Popularity & Social Status: Alpha Males and Queen Bees in Television

Written By: Lauren Long

Date Published: June 20, 2025

Photo by Myicahel Tamburini on Pexels.com

“It’s immortality my darlings.” ~Alison DiLaurentis, Pretty Little Liars

The following is a paper that I wrote for one of my university classes, Special Topics in Film and Television: UK. I examine the personalities of three teens who are leaders of their social groups: Skins’ Tony Stonem, Pretty Little Liars’ Alison DiLaurentis, and Gossip Girl’s Blair Waldorf. One alpha male and two Queen Bees.

  When we are at the adolescent stage of our lives, having a high social status is important. Our popularity plays a major role in our social identity and our peers’ perception of us. However, being part of the cool clique comes at a price: your every move, as well as every word that comes out of your mouth, is being scrutinized.

  One wrong decision or seemingly innocent sentence can demote you from the top of the social hierarchy and send you crashing down to the bottom. Three television shows that illustrate this are Bryan Elsley and Jamie Brittain’s Skins, I. Marlene King’s Pretty Little Liars, based on Sara Shepard’s book series, and finally Stephanie Savage and Josh Schwartz’s drama/romance Gossip Girl, based on Cecily von Ziegesar’s book series. Skins Tony Stonem (Nicholas Hoult), Pretty Little Liars Alison DiLaurentis (Sasha Pieterse), and Gossip Girl’s Blair Waldorf (Leighton Meester) are their respective social groups’ leaders and possess the qualities of intelligence, good looks and fashion sense, all must-haves for a popular young adult.

  They believe they are the right people to lead their group of friends. The social status of Tony, Allison and Blair is supported by visuals, their words, and the technique of manipulation, which they use to control their friends and family.  While these three teenagers are the ringleaders of their friend groups, does one of them actually have a soft side beneath the devious and manipulative exterior that they put forth?

     Bryan Elsley and Jamie Brittain created the TV show Skins. Tony Stonem is introduced in the pilot episode “Tony,” which aired on January 25, 2007.  The first visual of Tony that we see is him waking up in the morning with his duvet cover pulled right up to his chin. The duvet has two naked bodies on it, the back of a man and the front of a woman. This image tells us Tony is obsessed with sex and alerts the audience that he is not your average teenager. 

   The visual that portrays Tony’s social status occurs when he walks out of his house and immediately gets on his cell phone and begins to call his circle of friends. Tony phones everyone and puts some friends on hold while he talks to others, clearly illustrating that he is the instigator of conversations, the organizer of group social events and his friends do his bidding.  It is revealed that Tony has made plans for his best friend, Sid Jenkins (Mike Bailey), to lose his virginity at a party they have been invited to.

     At the school cafe, Tony explains to Sid that while at the party they will get a girl “catastrophically spiffed up, and in her confused state, however momentarily, she’ll think you’re good enough to shag.”  This statement shows Tony’s immorality and lack of compassion for those around him, as well as his feeling that Sid is beneath him. Tony feels compelled to help Sid lose his virginity, as he is seventeen years old and they cannot be friends if Sid is still a virgin. Not exactly a judgment that a good friend, much less a best friend, would make. The visual nicely portrays Tony’s social status as the alpha male and makes his beliefs clear. In his article “Characterization as Social Cognition in Welcome to the Dollhouse,” Michael Z. Newman states that:

            One key aspect of characterization is the construction of character psychology, the attribution of mental states to fictional representations (including intentional states such as beliefs and desires), personality traits that refer to psychological characteristics, and affect states such as moods and emotions” (53). 

   This certainly describes Tony’s character; his desire for Sid’s deflowering depicts his belief that, because he is not a virgin, Sid should not be one either. The visuals of Tony’s bedspread, talking on his cell phone, and describing his plan for Sid to have sexual intercourse for the first time, all cement his leader status.

  Pretty Little Liars Alison DiLaurentis is the ‘It Girl’, the ‘Queen Bee’, and leader of her social group.

   The Pretty Little Liars pilot episode aired on June 8, 2010. Alison makes her first appearance when she jumps through the door of Spencer Hastings’ (Troian Bellisario) barn and says “Gotcha!” thus scaring Spencer, Aria Montgomery (Lucy Hale), Emily Fields (Shay Mitchell), and Hanna Marin (Ashley Benson). As the girls rebuke her for scaring them, the wind blows Alison’s hair around her face, and she confidently walks into the barn, sashaying her hips and shaking her blonde hair over her shoulders. Her body language, including her smug smile, supports her image as Queen Bee and depicts that she knows she is the leader and the girls are her followers. Unfortunately, this is the last time the audience sees Alison alive because it is on this night that she disappears, and her body is found a year later.

     Part of the visual that supports Alison’s image as the Queen Bee includes her appearance in this scene. She wears a yellow ruffled top that shows off her toned chest, skinny jeans, a silver necklace that falls to her midsection, and large silver hoop earrings. Her hair is curled and falls perfectly around her. This image portrays Alison’s confidence and indicates that she is the Queen Bee. Alison, Aria, Emily, Hanna, and Spencer are beautiful, which elevates their social status because physical attractiveness plays a huge role in popularity. The more beautiful a girl is, the higher her chances of being accepted into the popular clique.                      

However, beauty also has a downside to it. If a young woman is stunningly beautiful, the clique’s other female members often feel threatened by her beauty and her resulting confidence.  In her article, “Social Status and Shaming Experiences Related to Adolescent Overt Aggression at School,” Cecelia Âslund says that: “A person with high social status who experiences social threat may be more inclined to aggression in order to defend his/her social position and status – related privileges” (2).

   This definitely describes Alison’s character. There is no line she will not cross to ensure her status as Queen Bee, and she does not hesitate to destroy anyone whom she perceives as a threat. Another example of her superior social status is shown in Season 1’s second episode, “The Jenna Thing.”  Emily is in her room with Maya St. Germain (Bianca Lawson), who has moved into Alison’s old house, and Alison’s body was discovered in the backyard of her former residence. Maya picks up a framed photograph of Hanna, Spencer, Alison, Aria and Emily and observes that Alison was always in the middle, the center of attention. This further supports Alison having a prominent social status, by being in the center, she is shown to be the most popular of the five girls, and she never lets them forget it. Maya tells Emily that instead of joining the popular groups, she runs away because the Queen Bees scare her.

   Queen Bees scare everyone, but they also draw people to them and those who hold lower social status desire to be in the ‘in crowd’. Less popular people want to be part of the ‘in crowd’ for its protection as opposed to being the recipient of its wrath. This is shown in Gossip Girl, where Blair Waldorf expresses that she is the Queen Bee when she hosts the Kiss on the Lips party.

       Gossip Girl’s Blair Waldorf is one of Manhattan’s elite. The first episode of the series aired on September 19, 2007.  Blair’s elite social status is illustrated in a visual that has her sitting on the steps of the Met, flanked by Kati Farkas (Nan Zhang) and Isabel Coates (Nicole Fiscella). Jenny Humphrey (Taylor Momsen) is giving Blair the invitations that she addressed for the Kiss on the Lips party. We learn that someone in Jenny’s art class saw her calligraphy and told her that if she addressed all the invitations that she could have one. Sticking to the deal, Blair hands Jenny her invitation. By doing this, Blair shows that she can keep a bargain, which is essential for her to keep her Queen Bee status. If a popular person makes a promise but then breaks it soon after, eventually, over time, people will realize that they cannot trust that person. Slowly, the individual’s popular status will fade away into nothing, and they will always be viewed as the person who cannot keep a promise.

      In their article “’ Life is A Tightrope’: Reflections on Peer Group Inclusion and Exclusion Amongst Adolescent Girls and Boys,” Molly Warrington and Mike Younger describe popularity as: “Being ‘part of the in-crowd,’ sustaining an image which allows integration and inclusion with peers who are valued and esteemed, adopting behaviour, dress and roles which are fashionable and conform to the latest trends, are all crucially important to young people” (153).  This describes Jenny, who is on the outside looking in, but with the favourable reception that she received from Blair, Kati, and Isabel for successfully completing the invitations, she has been integrated into the popular group. This is usually how popular girls work: they give an outsider a task to complete, and if the chosen candidate completes the task well and gains the approval of the clique, they are in; if they do not, they continue being outsiders.

      The visuals of Tony, Alison, and Blair’s characters all exhibit their personalities and how they operate.  In his article, Newman states: “Characters are products of social cognition, the human propensity for making sense of others. However, they are also products of artists who fashion them to appeal to our nature as human beings” (53). This observation is accurate, and the audience, when seeing characters on television, can take their body language and facial expressions and speech into consideration and apply it to their everyday lives as they observe others around them. Tony, Alison, and Blair all fit this character description because they are what every young man and woman wants to be: popular, confident, assertive, and physically attractive in stylish clothes which declare their wealth. The next contributing factor to the social status of these characters is their words.

    Tony further demonstrates his social status as an alpha male when he is talking to Sid’s voicemail, which tells him that Sid is either asleep or too bored to talk to him. Tony responds with “You’re a lazy turd, Sid, we have plans remember? Concerning your cock? Ring me.” He then rings Chris Miles (Joe Dempsie) and gets his voicemail, leading Tony to derogatory name-calling of Sid and Chris. Tony, Sid and Chris use the ‘F’ word frequently, and Warrington and Younger address this in their article, saying:

            Inclusion thus demands certain behaviours, language, attitudes, which are linked with being ‘normal’ girl or boy, involving actively engaging in hegemonic heterosexual identities and relations . . . To not ‘go with the crowd,’ to resist the mainstream, is a hazardous activity, with high risks of social exclusion rarely taken except by the eccentric, the very strong-minded or the significantly different” (153-154).

      If Sid and Chris did not use this language, it is quite likely that they would be excluded from their social group. Similarly, if Tony did not follow the expected standards of an adolescent male, he would be at the bottom of the social food chain. When Warrington and Younger say that not following the rest of the popular crowd is a risky action, they are quite right.  If one chooses to travel their own path, there is a very good chance that they will be excluded from parties and other social gatherings that the popular crowd will be attending. 

     In Alison’s case, while she may not use the crass language that Tony and his friends use on Skins, she gets her message across: it is her way or the highway.

    Alison’s words expose her naturally nasty and manipulative nature. In “The Jenna Thing,” the girls are trying on clothes in Emily’s room when Alison bursts out with, “I see you!” She marches over to the window and glares out of it while informing the girls that Toby Cavanaugh (Keegan Allen), Emily’s neighbour, was spying on them. Aria asks if they should tell somebody, and Alison says that they could, only for a devilish smile to appear as she says, “But I have a better idea.”  Fireworks explode in the sky, cleverly foreshadowing Alison’s idea.

  She plans to throw a stink bomb into Toby’s garage to teach him a lesson. She says, with a disdainful look, “Who knows what he does in there all day, the little freak?”  Aria, Hanna, Spencer and Emily are all reluctant to go through with the stunt and ask if Alison is sure that it was Toby that she saw. Alison is adamant and replies that he is not in the garage and expresses her frustration by saying, “Yes, and it’s a stink bomb for God’s sakes, we’re not nuking the place, now let’s do it!”  Spencer hesitantly gives Alison the lighter, and she lights the bomb and throws it into the garage. However, she is mistaken. Jenna Marshall (Tammin Sursok), Toby’s step-sister, is inside the garage. Consequently, Jenna is blinded, and therefore the episode title is “The Jenna Thing.”

   Unfortunately, when it comes to popularity, we do not stop to think about the consequences of our actions whilst seeking revenge. In their article “It’s Not Just Being Popular, It’s Knowing It Too: The Role of Self–Perceptions of Status in the Associations between Peer Status and Aggression,” Lara Mayeux and Antonius Cillessen state that:

            It is possible that popular adolescents who are aware of their status understand the protective nature of it, and feel free to aggress against others because they know that they are unlikely to be censured. These youth may even enjoy the opportunity to aggress against peers that have slighted or upset them (or challenged their ‘authority’), because it reinforces their feelings of social power in the peer group” (884). 

   This completely describes Alison who enjoyed the idea of getting revenge on Toby, but she did not show concern when it was revealed that Jenna had been badly injured. She did not like Jenna or Toby, but especially Jenna, because she quickly became popular after moving to Rosewood. When Alison invited her to join her group of friends, Jenna declined, displaying her confidence and strength of character.

   Blair’s verbal expressions showcase her character as well, but she does not resort to actions that cause people physical harm.

   In Gossip Girl’s pilot episode, Blair finds out from her boyfriend, Nate Archibald (Chace Crawford), that the previous summer he had slept with Serena van der Woodsen (Blake Lively), upon her return from boarding school in Connecticut. Nate picked the wrong moment to tell Blair because not only was she planning on giving her virginity to him, but earlier that evening, Blair and Serena had met and rekindled their friendship. Nate destroyed this reunion when he revealed to Blair his and Serena’s infidelity to her. An angry, heartbroken Blair tells him to leave as she falls onto her bedroom floor sobbing. The words spoken show that Blair is in touch with her feelings and is not afraid to cry in front of people who have hurt her. In the article “A Typology of Retaliation Strategies against Social Aggression among Adolescent Girls,” it is stated that:  Clique exclusivity, glares, ignoring, eye-rolling, high-profile conflict creation, and manipulation are all tactics girls will employ to elevate and maintain their places in the hierarchy” (114).

      This is exactly what Blair does after Serena’s deception is revealed; she glares at her, ignores her, and singles Serena out for showing up at the Kiss on the Lips party uninvited.  Along with the images and words said by Tony, Alison, and Blair, their social status is further proven by their talent for manipulating others to do what they want.

    Every single morning, Tony manipulates his father so that he can help his younger sister, Effy (Kaya Scodelario), sneak back into the house after she has been out all night partying. Tony purposefully blasts his music so that his father comes in to yell at him, thus giving Effy enough time to get into the house and up to her room undetected. Tony also directs his girlfriend, Michelle Richardson (April Pearson), to help plan the loss of Sid’s virginity, even going so far as to cruelly kiss Michelle in front of Sid, who is in love with her.

    In her article “Effects of Popularity and Gender on Peers’ Perceptions of Prosocial, Antisocial, and Jealousy – Eliciting Behaviours,” Lara Mayeux states that there is: “Two distinct types of popular peer: one that is both popular and well accepted (prosocial – popular) and another that is popular but disliked (populistic). Prosocial – popular peers were viewed as sociable, kind, and academically engaged. Populistic peers were viewed as antisocial (aggressive, antiauthority), arrogant, and highly influential” (351-352). Tony is a mixture of the two. He is prosocial when interacting with his friends’ parents, and is populistic towards his friends, especially Sid whom he sends to a brothel to buy drugs for the party.

   Alison portrays her manipulative ways even further in the third episode titled “To Kill a Mocking Girl” through a flashback.  

   Season 1’s third episode, “To Kill a Mocking Girl,” aired on June 22, 2010. While at a party, Spencer flashes back to seeing Alison confronting Toby. When Alison threatens and blackmails Toby into taking the blame for the fire, her body language of arms folded across her chest and leaning forward slightly shows that she has the upper hand, while Toby’s arms hang limply at his sides.

    A few minutes later, after Hanna, Aria, and Emily have expressed their concern about Jenna and Alison has dismissed it, Hanna tries to stand up to Alison by saying, “What if we said it was an accident, we . . .” Hanna does not get to finish her sentence because Alison angrily cuts her off and insults her by saying, “No! We’re not telling anybody anything! Damn it Hanna, don’t make me sorry I included you in the first place! You know what, I have gone out of my way to bring your big wannabe butt into this group. You better keep your mouth shut, unless you want to go back to spending your weekends alone with Dance Dance Revolution and a jumbo bag of chips!” Aria angrily tells Alison to stop it and leave Hanna alone, who is silently crying. This, along with Alison’s blackmailing of Toby, shows her cruelty, selfishness, and manipulation. Instead of handling the situation maturely when she allegedly saw Toby spying and calling the police, as suggested, she chose to throw a bomb into his garage and then blackmailed him into taking the blame. In her article “Aggressive and Social Behaviours in within Early Adolescent Friendship Cliques: What’s Status Got To Do With It?” Leanna M. Closson describes:

            Dominant children and adolescents tend to use one of three strategies of resource control:             prosocial (e.g., reciprocity, cooperation, persuasion, and helping behaviors), coercive        (e.g. aggression, manipulation, deception, insults, or threats), or bistrategic (i.e., the use of either prosocial or coercive strategies depending on what would bring the most success given the context of the situation)” (410).  

     Alison uses the coercive resource control strategy when she forces the girls to go along with her plan of scaring Toby and threatening him to take the blame when it goes horribly wrong.  Alison fits the mean girl definition perfectly: she has the face of an angel, but she has the soul of a devil and the cunning of a snake.

      Blair, on the other hand, has a conscience and feels guilty when she does something wrong.

      Blair manipulates Serena in “Poison Ivy,” which aired on October 3, 2007, when she wrongfully reveals that Serena is a recovering drug addict and a patient at the Ostroff Treatment Center at the Ivy League mixer. However, it is not Serena who is a patient at the Ostroff Center, but her younger brother Eric, who was brought there after he attempted suicide by slitting his wrists. When confronted by Eric, Blair regrets her attempt to get back at Serena for sleeping with Nate.  Earlier in the episode, Blair and Serena have a physical altercation during field hockey. In “A Typology of Retaliation Strategies against Social Aggression among Adolescent Girls,” it is stated that:

            Girls respond to peer attacks of indirect social aggression in various ways . . . Strategies include truth coalition, face – to – face confrontation, faux confrontation, cancelling the friendship, gossip, cold shoulder, physical violence, rumours, nonverbal cues, picking teams, and specialized torture” (113).

        Blair employs gossip and rumour strategies to control her friends and seek revenge against her enemies. It is only after Eric rightfully shames her and tells her the truth that Blair feels remorseful for her actions and finds Serena in Central Park, which is where Serena goes when something is bothering her. Blair then reads a letter that she wrote but never sent while Serena was away at boarding school. The letter reveals how much Blair misses and needs Serena, her best friend, because her world is falling apart. As Blair reads the letter aloud, her voice cracks and her eyes fill with tears, showing her sensitive and vulnerable side, which only those closest to her get to see.

      Skins Tony Stonem, Pretty Little Liars Alison DiLaurentis, and Gossip Girl’s Blair Waldorf are the ringleaders of their social groups. They illustrate their social status with visuals, lines, and the technique of manipulation. These characters always look good and put a noticeable amount of time and effort into their appearance. However, while Blair is manipulative and conniving like Tony and Alison, she is the more conscientious of the three as she is able to admit when she is wrong, she is courteous enough to apologize to people she hurts, and will mend the broken pieces of a friendship, just as she did with Serena in Poison Ivy. Tony and Alison, on the other hand, are shown to be cruel and put their own needs above the wellbeing of others. Their characters are controlling, insensitive, and without conscience in their interactions with their peers. Alison and Tony both need to learn lessons in humility as well as how to interact with others without having ulterior motives.

Leave a Comment