The Ethical Biases of AI: A Call To Action

Written By: Lauren Long

Date Published: June 13, 2025

Photo by ThisIsEngineering on Pexels.com

“The sad thing about artificial intelligence is that it lacks artifice and therefore intelligence.” ~Jean Baudrillard.

When it comes to Artificial Intelligence (AI), there are pros and cons to each side. In the pros column are higher efficiency, task automation and enhanced improvement, while on the con side are job displacement, ethical biases, and information concealment risks. Goldman Sachs has estimated that 300 million jobs could be lost to artificial intelligence, which is 25% of the global labour market.

  This is concerning, but equally concerning are the ethical biases that come into play. Every time we share something online, we run the risk of it being stolen and utilized for an individual’s own agenda without our consent. My mom has told me about an artist who posted her work to Instagram, only to have it stolen by individuals who put it on T-shirts, cushion covers and other material goods and sold it as their own work, denying her the credit and recognition that is rightfully hers.

  I’ve seen pole dancers post about having their videos taken and intercut with other footage without their permission, with the added footage being irrelevant to the content of the original video.

  What kind of world are we living in where there are individuals who take the work we have spent hours on and poured our hearts and souls into and repost it to other sites while taking credit for something we have created?

  One of my Instagram book pals who creates content for series such as Rebecca Yarros’ Empyrean and Sarah J. Maas’s A Court of Thorns and Roses and Throne of Glass, along with other digital content creators, has had people take her images and pass them off as their own all the time. When she messaged them, they straight-up denied any wrongdoing on their part, and there is nothing I loathe more than people who refuse to take responsibility for their actions, no matter what the context is.

  At the beginning of this year, I was notified on the Discord server for Fate: The Winx Saga that a few of my Fate: The Winx Saga fanfictions had been stolen, translated and published to another website without my knowledge or permission, and had been on the site since July 2024. Several other authors were also targeted, sadly, all of them were no strangers to having their work stolen, but this was the first time it had happened to me.

  As annoying as it was, the situation was resolved quickly when all authors affected by the theft reached out to the site’s support team and proved that we authors on Archive Of Our Own (AO3), were the original authors and had not agreed to having our works translated and republished elsewhere.

 I wish I could say that that was the first and last time that’s happened, but unfortunately, this is not the case.

  On April 20, 2025, an individual by the screenname of nyuuzyou scraped Archive of Our Own, stealing 12.6 million works that were available to the public. Seven of my stories were among that number, while other authors on the Discord server had all of their works stolen, even those that were locked and not accessible to the public. Three days later, on April 23rd, DMCA takedown notices were issued, with nyuuzyou filing a counterclaim to the notices. But his thievery didn’t stop with Archive Of Our Own.

  On May 2, 2025, the website fanlore reported nyuuzyou’s scrape, citing the website PaperDemon’s original announcement that nyuuzyou had stolen artwork and writings from seven websites to train AI bots on the machine-learning platform HuggingFace.

  PaperDemon reported that from its site alone, 49,382 artworks and 2,950 written pieces were scraped by nyuuzyou.

  Users who have had their works stolen have rightfully expressed their anger, calling nyuuzyou out for their thievery and profiteering from our works, but we are not, because it is fan work.

  A Reddit user says, “I want to bitch at him on his stupid website, but I refuse to make an account on his dumb-ass website ☹☹ this guy knows it’s illegal. He doesn’t care he’s threatening the future of fanfiction.”

   Another victim of nyuuzyou’s thievery went on HuggingFace to openly express their displeasure under the alias AO3userwhoisnothappy and had this to say: “You’re waking the sleeping giant by publishing an AO3 scrape here. Fandom is VIOLENTLY anti-AI right now. Expect to be fighting DMCA takedown notices for the next century because once word gets out, everyone and their brother is going to be coming for this data. When fandom gets mad about something … ask app developers that try and make a profit off the archive. This isn’t a threat, honest, this is “Are you sure you know what you’re in for once this gets into the general fandom zeitgeist?”

 I offered the writers on the Discord server the opportunity to give their own statement, and my good friend @IDreamofRoses agreed. This is her opinion: “If you’re asking me, GenAI has no place in any field of art. Art is a reflection of the human soul, something you feel and need to let it out. AI, in this situation, is a thief. Imagine creating something – a painting or a few simple paragraphs – putting in the hours, your emotions, and then having someone pass by it, like it, and take it from you, just because “I can’t draw/write”.

I am beyond tired of listening to this sentence as a pitiful excuse for people’s lack of creativity. I can’t cook to save my life, but you don’t see me going around stealing my friends or my mom’s dishes and saying, “Yeah, I made that.” It’s pitiful and a very sad reflection of humanity and where we’re going as a race.

Don’t get me wrong, AI is here and it is the future. It helps in so many fields, but here’s the thing – NOT IN ART. What happened recently (yet again, sadly) with AO3’s works – yeah, I’m looking at you nyuuzyou – is a disgrace. People have added hours, days, weeks, months, years of their life into creating something FOR FREE so everyone can enjoy, and you decided to steal because what, “I can’t write”? Saying “Shame on you” is the nicest thing I can say to you. And to the other people who said that it’s needed to develop AI further, hell no. Stealing is not the ground on which we should be building the future. Ask for permission before you take something – weren’t you taught this? If not, I pity you.

Drawings, books, fanfics… Whatever art it is, AI shouldn’t go near it – not unless you get specific permission. So next time, fucking ask and if you get a no, it’s a fucking no.

As someone who enjoys both writing and drawing, I am not giving permission for AI to use any of them. And if I see it, be very certain I will use every legal measure I have to get my creations back to where they came from.

To put it in the nicest way I can, shame on you, nyuuzyou, shame on those who supported you in the comments and on social media, and shame on the many more who view this as something we need to do. I have a lot more I want to say, but let’s keep it civil. Just remember the words of one of the greatest creators in the whole world (it applies to writing as well), Hayao Miyazaki:
“AI-generated animation is an insult to life itself.”

I was given my writing confidence back by writing fanfiction. Therefore, I am strongly against anyone who takes my writing and passes it off as though they share credit for the ideas I came up with, or, as nyuuzyou has done, uses the works crafted by artists and writers alike to train AI bots.

  As described by Lev Grossman, fanfiction is “what literature might look like if it were reinvented from scratch after a nuclear apocalypse by a band of brilliant pop-culture junkies trapped in a sealed bunker. They don’t do it for money. That’s not what it’s about. The writers write it and put it up online just for the satisfaction. They’re fans, but they’re not silent, couch-bound consumers of media. The culture talks to them, and they talk back to the culture in its own language.”

  Lev is among those authors who are in favour of fanfiction. While some authors out there are against it and have respectfully requested that fans don’t create fanfiction with their works, here are some quotes from authors who are not against it, recognizing the value of fanfiction and the positive impact it has on a writer’s self-esteem and skillset.

 “Fanfiction is the madwoman in mainstream culture’s attic, but the attic won’t contain it forever. Writing and reading fanfiction isn’t just something you do; it’s a way of thinking critically about the media you consume, of being aware of all the implicit assumptions that a canonical work carries with it, and of considering the possibility that those assumptions might not be the only way things have to be.” ~Anne Jamison, Author of Fic: Why Fanfiction Is Taking Over the World.

  “I think that all writing is useful for honing writing skills. I think you get better as a writer by writing, and whether that means that you’re writing a singularly deep and moving novel about the pain or pleasure of modern existence or you’re writing Smeagol-Gollum slash you’re still putting one damn word after another and learning as a writer.” ~Neil Gaiman, Author of American Gods.

 “The difference between fanfic and a ‘real’ novel is that fanfic is honest about its inspiration.” ~Mary Robinette Kowal, Author of The Calculating Stars.

  “The whole point of fanfiction is that you get to play inside somebody else’s universe. Rewrite the rules. Or bend them. The story doesn’t have to end. You can stay in this world, this world you love, as long as you want, as long as you keep thinking of new stories.” ~Rainbow Rowell, Author of Wayward Son.

 “Fanfiction is important because it gives many newbie authors a chance to stretch their wings, usually in a safe space. And this is especially true for younger, queer writers who’re trying to see themselves in a piece of fiction/media, but can’t do so with what’s considered canon. We’re here, we’re queer, but we’re constantly surrounded by depictions of cishet people where queer characters are relegated to side characters, some of which are still problematic to this day.” ~TJ Klune, Author of The Extraordinaries.

 I hope that this article will spark a larger conversation about the use of AI in today’s society and help people to think critically about whether or not the cons I mentioned at the beginning outweigh the pros.

Links For More Information:

Search Tool to see the magnitude of the AO3 scrape: https://app.powerbi.com/view?r=eyJrIjoiYzJkY2QyOTAtYmZiNS00YzJkLWJiMjEtOGU3MDQ0OTJjOTFiIiwidCI6ImExMzA3OTQ5LWVlMGItNDIzNy1iMDI5LTU0ODIwYmU0ODA4NSIsImMiOjF9&pageName=47a4e46a31aa730a63d0

Fanlore: Theft of Fanworks Perpetrated By nyuuzyou: https://fanlore.org/wiki/Theft_of_Fanworks_Perpetrated_by_nyuuzyou

nyuuzyou’s HuggingFace account: https://huggingface.co/posts/nyuuzyou/318268301919621

nyuuzyou’s X account: https://x.com/nyuuzyou?lang=en

  That’s it for now.

  Thanks for reading.

  Until next week, xoxo 

  Created with Love and Awareness by Lauren

Leave a Comment