.
When I read this book for the first time, I struggled to comprehend that eighteen-year-old Coriolanus Snow was the same man who became the cruel, ruthless President of Panem, because when the book starts, he’s a teenager who is trying to do right by his family and he still has empathy. Sure, he has his less-favourable moments, but what eighteen-year-old doesn’t?
When we’re eighteen, we are in another transition period. We are transitioning from being adolescents to being young adults, and are beginning to find our place in the world. For Coriolanus and his classmates, the Hunger Games are part of their lives, but not all of them agree with them.
Unlike his older counterpart, Coriolanus questions the Games and if they are necessary, particularly after he meets his tribute, Lucy Gray. Not only does Lucy Gray invoke sympathy in Coriolanus, but he also falls in love with her, and her presence and beliefs make him question the beliefs he has been brought up with.
Coriolanus is an interesting character in The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes because he isn’t fully bad yet, he is good and bad, and he constantly goes back and forth between those two sides. Throughout the book, he walks the line between good and evil, with the darker side of his personality being stoked by his experiences of being a child in wartime. His story takes place 10 years after the war between the Capitol and the Districts ended, with the latter emerging victorious. Even though the Capitol won, there are a lot of rich families, like the Snows, who really suffered, and instead of realizing that the Districts are also struggling and working together to find a solution, it’s an us vs. them scenario. The Capitol views itself as above the Districts, and their feeling is that because the Districts started the war, they deserve to continue suffering.
When Coriolanus is assigned Lucy Gray, the female tribute from District 12, to mentor for the Games, he sees it as a slap in the face because District 12 is the poorest of the Districts in Panem. As Coriolanus gets to know Lucy Gray, however, his perception begins to change. There is an instant connection between the two of them, and for the first time in 10 years, Coriolanus lets his guard down around someone outside of Tigris and his grandmother.
Lucy Gray and Coriolanus bond over being orphans, both of them lost their parents and siblings in the war and know what it’s like to be hungry. As Coriolanus comes to know Lucy Gray, he begins to feel empathy for not just her, but the other tributes as well, freely admitting to Tigris that it’s disturbing to see them in the cage in the zoo. From the moment the tributes arrive in the Capitol, they are treated as lesser beings in the most deplorable, inhumane conditions, which are ordered by Dr. Volumina Gaul.
Dr. Gaul is the Head Gamemaker and oversees the Games. Sadistic and violent, she does not value human life. Coriolanus is scared of her, and he sees that there is no humanity in her. She truly enjoys making people and animals suffer, and she believes that the Games are necessary. That all humans are, at their core, violent and primal beings.
Coriolanus, having been raised primarily by Tigris and his grandmother, straddles the line between believing the Capitol’s and his grandmother’s beliefs about the Districts and having compassion for them. Tigris is the voice of reason. She is the only one in the Snow family who really has a mind of her own and hasn’t allowed herself to become corrupted by the war-torn world she has grown up in. Being older than Coriolanus and having lost her parents in the war, Tigris had to grow up fast, and in addition to being Coriolanus’s older cousin, she also adopted an older sister/mother role for him. She has done her best to instill morals, empathy and compassion in him, and she believes that her cousin can be a good person.
Tigris has protected her cousin all their lives, but her kind heart and love aren’t enough to protect him from the cruelty of the people he comes into direct contact with, Dr. Gaul and Dean Casca Highbottom. Dr. Gaul, unfortunately, poisons Coriolanus’s mind with her ideals and beliefs, and Dean Highbottom is another factor in Coriolanus’s descent into the dark side.
The original Hunger Games trilogy was a warning not to become desensitized to violence. To a certain extent, Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes is too, but there are other messages at work. The biggest one is that most people are not born evil, it’s their life experiences and the people they meet along the way that turn their souls from pure nothing but darkness.
For Coriolanus, his experiences of the war and being a child of wartime have made him fearful of not having control, so any opportunity where he sees the potential to have control, he grabs on with both hands. It’s a very human thing to do, when we’ve had bad experiences that have been out of our control, we look for things that we can keep a hold on. Dr. Gaul uses Coriolanus’s desire for power over his own life to exert her influence and manipulate him.
Dean Highbottom has a vendetta against Coriolanus’s father, but since Crassus Snow was killed in the war, Highbottom focuses his hatred of the father onto the son, very similar, if not identical, to how Professor Snape treats Harry in the Harry Potter series. James Potter bullied Snape during their school years, and when Harry comes to Hogwarts, Snape projects all of his resentment and hatred, stemming from the childhood trauma of being bullied, onto Harry.
Both Coriolanus and Harry pay for the sins of their fathers, but the difference is that Harry manages to stay on the other side of the line. He remains good and keeps his humanity, whereas Coriolanus loses his goodness bit by bit and becomes irredeemable.
Because of Coriolanus’s need for control, he loses the girl he loves. While Katniss and Peeta played the star-crossed lovers to win sponsors in the Capitol, only to have Katniss fall in love with Peeta for real, Lucy Gray and Coriolanus are the real star-crossed lovers.
Coriolanus and Lucy Gray did love each other, and their story made me sad, because had Coriolanus not allowed his hunger for power to overtake his good side, everything could have been different. He lost sight of the fact that love doesn’t make you weak, but strong.
When Katniss and Peeta came along, Coriolanus saw what he and Lucy Gray could have had. The main message that I took away from this book was that it is harder to judge someone when you know their full story.
Thanks for reading!
Until next time, xoxo