Forgiveness and Second Chances: The Mistake

Written By: Lauren Long

Date Published: December 3, 2025

Photo by Shamasana on Pexels.com

“I need you. I can’t stand the thought of being without you.” He releases a shaky breath. “You’re the last person I think about before I go to sleep, and the first person I think about when I open my eyes in the morning. You’re it for me, baby.” ~Elle Kennedy, The Mistake

  Hello, dear readers, and Happy Wednesday! We are 28 days away from the end of 2025. How crazy is that?! It feels like the year just flew by!

  Something I’m grateful for is how many new authors and their works I’ve gotten to experience, with some quickly earning a spot on my favourite authors’ list. Elle Kennedy, Sarah J. Maas, and Rebecca Yarros, just to name a few, show a terrific understanding of the human psyche and emotions. In addition to addressing social issues, they use both to create believable, relatable characters and worlds, captivating their readers from start to finish.

 We’re kicking off the December blog posts with The Mistake, the second novel in Elle Kennedy’s Off-Campus series.

 This time around, the couple whose story we’re immersing ourselves in is Grace Ivers and John Logan. Lace up your skates, let’s go! Fair warning, there are a few spoilers here, so if you haven’t read or listened to the book yet, go do that and then come back! 😉

  At the start of the novel, both Grace and John, or Logan as he’s also called, have their own things going on. Grace is a college freshman, she’s living away from home for the first time, and she’s struggling to find herself and her own identity. Meanwhile, John is hiding the truth about his family life and the reality of his homelife behind his charm and easygoing persona. Once they collide, their lives become entwined unavoidably, changing them both forever.

 The themes explored in the books are alcoholism, yearning, betrayal/backstabbing by a friend, and second chances.

  With the theme of alcoholism, Elle explores what it’s like to have a family member who is addicted to alcohol and the impact that it has on other family members. She looks at how this disease can break down a marriage, how the kids have to grow up too fast, and how, sometimes, there’s a dead-end road ahead of the kids because they choose to sacrifice what they want to take care of their family member addicted to drink and keep a roof over their heads. Before I read this book, I had never really thought about the impact alcoholism would have on a family and their daily lives. That’s another thing I love about Elle Kennedy: her books make me think and shift my world views for the better.

 Theme #2 is the betrayal/backstabbing of a friend. We’ve all been here! Grace’s friendship with Ramona, her “friend” since Grade 1, is very manipulative. There’s a character I dislike in every book I read, and in The Mistake, it was Ramona. I found her to be super annoying, and the fact that she was controlling of Grace didn’t warm me to her at all. In my opinion, Ramona is very selfish. She wants Grace to hang out with her friends because she deems them cool enough to hang out with. She doesn’t want Grace to have friends outside of her and the people she hangs out with, which we see when she tells Grace outright that she doesn’t want to hang out with Grace’s classmates because, to her, they’re boring.

 Ramona’s inability to keep her mouth shut leads to Grace being the subject of gossip and the victim of an online smear campaign, and a thoughtless move by Ramona is the final straw for Grace’s tolerance, where their friendship is concerned. Her annoyance with Ramona has been building for awhile; her impatience with Ramona’s tools of “Forgive Me” hugs and crocodile tears, which Ramona uses to keep Grace in the metaphorical cage, finally comes to a head when Grace realizes that she can’t trust Ramona. I was cheering when Grace made the decision she did and that she stood strong despite her old friend’s many attempts at contact.

 I connected to Grace in this way because I’ve been stabbed in the back by people I thought were friends and when I was younger, I made it easy for people to manipulate me. I think no matter what stage of life we’re in, there’s a possibility of betrayal from people we thought were friends. What matters is how we choose to act during the betrayal and in its aftermath.

 Finally, yearning and second chances. Actually, yearning has two sides: it’s both a theme and a character device for the protagonists. John wants what Garrett and Hannah, who were the couple in The Deal, have. He yearns for the kind of relationship they have, where there is care and respect and love, as well as having a partner who is willing to call him out when needed. Grace’s yearning is to be more autonomous and to have a circle of friends with whom she genuinely connects and enjoys spending time.

  As far as second chances are concerned, they’re worth it for some people and not for others. When we’ve been hurt by someone, we can be very reluctant to give them a second chance. Grace is reluctant to be with John, and she doesn’t give in at first, but he works relentlessly to win her heart, prove that he’s worthy of another chance and that he’s serious about her and them being a real couple.

  What are your experiences with second chances?

   Thanks for reading!

   Until Friday, xoxo

   Created with ♥️ By Lauren

Leave a Comment