Written By: Lauren Long
Date Published: March 14, 2025

“I don’t know what it says about me, really, the fact that I love this dynamic so much. But I do. A crazy, neurotic girl meets a gruff bad boy and I fall to pieces. To be honest, it’s the potential for angst that calls to me as much as the possibility for epic romance. Rachel just feels everything so acutely and sometimes to a fault, unashamed of her convictions, opinions and emotions. Meanwhile Puck’s burgeoning awareness, of both his own feelings and those of others, is being stunted time and again by the people closest to him shutting him out and reinforcing his fears of being unworthy of them. So, here is a girl who craves the affection she knows in her heart that she deserves and the boy who tries to prove himself and falls short every time and for one achingly brief period of time they put that fear and hurt aside and saw each other and my world exploded. I don’t know if they are “meant to be”, but I do know that there is easily, easily, the potential for them to find some sort of understanding and intimacy, both emotional and physical, with each other. And that much like them, it won’t be perfect, but it’ll be beautiful.” ~melon_collie – https://www.fanforum.com/f336/puckleberry-%5Bberry-puckerman%5D-23-hes-man-gives-damn-will-treat-her-well-62948545/
We all have our favourite ships, right? Those characters we love in books, TV and films, and from the first moment a spark is shown, we’re invested in their relationship and cheer when they finally get together.
But what about the relationships that have so much potential and we know could be great together, but who never get their happily ever after on screen or in a book, and we have to read fanfiction if we want to see it happen? We all have those ships, too. Mine are Rory and Logan from Gilmore Girls, (don’t get me started on all the wasted potential in the revival or the end of Season 7) and Riven and Musa from Fate: The Winx Saga (nearly three years later and I’m still mad about Netflix canceling the show when we were so close to getting our Rivusa! Although, I will say that on the fandom for Fate: The Winx Saga, Musa and Riven are listed as each other’s significant others, so that makes me happy).
Before I was a Rogan and Rivusa shipper, I was a Puckleberry shipper.
Glee’s Puck and Rachel may have only been a couple for one episode, but during Mash-Up (1×08), it was clear to me that Puck was so much better for her than Finn. Unlike the relationships between Finn and Rachel and Quinn and Puck, there was something about Puck and Rachel that just made sense. They balanced each other out, with Rachel bringing out a softer, more sensitive side of Puck and Puck, or Noah as she called him, calming her ego.
To this day, I prefer Puck and Rachel over Finn and Rachel because Puck never tried to change who she was or ask her to change for him; he liked her for who she was as a whole person. Finn, on the other hand, didn’t fully accept Rachel for who she was and would try to change the parts of her that he didn’t like or ignore them altogether. With Finn, Rachel becomes a shell of her former self, but with Puck, she could be herself and not worry about whether or not she was good enough for him if she was her authentic self. Puck and Rachel could be themselves around each other and felt safe enough with the other to completely let their guards down.
Do you know how rare it is to find someone who likes you for you in high school, platonically or romantically?
Ryan Murphy, Ian Brennan and Brad Falchuk missed a golden opportunity to tell a high school love story with great potential for the future, where two people accepted each other for who they are and were not afraid to be themselves with each other. A healthy relationship where there was trust and loyalty on both sides, as well as never expecting the other person to change who they were to fit the mould of the person their partner wanted. Puck may have cared about his popularity at the start of Season 1, but that changed as his character grew and evolved, while Finn stayed mostly the same, and his popularity was always more of a priority for him. This is shown in his relationships with Rachel and Kurt in Season 2 when he didn’t defend Rachel against Santana and Brittany’s bullying or stand up to Karofsky when the latter was terrorizing Kurt and making his life a living hell.
What’s more, I found Finn to be very selfish because he could never make up his mind between Quinn and Rachel; he toyed with both of them and only wanted them when they were with someone else. He was also hypocritical in the fact that he became angry with Quinn and Rachel for cheating on him with the same guy a season apart, but a few episodes later in Season 2, he encourages Quinn to cheat on Sam with him, even knowing full well how much it sucks to be on the receiving end of the cheating.
When Rachel was with Puck, he was fully devoted to her with no ulterior motives (Finn, Jesse), and I honestly believe that had the writers decided to give a romantic relationship between Puck and Rachel a real shot, Puck would have been all in with her in a heartbeat.
Both Lea Michele and the late Mark Salling expressed their thoughts about the relationship between their characters, with Lea noting that Puck and Rachel can relate to each other because they’re going through the same thing with wanting to forget Finn and Quinn, who share the common denominator of not wanting people (in this case, Puck and Rachel) until they’re unavailable. Mark piped in that he had hope for a further exploration of their relationship, stating, “I like that dynamic myself.”
Here are some of the reasons I liked Puck for Rachel:
- When she said she couldn’t be with someone who wasn’t brave enough to sing a solo in glee club, Puck rose to the challenge and not only sang his first-ever solo, he dedicated it to Rachel and showed that he had leading man potential and that he could handle her big personality.
A few minutes later…
2. He apologized to her for the slushies: Before they both joined the glee club, Puck was one of Rachel’s biggest tormentors and regularly threw slushies at her. During their short-lived relationship, the tables turned, and he had one thrown in his face. When Puck was slushied, he understood how hard it can be for people like Rachel and was regretful that he’d ever done it to her and sincerely apologized to her. For Rachel’s part, she could have laughed and left Puck to deal with the slushie alone, but she chose to stay and help him clean up because she knew what it was like to be on the receiving end of that form of bullying.
3. He picked her and the glee club over football: When Coach Tanaka issued an ultimatum to the football players who were in the glee club that forced them to choose between being on the football team and being in the glee club, Puck was originally going to choose football. I think the reason he chose the glee club (and Rachel) was because for the first time, he didn’t have to be just another football player; he could be himself in glee club, and he had someone who believed in him and recognized his potential. He loved football, but he loved music and playing guitar too.
4. He’s the first one to come to Rachel’s defense: When someone is being mean to Rachel, Puck is the first one to step up and defend her. In Season 1, when Jesse and Vocal Adrenaline egged Rachel, Puck was the angriest member of New Directions and was ready to defend her honour even though they weren’t together at that point. Side note: I don’t understand the writers putting Rachel and Jesse back together in the sixth and final season or how they wrote him taking her to her junior prom. If it had been me that was egged by an ex-boyfriend and then he came crawling back, I would have told him to take a hike.
In Season 2, when Santana spitefully reveals that she and Finn slept together the previous year, Puck is the only member of the Glee club to show genuine concern for Rachel and ask her if she’s okay.
A few scenes later, at Sectionals, Puck again shows that he genuinely cares about Rachel when he is the lone member to say that he likes Rachel while everyone else stands by and watches Santana talk down to her.
Although it’s unknown if Puck meant that he liked Rachel platonically or romantically, I’m going with the second one because of how he treated her after they broke up. There were lots of little hints that there was an attraction between them.
The relationship between Puck and Rachel is a classic what-could-have-been scenario, and it’s sad that while the fans aboard the Puckleberry ship saw the potential of a romantic relationship between these two, the writers and Ryan Murphy never did. Instead, they opted for toxic, unhealthy relationships where the messages were “If the person you’re in a relationship with doesn’t like you for you, change yourself so they will” and “Never mind that this guy was manipulating you the whole time you were together and then when you were broken up, he literally threw an egg on your face, he matches your musical talent so everything’s good!”
That’s it for this week! Enjoy your weekend, dear readers!
Until next week, xoxo
Created with ❤️ By Lauren