The Dixon Rule: When The Unexpected Becomes the All Along

Written By: Lauren Long

Date Published: March 12, 2025

Photo by Shuvalova Natalia on Pexels.com

“Christ, I love this woman with all my heart. Being with Diana is like discovering a piece of myself that I never knew was missing. She makes me want to be the best version of myself, not because I feel like I have to impress her but because she inspires me to be better.” ~Shane Lindley, Elle Kennedy, The Dixon Rule

  Elle Kennedy’s The Dixon Rule is a romance, and romance was the main genre I read in my teenage years.

 Francine Pascal’s Sweet Valley High was my go-to when my family and I visited the library on the weekends. As soon as we walked through the doors, I would head straight for the section where the Sweet Valley High books were. I would take out a mix of old and new books, rereading the ones I had already read in addition to reading the ones I hadn’t.

  As I grew older, I switched from Sweet Valley High to Cecily von Ziegesar’s Gossip Girl series and another author whose name I can’t remember, but if I saw the cover of one of their books, it would come back to me.

 I spotted Elle Kennedy’s The Dixon Rule in February while I was at HomeSense with my mom and sister. I’ve mentioned in previous posts that when I’m looking for a new book, there has to be something about it that pulls me in. It can be the cover, the synopsis, or a recommendation from a fellow book lover.

  When I noticed The Dixon Rule, the book was shelved so that both the synopsis and the front cover were hidden from view, and I was intrigued enough by the title to take a closer look.

   The image on the front cover was a young woman in a black and silver cheerleading uniform, and the very first paragraph mentioned a ballroom dance competition! Sold! I was obsessed with cheerleading when I was younger, and during my later years of high school, I would tune in every week to Dancing With the Stars because I loved watching the ballroom dances and seeing the classic yet sparkly costumes. As it turns out, I love reading about it too, and I was rooting for Diana and Shane, the book’s romantic leads, even before their dance partnership turned into something more.

  The other factor that sealed my decision to buy this book? It and the two other novels I purchased were priced at $7.99 each, and I couldn’t say no to a deal like that!

  Okay, now that I’ve had a little rambling session, let’s chat about the book!

   The Dixon Rule follows the story of Diana Dixon, a student at the fictional Ivy League school of Briar University and captain of the cheerleading squad, and Shane Lindley, also a student at Briar and plays forward for the school’s hockey team, and who has been drafted by the Blackhawks after he graduates.

   At first, Shane and Diana have a love-hate relationship like Anastasia and Dimitri from the 1997 cartoon. They’re opposing forces who have a strong current of unspoken attraction running between them. If we want to get really specific, dear readers, another childhood couple Diana and Shane remind me of are Belle and the Beast from the 1991 film, because at the beginning, they make all these assumptions about each other, but as they spend more time together and look deeper to see what’s on the inside, they realize that they have misjudged each other.

  Shane goes from giving Diana a hard time to becoming her dance partner and biggest defender. The transformation that Diana goes through from having Shane in her life is that she’s always felt like she has to be the tough girl, and what she learns from Shane is how to be vulnerable, and that there is strength in vulnerability.

   Shane and Diana’s story may be a classic enemies-to-lovers romance, but it’s so much more than that. As the book progresses, we see how their relationship evolves and the journey that they go on together, and we see the different dynamics that they have with their families. The best romance novels are the ones that have substance and relatable characters, and that’s what Elle Kennedy has accomplished with this book. It’s about more than just the romance; it’s about family dynamics and relationships, and it also brings attention to domestic violence and abuse.

  When I read the part of the synopsis about Diana’s ex-boyfriend being unwilling to take no for an answer, I thought that the storyline would be a case of cat and mouse, but it was much more sinister than that.

  The parts of the book where Diana’s ex Percy appeared, each time becoming more persistent, I was afraid for her, and I was afraid with her. I wanted so much to be able to step into the pages and comfort her and help her because I could see how much his persistence was affecting her mental and emotional health. This storyline shines a light on how scary it can be when an ex-partner, or even someone who has shown interest in us romantically, refuses to take no for an answer and disrespects our boundaries while manipulating and abusing us emotionally and how quickly gaslighting and jealousy can turn into physical violence.

  I have had two instances in my life where I had men who wouldn’t take no for an answer, and while it never got to the point where I was scared for my life, the mental and emotional turmoil was not easy to deal with. I was 17 the first time it happened, and once I’d told the guy in no uncertain terms that I didn’t want a relationship with him, his behaviour changed quickly. The final time he called our house, I handed the phone to my dad, and he asked him to stop calling. The next day at school his sister, who was the reason this creep knew about me in the first place, he’d seen my Facebook profile while she was looking at it and decided he wanted to take me to grad even though I already had a date, told me he’d called me and my dad f****** psychos and that he’d called me a b****. Looking back on it now and having heard and read experiences of women being harassed and worse, I can safely say I dodged a bullet with that guy.

  I think that experience did impact how I view men, which has resulted in me guarding my heart closely.

   While Diana is dealing with an ex who can’t understand “no means no”, Shane has the opposite problem. A year before the book starts, he has his heart broken badly by his high school sweetheart, Lynsey. While Diana and Percy’s relationship is unhealthy because he is possessive and later violent, Shane’s relationship with Lynsey is unhealthy because it’s one-sided. They dated for four years, and as more of Shane’s history with Lynsey is revealed, we learn that while Shane was a great boyfriend, Lynsey always took more than she gave.

  It’s only when Shane begins to have strong feelings for Diana and build a genuine connection with her that he realizes how vastly different his relationship with Diana is to the one he had with Lynsey. While Lynsey rarely attended Shane’s hockey games and he attended every single one of her dance recitals, Diana makes the effort to support Shane at hockey as well as showing interest in his interests outside of hockey, such as golf.

  Shane and Diana’s relationship is one of equals because they recognize and respect that while they have different interests, the right partner will participate without being asked. Diana and Shane may have started off as two people who let their preconceived notions of each other get in the way of finding common ground, but they end as a couple who realize that sometimes our soulmate is the person we least expect.

  I fell in love with Diana and Shane, and I would love to see another book about them and where life takes them, but that’s up to Elle Kennedy!

  That’s it for today!

  Thanks for reading!

   See you Friday, xoxo

    Created with ❤️ By Lauren

Leave a Comment